Institutes outside Greece
Minority citizen-soldiers, mobilizations & discrimination in the Ottoman Empire and the Kingdom of Greece during the early 20th century
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis dissertation is a comparative, transnational, and relational analysis of the minority citizen-soldiers in the Ottoman and Greek conscript-based armies that served during the Long War (1911–1922), and also engaged in wars against each other. It examines the relationship developed between both states and their minority conscripts and the impact of the continuous wars in this relationship. It analyzes the states’ efforts to link service to citizenship and their policies of inclusion and exclusion of minority conscripts, and also the latter’s reactions and attitudes toward their military and war service. It is also a study of the majority-minority citizen-soldiers relations in the midst of war. The minority and majority citizen soldiers had distinct (but sometimes similar) trajectories in the early phases of the Long War, but by the end of the war they could not relate to one another divergence of experience. This dissertation also explores a group that served as a shared mobilization pool by both states, the Ottoman Greek Orthodox citizen-soldiers, and analyzes their attitudes toward war and the possibility to become Greek citizens. Drawing from grassroots sources such as diaries, memoirs, letters, and oral interviews this dissertation produces a history of the minority citizen-soldiers from below and delves into their experiences, their emotions, and the intricacies of their agency. It argues that the axes of their inclusion and exclusion were determined not only by the way the political leaderships of both states viewed minorities’ conscription but also by war needs. The war revealed the limitations of Ottoman and Greek inclusive nationalisms, and the minority citizen-soldiers, the armed branches of their communities, were the first to witness and fall victim to the ongoing changes. Amid the war, the human landscape of total mobilization gradually became less pluralistic and more segregated, as the homogenization of the army became a matter of state and national security. The war had essentially become a laboratory for nation-building, enforcing a postwar majoritarian-centric peace-building and memory, where most minority veterans did not belong any more. The unilateral repeal of the war contract meant that they had mobilized, served, and sometimes fought, for nothing.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutes outside Greece
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Minasidis, Charalampos
- Μηνασίδης, Χαράλαμπος
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/57414