Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Ο ιατρός στο Σύνταγμα: συμβολή στην ερμηνεία των άρθρων 21 § 3 και 5 § 1 του Συντάγματος

Abstract

dc:description

Historically, the doctor is positioned on the outer edges of the constitutional matter. The patient’s vulnerability influences the focus. This thesis aims to place the doctor at the core of the constitutional order for his rights and obligations to be looked into. Contemporary threats involving escalating violence in hospitals and the growing aggressive policy of medical malpractice lawsuits set doctors at risk of compromising their professional freedom. Furthermore, the prevalence of the informed consent model, which emerged in response to the paternalistic model, fails to adequately safeguard the patient's autonomy and the protection of his social right to health, while also preserving the professional and scientific freedom of the doctor. Establishing a shared-decision making approach between doctor and patient constitutes the optimal option to uphold the rights of both parties. The significance of the shared-decision making model is evident in both routine medical care and end-of-life matters. Even if euthanasia and assisted suicide are essentially prohibited by the Criminal Code and the Code of Medical Ethics, the right to a dignified and painless death originates from the constitutional order. Its implementation requires the establishment of a necessary legislative framework to designate the doctor as an attendant and consultant in this situation. Sorting and prioritizing patients is another challenge that doctors face and must manage in their professional careers. Allocating health resources at a large scale does not address the distress and agony faced by doctors at the micro-level when they must judge between two patients. To uphold the principles of procedural justice, it is necessary to formulate comparative criteria and a selection process that safeguard the doctor's professional autonomy while also respecting the social right to health of the patients involved. Owing to the pandemic, the issue of prioritization has become especially pertinent. Concurrently, it displayed the doctor initially as a beneficiary and subsequently as a victim: The compulsory immunization of healthcare professionals gave rise to significant constitutional concerns and called for establishing an equilibrium between article 21 para. 3, and article 5 para. 1 of the Constitution. This tight race took the form of a confrontation between the autonomy of doctors on the one hand and the social right to health of citizens and the safeguarding of public health on the other hand. Furthermore, while the aforementioned pertain to the deontological extensions of the medical profession, emphasize the doctor's “special sovereign relationship” with society, essentially encompassing the entire medical domain, the doctor's decision to practice in the public or private health sector has distinct constitutional ramifications. Thus, in the second part of the thesis we shall encounter the doctor acting in the private health sector. Traditional constraints, such as regionality, on professional freedom established by article 5 para. 1 of the Constitution were repelled as an aspect of a broader policy to liberalize occupations in accordance with European law and its tenets that attenuated the distinction between liberal professions and entrepreneurs. On the other hand, the process of gradually lifting restrictions on the formation and functioning of organized Primary Health Care entities, subsequent to the initial prohibitions outlined in Law 1397/1983, transpired over an extended and more intricate course. The endeavor to promulgate a presidential decree establishing the prerequisites and terms for the formation of Primary Health Care institutions, whereas striking a balance between economic liberty and the social right to health, was perpetually vulnerable. The Council of State's opinions progressed from initial considerations regarding the exclusive approval of partnership companies to those regarding the acceptance of capital companies of a special form requiring the exclusive presence of doctors in the shared capital. Ultimately, the Council of State endorsed a form in which doctors would retain the majority of the shared capital. Nonetheless, this solution was overturned when the Plenary of the Council of State cancelled a sequence of provisions envisioned by presidential decree 84/2001. Ultimately, the restrictions were eliminated through the enactment of Memorandum laws, which permitted private non-medical individuals to establish not only a company specializing in health services but also a private practice with doctors as employees. In order to protect the scientific and professional freedom of doctors and uphold the social right to health outlined in article 21 para. 3 of the Constitution, the establishment of scientific managers, a scientific Director and a scientific Council, along with their veto power over the operation of the economic entity, was maintained. The private secondary health care sector followed from the beginning a smoother course with which the primary sector was essentially harmonized. The third section of Thesis introduces the physician in his capacity as a public official. The NHS's consistent provision of full and exclusive employment was associated with the safeguards provided by article 21 para. 3 of the Constitution, in order to prevent the formation of "customer relationships" and ensure the loyalty of doctors. On occasion, small fractures occurred as a result of efforts to rectify particular structural malfunctions and deficiencies within the health system. From the rural practice to part-time contracts in areas such as rural areas and barren regions, the public health system has attempted to satisfy permanent and ongoing needs, but not in a systematic way. The establishment of afternoon outpatient clinics and afternoon surgeries, which allowed NHS doctors to supplement their income within the public health system, as well as the reintroduction of the “personal doctor” foreseeing the "per capita" pay even for the doctors of NHS, constituted a gradual introduction into the NHS of elements defined in article 5 para. 1 of the Constitution, traditionally associated with the private sector, maintaining however the provisions of full and exclusive employment. This constant is overturned by recent changes to the legislative framework that permit private practice doctors to operate within the NHS and NHS doctors to practice in the private sector, raising concerns regarding the preservation of the social right to health in light of these changes.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Vrachni, Georgia
  • Βραχνή, Γεωργία

Subjects

dc:subject × 65

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/57468

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Vrachni, Georgia; Βραχνή, Γεωργία. Ο ιατρός στο Σύνταγμα: συμβολή στην ερμηνεία των άρθρων 21 § 3 και 5 § 1 του Συντάγματος. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/57468