Back to search

University of the Aegean

A taxonomic analysis of the implications of big data analytics for privacy in democratic societies

Abstract

dc:description

In the age of big data, collecting data has become easier than ever before as almost every aspect of our daily routine is quantified. The use of big data techniques has the potential to bring significant benefits in various areas of the public sector, such as healthcare, education, administration, and political participation. However, advances in big data analytics are creating new privacy implications and new threats that challenge current privacy regulations and techniques. Big data technologies enable, for example, the re-identification of data subjects through the use of non-personal data. De-identified data can be combined with external data sets or certain information can be indirectly linked to individuals, making it difficult to clearly distinguish between personal and non-personal data. The impact of big data on privacy has attracted a lot of attention in the media and among researchers. The vast volume and variety of data and the rapid pace of technological development have created a new and complex environment in which the privacy landscape is continuously changing. Manny agree that the complexity of today's data-driven society makes it difficult to effectively deal with privacy threats and their implications. Aiming to contribute to the ongoing discourse, we focused our attention on this area. In recent years, privacy research related to big data technologies has evolved into a multidisciplinary field that encompasses computer science, psychology, philosophy, social sciences, political science, etc. Accordingly, the relevant scientific literature is extensive, complex, and heterogeneous. Therefore, the first step of this research was to conduct a scoping review aiming to provide an overview of the existing findings on the impact of big data on privacy and to identify and analyse gaps and inconsistencies in the knowledge base on privacy in the context of big data. In the initial phase of this study, we focused on the following research question: What is the impact of big data on privacy? The results of the scoping review showed that although the impact of big data on society is a hot topic in research and there is widespread awareness and discussion, the public and political sphere is still the least explored in the literature on privacy in the context of big data. Initially, research on privacy in the context of big data was largely focused on the field of commercial marketing. However, incidents such as the Snowden revelations and the Cambridge Analytica changed the general perception of threats to online privacy to a recognition that privacy threats may originate from the uses of big data for non-commercial goals by governments, political parties, and powerful organizations as well challenging privacy in new ways and with new implications. The role of information seems to be redefined: social media has become a significant source of data for various non-commercial purposes such as e-government, e-health, e-democracy, e-education, and political communication. At the same time governments and powerful organizations can process these data and derive personal information from it without the consent or knowledge of citizens, leading to complex privacy implications. The use of big data analytics by political organizations aimed at targeting political messages and advertising to specific groups of voters has also become increasingly common in recent years, and it appears that these practices are linked to political phenomena such as the rise of populism and authoritarianism. In addition, power asymmetries, where powerful organizations have significant control and influence over personal information compared to citizens, make the privacy landscape even more complex. Recognizing that the privacy issues arising from the use of big data for political purposes have unique characteristics, we have narrowed our research in this direction. Given the fragmented and interdisciplinary nature of the literature and the complexity of the concepts involved (e.g. privacy, big data, big data analytics etc.) in the next step of this research we conducted a systematic literature review across multiple disciplines (computer science, social science, philosophy, political science) following the research question that resulted from the scoping review: What are the privacy threats and implications of using big data technologies for political purposes? First, we identified studies that addressed privacy issues related to the use of big data for e-government initiatives and political goals. In the second phase, we identified open problems and areas not covered by previous research, and we reformulated the original research questions as follows:R.Q.1. What are the privacy threats associated to big data technologies used for political communication, e-government, and e-democracy?R.Q.1.1: Which are the new challenges that big data brought to the privacy debate?R.Q.2: What are the implications of the privacy threats? The third phase of the systematic review resulted in 511 articles that were considered for the analysis and synthesis of the patterns and themes that we found. The purpose of the review was to synthetize the findings to highlight the evidence at a meta-level, to discover areas where further research is needed, to advance knowledge about the privacy threats posed by big data and the implications arising from the use of big data analytics for political communication, e-government, and e-democracy, and to provide a framework/background to position new research activities. In order to gain a comprehensive understanding, we considered it important to start with an analysis of the conceptualization of privacy. Therefore, we analysed and summarized the studies on privacy conceptions and created a taxonomy of privacy conceptualizations. Addressing the first research question (R.Q.1), we proposed a taxonomy of individual privacy threats in relation with surveillance, profiling, aggregation, and predictive big data analytics. In addition, we found that big data analytics challenges on privacy relates to groups rather than individuals. For example, collecting group data or aggregating individuals into group data enables the creation of parameters that can be used to make inferences about individuals and can be used for classification, prediction, and response. Furthermore, predictive decisions can perpetuate existing bias or create new patterns of unfair discrimination against minority or vulnerable groups. Big data analytics are shaping new types of groups that are not included in the categories of groups protected by antidiscrimination policies and practices. Focusing on the social value of privacy, we justified the role and importance of a little researched and discussed concept: group privacy. In addition, we identified types of group privacy, and we proposed a taxonomy of the privacy threats for groups and communities in relation with surveillance, profiling, information gathering, third parties access to gathered information, predictive analytics, gathering geolocation data through location- based services data - driven decision making, aggregation. Our research sheds light on the importance of group privacy in the context of non-commercial big data analytics and confirms concerns related to collective dimensions of privacy, an area that is still in its early stages despite having emerged a decade ago. Group privacy goes beyond individual privacy, as collective identities can be inferred through surveillance practices, which can lead to social divisions and discrimination. Recent studies confirm our findings, indicating a growing recognition of this topic. Furthermore, addressing R.Q.1.1, we concluded that big data technologies bring new and complex challenges. The blurring of boundaries between public and private information, the fact that privacy can be compromised even in the absence of a human actor, the group classification that that may lead to discrimination are some relevant examples. In regard to the second research question (R.Q.2), we identified implications associated with group privacy. For instance, targeting groups for political purposes may contribute to the success of populist movements, groups’ biases are easily reassured and almost never challenged, groups established perceptions and beliefs of groups are accentuated etc. In addition, we identified privacy implications of big data for democratic e-governments and e-democracy concluding that there is a social shift in the long-term effects of privacy. We argued that challenging privacy also calls into question the values reflected in the social and political dimensions of privacy (e.g., equality, fair elections, democratic use of information technologies). We showed that this is particularly evident in situations where powerful entities, including political parties, organizations, and governments, employ big data technologies to achieve their political goals. The implications of such actions can affect society as a whole, not just individuals. For example, tracking techniques used by governments for global surveillance could evolve in social control tools. Also, individuals or groups participation can be influenced or coerced through monetary incentives or other means. This can potentially compromise the authenticity and validity of the results. The impact of such manipulation can be significant, extending beyond just financial considerations. It can affect social and political outcomes as well. For example, if the manipulated results are used to influence political decisions or public opinion, this can have far-reaching consequences for society as a whole. Also, fairness, accuracy, completeness, pluralism of views -characteristics of a democracy may be undermined through personalization. Moreover, surveillance can interfere with freedom and democracy while the gathering of information affects the power dynamic between the observer and the observed, giving the observer more power to influence or direct the object of surveillance. This Thesis confirm concerns that privacy scholars have expressed about the social impact of big data. We showed the interconnections between the political processes in liberal democracies and the privacy threats that may pose barriers in safeguarding fundamental democratic values and we indicated the impact of the privacy threats on society. The proliferation of information and related technologies is changing societal dynamics, with personal data becoming a central resource that not only impacts individuals, but also changes the relationship between governments and citizens. Key players in this landscape include a variety of entities, including government agencies, political institutions, civil society organizations and citizens. While commercial companies are primarily focused on selling products, these actors are more concerned with disseminating ideas and opinions that significantly influence social norms and values. Scientists warn against viewing technology only as a neutral tool and emphasize its broader societal impact. While big data technologies offer potential benefits such as providing accurate information and supporting social initiatives, they also carry threats such as manipulation and propaganda. While manipulation and propaganda are often associated with big data, authors often overlook its direct link to privacy. However, it is important to recognize that manipulation and propaganda are “fueled" with personal information and are therefore inherently linked to privacy threats. Democratic governments in particular face the challenge of protecting social values, as the impact on privacy often defies existing protections. For example, while personalization technologies aim to improve public services, they can unintentionally promote inequality between citizens. By demonstrating how privacy threats intersect with political processes and impede democratic values, this study helps to inform privacy policy and practice.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of the Aegean
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Mavriki, Paola-Viola
  • Μαυρίκη, Πάολα-Βιόλα

Subjects

dc:subject × 21

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/57146

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Mavriki, Paola-Viola; Μαυρίκη, Πάολα-Βιόλα. A taxonomic analysis of the implications of big data analytics for privacy in democratic societies. University of the Aegean, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/57146