Back to search

Agricultural University of Athens

Προσρόφηση θρεπτικών στοιχείων από υδατικά διαλύματα και υγρά απόβλητα σε γεωυλικά

Abstract

dc:description

The recovery of nutrients from agricultural or municipal waste is of scientific and practical interest in the context of the circular economy and sustainable agriculture. In particular, the utilisation of alternative sources of orthophosphate phosphorus (PO4-P) becomes even more urgent considering the non-renewable mineral resources, which are the only raw material for phosphate fertiliser production worldwide, and the dependence of many countries on imports of fertilisers or raw materials in a global market affected by geopolitical tensions. Adsorption on mineral materials (geosorbents) has been proposed as a relatively simple and low-cost method of recovering P from wastewater. Nutrient-enriched geosorbents could be used as soil amendments to slow the release of nutrients and optimise their uptake by crops Such an application depends on criteria related both to the economic and environmental footprint of the chemical modification of the adsorbent and to the potential release of toxic elements or compounds from the adsorbent to soil and surface water. Furthermore, a limited number of studies have focused on adsorption experiments with real wastewater, bioavailability of recovered/adsorbed P and the use of adsorbents as soil amendments. This thesis consists of five research works, in which modified zeolite (CaT-Z) was used as the main adsorbent material after treatment with Ca(OH)2 solution. This chemical compound presents advantages in terms of low purchase cost and mild environmental impact that could result from the treatment of zeolite and its application as a soil amendment. In the first three experimental works, the adsorption capacity of the modified zeolite for phosphate anions was tested in aqueous solutions (Chapter 3) and two real wastewater of municipal (fresh urine, Chapter 4) and agricultural origin (digested olive mill wastewater, Chapter 5). In the last two studies, carried out with anaerobically digested livestock (Chapter 6) and olive mill wastewater (Chapter 7), lignite fly ash (FA) and zeolitic fly ash (ZFA) as a product of hydrothermal treatment of the former, were also used. The last two studies aim at comparing the adsorption capacity of the three gesorbents (CaT-Z, FA, ZFA), with the common characteristic of their surface being the presence of chemical groups containing calcium (Ca). The common objective of the five experimental studies was to investigate, at the chemical and molecular level, the adsorption mechanisms primarly of phosphorus (P) and secondarily of ammoniacal nitrogen (NH4-N) or potassium ions (K+), depending on the chemical composition of each wastewater. The investigation of adsorption mechanisms was based on chemical desorption tests and analyses of X-ray Diffraction (XRD), Scanning Electron Microscopy coupled with Energy Dispersive System (SEM-EDS), Electron Probe Microanalysis (EPMA) and Infrared-Attenuated Total Reflectance (IR-ATR) spectroscopy. The first experimental work (Chapter 3) showed that treatment of zeolite (particle size of 1.19-2 mm) with solutions of 0.1-1 mol/L Ca(OH)2 significantly increased the adsorption capacity of the modified material (CaT-Z), resulting in a significant increase in the percentage removal (R%) of P from solutions of 10 and 100 mg P/L compared to the raw zeolite (NZ). The modified zeolite, obtained by the treatment with 0.25 mol/L Ca(OH)2, exhibited an increased point of zero charge (pHpzc = 9.98) compared to the raw one (pHpzc = 6.14). The zeolite, treated with 0.25 mol/L Ca(OH)2, was selected for further experiments, since no significant differences in P adsorption from aqueous solutions were observed between the zeolite samples treated at concentrations of 0.1 to 1 mol/L Ca(OH)2. Subsequently, the impact of different experimental conditions on P adsorption was studied. The percentage removal and adsorption of P from solution of 10 mg P/L was not affected by initial pH between 4 and 9, indicating the effective performance of the modified adsorbent under slightly acidic and alkaline conditions. In solutions with relatively low P concentrations (0.5-10 mg/L), the adsorption capacity of CaT-Z increased with temperature (15, 25 and 35 °C) resulting in low residual P concentrations (81-238 μg/L). Kinetics experiments at 25 °C showed that adsorption equilibrium at initial concentration of 10 mg P/L occurred after 5-7 days, whereas at concentrations of 100-500 mg P/L, the equilibrium was achieved after 21-49 days. The maximum adsorption capacity of CaT-Z at 500 mg P/L ranged from 13.34 to 13.64 mg P/g between 42 and 77 days of process. The presence of bivalent iron, bicarbonate, acetate or citrate anions, as well as the anionic surfactant SDS, had a negative effect on the adsorption of P from aqueous solutions. Analyses of infrared spectroscopy (IR-ATR) indicated the adsorption mechanism of ligand exchange between carbonate and phosphate anions, while SEM-EDS analyses confirmed the formation of multilayer calcium phosphate (Ca-P) phases on the CaT-Z surface. In the second study (Chapter 4), raw (NZ) and modified zeolite (CaT-Z) were used to adsorb P from diluted fresh urine (FU), which is an important secondary source of inorganic nutrients. Both geosorbents were tested for comparison in the first sample of wastewater (FU-1), while in the second sample (FU-2) only CaT-Z was used. Emphasis was placed on the sequential desorption of P (NaHCO3-P, NaOH-P, HCl-P) from the loaded materials after adsorption in FU-1 to assess the contribution of adsorption and precipitation to P removal. The experiments with FU-1 showed lower residual P concentrations (0. 58-135.82 mg/L) in the presence of CaT-Z) after 6 days of adsorption compared to the NZ (6.39-259.02 mg/L). Besides, the total amounts of P desorbed from the loaded CaT-Z (qdes = 1.65-10.43 mg P/g) in the three extraction steps were higher than those desorbed from NZ (qdes = 1.65-10.43 mg P/g).These results indicate that the modified zeolite adsorbed more P from FU-1 compared to the raw material. The comparison between the adsorption (qads) and desorption (qdes) capacities of CaT-Z at various dilution ratios (5%, 10%, 50% and 75% v/v) of FU-1 and FU-2 revealed that the mechanism of adsorption (qads) contributed to the total P removal more than the mechanism of precipitation of calcium phosphate (Ca-P) phases in the liquid phase. Therefore, the total desorption capacity (qdes), as the sum of the three extraction steps after adsorption, can be used to estimate the real P concentration in the solid phase (qads). Additionally, the desorption procedure showed that the dilution ratio of wastewater and therefore the initial P concentration, affected the geochemical fraction of the adsorbed P. Specifically, the strongly adsorbed and insoluble Ca-P fraction (HCl-P) was dominant on CaT-Z after adsorption in less diluted FU samples (75% FU-1, 50% FU-1 and 25% FU-2), whereas the weakly adsorbed and plant-available NaHCO3-P (Olsen-P) dominated on CaT-Z after adsorption in more diluted FU samples (5% FU-1, 10% FU-1 and 5% FU-2). The analyses of XRD, SEM-EDS and EPMA confirmed the adsorption of P on both adsorbents, mainly in the form of calcium phosphate, while IR-ATR analyses indicated the mechanism of ligand exchange in the case of CaT-Z and the adsorption of NH4-N on both the modified and raw zeolite. The third experimental work (Chapter 5) investigated the adsorption of phosphorus (P) and potassium (K) from two samples of digested olive mill wastewater (OMW-1 and OMW-2) using the modified zeolite (CaT-Z). In the literature, there are a limited number of studies on nutrient adsorption from raw or digested olive mill wastewater. The adsorption of two nutrients was investigated as a function of contact time, pH and dilution rate (% v/v) of the wastewater with deionized water. The lowest P removal in the presence of CaT-Z was observed in the more diluted wastewater (3.125% OMW-1, 6.25% OMW-1 and 5% OMW-2). The maximum Ρ removal amounted to 73.9% in the 25% OMW-1 and 85.9% in the 10% OMW-2. Removal of potassium, as the predominant cation in the raw olive mill wastewater in general as well as in the digested samples OMW-1 (1684 mg/L) and OMW-2 (1708 mg/L), increased from 17.3% to 46.1% in OMW-1, and from 15.1% to 57.7% in OMW-2, when dilution increased from 50% OMW-1 to 3.125% OMW-1 and from 50% OMW-2 to 5% OMW-2, respectively. The maximum experimental adsorption capacity was calculated to be 15.8 mg K/g and 2.14 mg P/g CaT-Z. Plant-available P (NaHCO3-P) was the dominant fraction of adsorbed P on CaT-Z. The qualitative elemental X-ray maps, obtained from the EPMA analyses, revealed the co-occurrence of P and Ca on the surface of CaT-Z, whereas single-point analyses indicated increased concentrations of K and P on CaT-Z after adsorption in the 50% OMW-2. Moreover, the increase in K2O and Na2O contents (%wt) in some analyses of CaT-Z after adsorption was accompanied by a decrease in CaO and MgO percentages, indicating the exchange between K+ ions of the liquid phase and divalent cations (Ca2+ and Mg2+) of the CaT-Z surface. The formation of Ca-P phases on CaT-Z after adsorption in the samples 25% OMW-1, 50% OMW-1 and 50% OMW-2 was also confirmed by SEM-EDS analyses. In the fourth study (Chapter 6), modified zeolite (CaT-Z) of 1.19-2 mm particle size and fly ash (FA) in powder form (≤ 0.2 mm) were used to compare the adsorption of P and NH4-N from aqueous solutions and three different anaerobically digested effluents of agricultural and livestock waste. Experiments in aqueous solutions with a concentration of 100 mg NH4-N/L or 100 mg P/L showed significant differences in the adsorption capacity of the two materials. Fly ash adsorbed almost all P (qads = 9.96 mg P/g) after one day as a consequence of its mineralogical composition (presence of gypsum and calcite), whereas P adsorption on CaT-Z was a slow process of several weeks (up to 77 days) exhibiting an adsorption capacity of 8.56 mg P/g. On the other hand, CaT-Z adsorbed 4.13 mg N/g after 7 days, while FA adsorbed only 0.87 mg N/g, a result consistent with the fourfold higher cation exchange capacity of CaT-Z (0.86 meq/g) compared to that of FA (0.20 meq/g). The reduction in P adsorption from the aqueous solution of 100 mg P/L in the presence of bicarbonate ions (HCO3−) was clearly less in the case of FA due to a higher content of calcareous mineral phases. The desorption of P in three stages and of NH4-N in a single stage from the loaded geomaterials, after contacting the three digested wastewater (ADWW-1, ADWW-2 and ADWW-3), showed differences in the real adsorption capacity of both materials and in the speciation of the adsorbed P. According to the total P desorption capacity (qdes), FA adsorbed more P (0.87-16.96 mg P/g) compared to CaT-Z (0.38-1.29 mg P/g). In contrast, CaT-Z adsorbed more exchangeable NH4-N (3.03-3.76 mg N/g) compared to FA (0.04-0.26 mg N/g), consistent with the results of the adsorption experiment at 100 mg N/L. The plant-available fraction of NaHCO3-P (Olsen-P) was dominant on CaT-Z with 0.30-1.27 mg P/g, while the strongly adsorbed fraction of Ca-P (HCl-P) dominated on FA with 0.31-12.39 mg P/g. IR-ATR analyses confirmed the presence of NH4-N in CaT-Z and indicated the adsorption of P in FA after adsorption in the ADWW-2.In the fifth study (Chapter 7) of the thesis, modified zeolite (CaT-Z), lignite fly ash (FA) and zeolitic fly ash (ZFA) were used to adsorb P and K from anaerobically digested olive mill wastewater (ADOMW). Adsorption experiments showed that ZFA and FA adsorbed more P (up to 4.35 and 5.21 mg P/g, respectively) compared to CaT-Z (2.62 mg P/g). The adsorption of P on ZFA and FA increased between contact time of 7 and 14 days. Sequential P desorption verified the differences in the adsorption capacity of the three geosorbents and showed that the plant-available P (Olsen-P) amounted to 1.34, 2.34 and 1.69 mg P/g CaT-Z, ZFA and FA, respectively. After 14 days of adsorption, CaT-Z and ZFA adsorbed much more potassium (19.2 and 20.5 mg K/g, respectively) than FA (4.3 mg K/g), a result confirmed by the desorption of the exchangeable K+ from the loaded materials. SEM-EDS analyses confirmed the presence of calcium phosphate (Ca-P) phases on the surface of the three materials as well as the exchange between Ca2+ and K+. In summary, zeolitic fly ash proved to be more efficient in simultaneous P and K adsorption, combining the properties of zeolitic crystals (K adsorption via cation-exchange) and mineral phases of the parent material (P adsorption on calcareous minerals or surface precipitation of Ca-P), which were not affected by the hydrothermal treatment with NaOH. The satisfactory concentrations of plant-available P or/and K on the three geosorbents suggest their potential use as soil amendments. In the above experiments, conducted in real wastewater, the tests of PO4-P, K and NH4-N desorption from the loaded geosorbents and the resulting desorption capacities (qdes) contributed not only to the estimation of the bioavailability of the adsorbed nutrients, but also to the estimation of the “real” adsorption capacity (qads) of each gesorbent against the overestimated “apparent” adsorption capacity, calculated on the basis of the residual concentration of each nutrient in the liquid phase. In any case, the adsorption capacity of the three geosorbents in real wastewater was lower than that in aqueous solutions of phosphate anions or ammoniacal nitrogen, due to the presence of competing anions or cations and organic matter in the former. The comparison of P adsorption and desorption results among the experiments in slightly acidic human urine (FU-1, FU-2) and those in slightly alkaline digested wastewater (OMW-1, OMW-2, ADWW-1, ADWW-2, ADWW-3, ADOMW) shows that the alkalinity of digested wastewater, due to presence of bicarbonate anions (HCO3−), is an inhibiting factor for the formation of Ca-P complexes on the modified zeolite (CaT-Z). In addition, geosorbents with higher CaO content (FA, ZFA) exhibited a higher P adsorption and desorption capacity in aqueous solutions and real wastewater compared to CaT-Z. However, geosorbents with higher cation exchange capacity (CaT-Z, ZFA) were superior in adsorption of NH4+ or K+. Spectroscopic and microscopic analyses contributed to the understanding at the atomic and molecular level of interfacial interactions between the liquid (wastewater) and the solid (geosorbents) phases, providing useful indications for adsorption mechanisms.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Agricultural University of Athens
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Mitrogiannis, Dimitrios
  • Μητρόγιαννης, Δημήτριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 34

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/57843

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Mitrogiannis, Dimitrios; Μητρόγιαννης, Δημήτριος. Προσρόφηση θρεπτικών στοιχείων από υδατικά διαλύματα και υγρά απόβλητα σε γεωυλικά. Agricultural University of Athens, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/57843