National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η κατανόηση της μαθηματικής έννοιας του συνόλου απο μαθητές των τρίων σχολικών βαθμίδων και μελλοντικούς εκπαιδευτικούς
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe concept of a set is fundamental in mathematics, as “almost every other branch of mathematics relies on set theory as part of its foundation, so it is important to get at least some grounding in set theory before doing other advanced areas of mathematics.” (Tao, 2016). In school mathematics, most concepts are approached without direct reference to the concept of a set. However, the concept of a set is used in various contexts, sometimes inconsistently, resulting in students developing misconceptions (Fischbein & Baltsan, 1998).According to Cantor, “by the word ‘set’ we mean any collection into a whole of definite and distinct objects of our intuition or our thought” (Moschovakis, 1993). Intuitively, we perceive a set as a well-defined collection of distinct objects. In the Greek language, the word ‘set’ is used not only to indicate a collection but also to denote the sum or the number of objects in a collection. Mathematical discourse, including vocabulary, often involves extending or modifying the usage of everyday words, while the development of mathematical discourse should incorporate the integration of everyday language into mathematical discourse (Barwell, 2013).In this dissertation, we investigate the conceptions of primary and secondary education students, as well as prospective teachers, regarding the set concept and the potential influence of the everyday use of the word ‘set’ on the understanding of the set concept. Our research questions are: (a) how do students of different school levels and prospective teachers understand the concept of set, relations between sets, and equivalence between infinite sets, and (b) how is the understanding of the concept of set influenced by the social context? In the first stage of the research, we designed a questionnaire based on the literature (Fischbein & Baltsan, 1998; Tirosh & Tsamir, 1996; Bagni, 2006). The questionnaire was administered to 116 sixth-grade students, 127 ninth-grade students, and 154 twelfth-grade students from various schools in Greece. Subsequently, the questionnaire was given to 245 students – prospective teachers of the Department of Primary Education of Democritus University of Thrace, who had been taught basic concepts and operations of Set Theory within a Foundations of Mathematics course. Our aim was to examine whether misconceptions appear among students that persist despite their systematic engagement with elementary Set Theory. Finally, based on their questionnaire responses, 5 sixth-grade students, 5 ninth-grade students, and 6 twelfth-grade students were selected, and semi-structured, semi-clinical interviews (Elkind, 1964) were conducted to investigate the origin of their perceptions and particularly the influence of different language registers of students (Halliday, 1978).The most common misconceptions among the participants that answered the questionnaire of our study were (1) the perception that the elements of a set should have a common property, (2) the inclusion of indistinct elements in a set, (3) the rejection of the existence of empty sets, (4) the rejection of the existence of singletons, (5) the confusion between equality and equivalence, (6) the confusion of the concepts of belonging and subset, (7) the perception that the number of elements (cardinality) of an infinite set is greater than the number of elements of any proper subset, (8) the perception that infinite sets are incomparable, and (9) the perception that all infinite sets are equivalent. Among students of the three school levels, age seemed to have a positive influence in most cases, but not in all cases. Prospective teachers appeared to have noticeably better results in most questions. However, some of the most prevalent misconceptions observed in students of all three school levels were also observed in prospective teachers. Specifically, the requirement for the elements of a set to have a common property, the confusion between the concepts of belonging and subset, and the perception that infinite sets are incomparable seem to persist despite systematic teaching in Set Theory. Our qualitative analysis revealed that many students, influenced by the use of the term ‘set’ in both the mathematics classroom language register and the everyday language register (Halliday, 1978), appeared to perceive the set as a number rather than a collection, or to have both perceptions simultaneously. Thus, the influence of naming on meaning-making by students becomes apparent (Planas et al., 2022), as well as the need for particular attention from educators at all levels, not only in teaching the concept set of but also in the correct use of the word ‘set’ in the classroom.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vlachos, Ioannis
- Βλάχος, Ιωάννης
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Σύνολο
- Γλωσσικό ιδίωμα
- Νοηματοδότηση
- Παρανόηση
- Μαθηματικά
- Εκπαίδευση
- Set
- Language register
- Meaning making
- Misconception
- Mathematics
- Education
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Μαθηματικά, άλλοι τομείς
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση και Έρευνα της εκπαίδευσης
- Natural Sciences
- Mathematics (miscellaneous)
- Social Sciences
- Education and Educational Research
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/57139