Back to search

Technical University of Crete (TUC)

Nanoparticles vs pesticides: applications and impact on agro-ecosystems

Abstract

dc:description

Modern agriculture faces significant challenges in achieving sustainable food production while minimizing the depletion of natural resources and environmental pollution. Recent advancements in nanotechnology hold great promise in addressing these challenges. This has been highlighted by several studies focusing on various agricultural applications of nanotechnology, such as the development of nano-fertilizers, which enhance nutrient delivery through targeted release, thereby reducing waste and environmental impact. A major challenge chemical control faces is the loss of available conventional active ingredients due to strict environmental safety regulations which, combined with the loss of fungicide efficacy due to resistance development, constitute major issues of contemporary crop protection. Metal containing nanoparticles appear to have all the credentials to be the next-generation, eco-compatible fungicide alternatives and a valuable anti-resistance management tool. Could the introduction of metal NPs as nano-fungicides be the answer to both reducing environmental footprint of xenobiotics and dealing with fungicide resistance? Furthermore, and despite their “golden” potential to be used as pesticide alternatives and anti-resistant agents, safety issues concerning undesirable effects towards non-target organisms such as phytotoxicity, toxicity to humans and environmental ecotoxicity, should be considered before their commercial introduction as nano-pesticides. Under this light the main objectives of the present thesis were a) to study the effectiveness of metallic nanoparticles (MNPs) against phytopathogenic fungi both in vitro and in vivo, b) to investigate the mechanism of fungitoxic action of MNPs at the biochemical level, c) to explore the potential use of MNPs alone or in combination with conventional plant protection products to combat resistant phytopathogenic strains, as well as to reduce recommended doses and the environmental footprint of pesticides, d) to examine the potential use of MNPs against populations of the olive fruit fly, resistant to insecticides, and their impact on the endosymbiotic microorganisms of the fly's gut flora, and e) to investigate the toxicological effects of MNPs on the growth and physiological parameters of tomato plants, as well as on the symbiotic organisms of their root system. Metallic nanoparticles as fungicide alternatives In an attempt to evaluate their potential to be used as fungicide alternatives, copper (Cu-NPs, CuO-NPs), silver (Ag-NPs) and zinc (ZnO-NPs) containing nanoparticles (NPs) were assessed in vitro against seven economically important fungal species, known to cause foliar and soil-borne plant diseases. Cu-NPs emerged as the most effective, followed by ZnO-NPs and Ag-NPs, while CuO-NPs and showed limited effectiveness. Cu-NPs demonstrated greater fungitoxicity than the reference fungicide Cu(OH)2 across most species. Most NPs tested outperformed their bulk counterparts in terms of toxicity, indicating distinct mechanisms of action between nanoparticles and their ionic counterparts. All NPs were significantly more toxic to fungal spores than to hyphae and overall more effective than Cu(OH)2, as confirmed by in vitro bioassays. Additionally, NPs notably reduced grey mold symptoms on plum fruit, particularly Ag-NPs, which completely inhibited disease development. These findings highlight the promising potential of these nanoparticles as protective antifungal agents. Following this initial screening, selected MNPs were tested against fungicide-resistant fungal pathogens. MNPs combating fungicide resistance Combating drug-resistance is a daunting task, especially due to the shortage of available drug alternatives with multisite modes of action. In the second part of this thesis, the potential of MNPs to be used against fungicide-resistant fungal pathogens, their potential synergy with conventional fungicides as well as the underlying mechanisms were investigated in four pathogen-NP cases. In the first case, copper nanoparticles (Cu-NPs) were found to be effective against both sensitive and resistant to thiophanate-methyl (TM) and pyraclostrobin Botrytis cinerea isolates bearing the E198A and G143A resistance mutations in the β-tubulin and cytb genes, respectively. A synergistic effect was observed between Cu-NPs, TM and fluazinam both in vitro and when tested on apple fruit. Copper ion release contributed to the fungitoxic activity of Cu-NPs, but nano-specific mechanisms including ATP-dependent metabolism were also involved. Similar results were observed in the case of Cu-NPs, which could suppress mycelial growth in both sensitive (BEN-S) and resistant (BEN-R) to TM M. fructicola isolates harbouring the E198A benzimidazole resistance mutation, more effectively than Cu(OH)2. Copper ion release and ATP-dependent metabolism were also found to contribute to the fungitoxic action of Cu-NPs against M. fructicola. A significant synergy of Cu-NPs with TM was observed against TM-sensitive isolates both in vitro and when applied on plum fruit suggesting an enhanced availability or nanoparticle-induced transformation of TM to carbendazim. In the third case, to test whether the effectiveness of MNPs could be affected by the metallic basis of NPs, Ag-NPs were tested against the above M. fructicola isolates in terms of effectiveness and fungicide resistance management both in vitro and in vivo. Ag-NPs effectively suppressed mycelial growth in both sensitive (BEN-S) and resistant isolates. Ag-NPs also exhibited synergy with TM regardless resistant phenotype (BEN-R/S) both in vitro and when applied on apple fruit. Contrary to the profile observed in the case of Cu-NPs, the synergistic action was attributed to an enhanced Ag-NPs activity rather than increased TM availability. Furthermore, the role of released silver ions on the fungitoxic action of Ag-NPs against M. fructicola was found to be limited, while ATP-dependent metabolism probably contribute to their fungitoxic action. In the last NP-pathogen case, the antifungal potential of ZnO-NPs against Alternaria alternata isolates with reduced sensitivity to the succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SDHI) boscalid, resulting from target site modifications, was assessed. Similarly to the above cases, ZnO-NPs could effectively inhibit mycelial growth in both sensitive (BOSC-S) and resistant (BOSC-R) isolates. Zinc ion release was partly responsible for the fungitoxic effect of ZnO-NPs as well as additional mechanisms involving cellular ion homeostasis such as ATP-dependent ion efflux and ROS production. ZnO-NPs showed a synergistic effect with boscalid in all phenotypic cases (BOSC-S/R) both in vitro and in vivo. A “capping” effect of boscalid when applied with ZnO-NPs probably accounts for this synergistic effect by causing a significant reduction of the nanoparticle size. All the above cases indicate that metal NPs can combat fungicide resistance especially when used in combination with the same fungicide that the pathogen has developed resistance to. This extraordinary resistance-negating effect can be attributed to several mechanisms such as increased bioavailability of the fungicide caused by a carrier effect of the NP, chemo sensitization of the fungal cell caused by the NPs or an indirect increased toxicity of the NPs due to a “capping” effect of the fungicide which results in smaller, and thus more toxic, NPs. In any case, besides managing fungicide-resistance, the combination of MNPs with fungicides was shown to drastically reduce the recommended fungicide doses which can contribute to the mitigation of the problem of environmental contamination caused by the excessive use of agrochemicals. MNPs against insecticide-resistant Bactrocera oleae populations Besides their antimicrobial properties, MNPs such as those containing silver, zinc oxide, titanium oxide and copper, have exhibited a great potential as pesticide alternatives against arthropod pests of economic importance, including flies, moths, mosquitos, lice and ticks. In this study, copper nanoparticles (NPs) were tested as an alternative control agent against olive fruit flies (B. oleae) with reduced sensitivity to the insecticide deltamethrin and their impact on the insect's reproductive and endosymbiotic parameters was investigated. Both nanosized and bulk copper applied by feeding resulted in significant levels of adult mortality, comparable to or surpassing those achieved with the insecticide deltamethrin at recommended doses. When combined with deltamethrin, Cu-NPs significantly enhanced the insecticide's efficacy against B. oleae adults, reduced the mean total number of offspring compared with the control, and the number of stings, pupae, female and total number of offspring compared with the insecticide alone. Both bulk and nanosized copper significantly reduced the abundance of the endosymbiotic bacterium Candidatus Erwinia dacicola which is essential for the survival of B. oleae larvae. These findings indicate that Cu-NPs can contribute to the management of B. oleae both by reducing larval survival and by enhancing deltamethrin performance in terms of toxicity and reduced fecundity, providing an effective anti-resistance tool and minimizing the environmental footprint of synthetic insecticides by reducing the required doses for the control of the pest. Toxicological effects of MNPs on tomato and its root-symbiotic organisms Plants, being an essential part of all ecosystems, are expected to interact directly or indirectly with nanoparticles, that could potentially inflict toxicity, accumulate via uptake or disturb interactions of plants with beneficial/symbiotic organisms. Various studies evaluating phytotoxicity of metal NPs have been conducted reporting adverse effects on various aspects of plant growth and physiology in numerous plant species although reports are often conflicting, highlighting that toxicity threshold of NPs towards plants is species dependent and each case should be evaluated separately. Tomato is a vegetable crop with great popularity and economic importance worldwide, and although studies evaluating phytotoxicity of tomato caused by silver, zinc oxide, titanium oxide, copper, and ferric NPs are available, their toxicity compared with their bulk counterparts, as well as their interaction with tomato’s endophytic symbiotic microorganisms is limited. Therefore, this study investigated the effect of copper (Cu-NPs, CuO-NPs), silver (Ag-NPs) and zinc oxide (ZnO-NPs) nanoparticles (NPs) on plant growth, physiological properties of tomato plants and their symbiotic relationships with the endophytic Fusarium solani FsK strain. Results indicated that the FsK strain was more sensitive to Cu-NPs and ZnO-NPs compared to CuO-NPs and Ag-NPs, with most nanoparticles exhibiting greater toxicity than their bulk forms. While NPs did not affect seed germination, they reduced root length and dry weight in a dose-dependent manner, with notable effects from AgNO3, Cu-NPs and ZnO-NPs. Root and shoot length of grown tomato plants was also affected by treatments while differences between NPs and bulk counterparts varied. NPs and bulk counterparts resulted in reduced chlorophyl-a and carotenoid levels and a marked oxidative stress response as indicated by increased MDA and H2O2 levels of treated plants. NPs and counterparts did not affect FsK colonization of roots indicating a possible shielding effect of tomato plants once the endophyte was established inside the roots. Interestingly, the presence of FsK in roots appeared to mitigate some of the nanoparticle toxicity, suggesting a complex interaction that could provide resistance against these toxic agents in tomato plants. Summarizing, the potential of MNPs to be used as alternative, eco-compatible pesticides was demonstrated in several disease/pest pathosystems. Results also highlighted their potential for addressing the crucial agricultural issue of pesticide resistance, especially when combined with pesticides which leads to synergy, enabling effective management of the resistance phenomenon while simultaneously allowing for reduced dosages and consequently minimizing the environmental footprint of these drugs. However promising for crop protection, MNPs may pose both known and unknown health and environmental risks. Phytotoxicity tests on tomato plants revealed adverse effects of metal NPs on growth and physiological properties as well as on an endosymbiotic fungal strain which shields tomato plants against soil diseases and stress conditions. Therefore, since their effect on biological systems is not yet completely understood, MNPs should be further studied for undesirable effects towards non-target organisms such as phytotoxicity, toxicity to humans and environmental ecotoxicity before their commercial introduction as nano-pesticides at a large scale.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Technical University of Crete (TUC)
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Malandrakis, Anastasios
  • Μαλανδράκης, Αναστάσιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 38

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/57681

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Malandrakis, Anastasios; Μαλανδράκης, Αναστάσιος. Nanoparticles vs pesticides: applications and impact on agro-ecosystems. Technical University of Crete (TUC), 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/57681