Back to search

University of Patras

Development of a laser shock-based disassembly process for adhesively bonded composite aeronautical parts

Abstract

dc:description

Novel aircraft engine fan blades utilize a multi-material structure composed of a 3D woven composite core partially covered by an adhesively bonded thin metallic layer. The end-of-life (EoL) management of such a configuration involves many challenges, with one of them being the disassembly of the bonded components. Numerous methodologies have been explored to address the debonding challenge, encompassing various physical and chemical phenomena. However, many of these methods have been proven less suitable in scenarios involving composite materials, especially when the preservation of the integrity of the materials is essential. Recent developments on the laser shock technique have revealed the potential of the method to be used for the disassembly of adhesively bonded CFRP and metallic parts. The laser shock technique involves the interaction between a high-power laser beam and a target material, initiating a plasma expansion process. The recoil momentum of the ablated material generates a high pulsed pressure, creating a shock wave that propagates within the material. This shock wave propagation induces localized high tensile stress, which can be used to effectively debond a bonded structure. Various laser configurations can be utilized to focus said tensile stress area to a location of interest, thus creating a versatile process. In this thesis, the laser shock technique is investigated as a disassembly method for adhesively bonded multi-material aeronautical structures. The process is specifically applied to a Foreign Object Damage (FOD) panel, which consists of a 3D woven composite core bonded by an adhesive film to a thin titanium protective layer. The FOD panel serves as a representative structure of a chord of a multi-material engine fan blade, acting as a demonstrator platform for the European research program "MORPHO" (H2020, 101006854), which provides much of the framework for this thesis. The study and utilization of the complex phenomena involved in the laser shock technique necessitate meticulous numerical simulation, which was conducted using the LS-Dyna explicit finite element code. The development of the numerical model can be split into two sections. Initially, a coupon-scale model of the multi-material assembly was designed, so that it can be validated utilizing experimental data. Subsequently, a strip of the FOD panel was modeled, in an attempt to upscale the process to a real component. Given the complexity of the composite substrate, further investigation into simulation techniques was deemed necessary. The composite in question is a 3D woven CFRP structure, prompting the initial design of a detailed finite element model using the TexGEN software. Given the intricacy of the structure, the software’s scripting capabilities were utilized for model design. Fiber bundles were simulated using an advanced composite material model capable of providing progressive damage indicators and simulating high strain rate phenomena described in the LS-Dyna manual as MAT_162. Material properties were obtained through a homogenization process employing the Chamis micro-mechanical formulations. The matrix of the 3D woven composite was simulated using an elastoplastic material model, with literature properties adjusted for the high strain rate of the laser shock process. The detailed model was subsequently compared to a homogenized one, simulated solely by the progressive damage composite model (MAT_162). The comparison of shockwave propagation revealed minimal difference between the two models. However, when comparing damage prediction, differences between the two simulation techniques became evident, with the detailed model proving more accurate in predicting small matrix cracking. Despite the slightly increased sensitivity to damage demonstrated by the detailed model, the homogenized model was deemed more suitable for simulating the process due to its enhanced efficiency. Material properties for the homogenized model were obtained by high strain rate characterization of the composite substrate. Specifically, coupons that were cut from a single sheet of the composite were tested using the split Hopkinson pressure bars (SHPB) apparatus. Both tension and punch shear tests in the weft and warp orientation were conducted. Notably, the increased strength of the material in the warp orientation exceeded the capabilities of the tension testing apparatus, thus providing only elastic material properties. The weft orientation specimens, as well as the punch shear experiments, were conducted successfully and were able to provide the required data. Additionally, laser shock experiments were conducted using a multi-material coupon that incorporates a 3D woven composite substrate bonded to a titanium layer. Experiments utilized two distinct configurations. Initially, a single-sided, single-pulse configuration was used, while a laser interferometer (VISAR) was used on the opposite face of the specimen, measuring the particle velocity. The process failed to generate the desired stress field for the debonding of the titanium layer but provided valuable back face velocity measurements. Subsequently, a symmetric configuration was employed, where two laser beams are directed through optics on each side of the specimen, with a time delay between them. This allows for a more precise stress field generation and was able to debond the titanium layer. After the extensive experimental campaign, the coupon was modeled and the laser shock process was simulated using the LS-Dyna explicit code. The model, like the coupon, includes the composite substrate that was modeled using MAT_162, bonded to a titanium protective layer that is modeled using the Johnson-Cook plasticity model in combination with the Grüneissen equation of state. Material properties derived from the literature were used for the titanium component, as it is a very well-studied material for high strain rate applications. The bondline between the two components utilizes the cohesive zone method (CZM). Experimental back face velocity measurements were used to validate the numerical model in terms of shock wave propagation, while the properties for the CZM were obtained by comparing the predicted damaged area of the model to microscope photographs of the symmetric experiments that managed to debond the assembly. The laser shock disassembly process necessitates multiple consecutive shots. The simulation of this process is carried out by developing an automated Python script for sequential simulations. Initially, a preliminary study compared this approach to a traditional methodology that uses a single simulation for a small number of consecutive shots. The results were identical, and the multi-step process was deemed more practical. To implement this, a traditional LS-Dyna simulation is conducted, and the results are used as input for the subsequent simulation. All necessary loadings were described parametrically to enable external control via a Python script. This script uses an LS-Dyna keyword manipulation library to adjust the parameters of each consecutive analysis. Loading inputs can be provided in various ways depending on the problem’s complexity, with the most versatile method being the input of a CSV file containing shot locations and other useful information, such as the delay for a symmetric shot. After establishing the methodology with a validated numerical model, it is possible to upscale the process for the disassembly of a strip of the FOD panel. To achieve this, a preliminary simulation examined the effect of surface inclination, concluding that the process is only affected at extreme inclinations, which is not the case for the FOD panel. The model was derived from a CAD file provided by partners of the "MORPHO" project. Material models were identical to those in the coupon-scale model and are thus considered validated. The process employs a single-sided double-beam configuration with a time delay, where two laser beams irradiate the same spot on the component with a time delay between them. This configuration allows control of the stress field, similar to the symmetric configuration, with the added advantage of only targeting one surface of the component. The simulation procedure comprises two stages: the process definition and the disassembly process simulation. Initially, process definition simulations were conducted to determine the delay times necessary for debonding the top and bottom interfaces of the panel. These simulations provided a delay time for debonding the top interface between the Ti/CFRP and a second-order polynomial equation to calculate the delay time for debonding the bottom interface of the Ti/CFRP assembly based on the laser spot location. The second stage involves process simulation for the full disassembly of the strip of the FOD panel. This simulation uses the automated Python script to conduct 29 consecutive simulations at 14 predefined spot locations, resulting in the complete separation of the titanium edge. The damage state of the CFRP was inspected via the history variables provided by MAT_162. As expected, the composite developed matrix cracking in different areas but notably no fiber damage. This conclusion is useful for EoL assessment, as the component can be recycled, providing high-value recycled carbon fibers.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Patras
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Kormpos, Panagiotis
  • Κόρμπος, Παναγιώτης

Subjects

dc:subject × 19

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/57849

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Kormpos, Panagiotis; Κόρμπος, Παναγιώτης. Development of a laser shock-based disassembly process for adhesively bonded composite aeronautical parts. University of Patras, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/57849