Back to search

Institutes outside Greece

Le système européen des quotas d’émission de gaz à effet de serre: recherche sur la notion d’efficacité juridique

Abstract

dc:description

This doctoral dissertation examines Directive 2003/87/EC, which established a greenhouse gas emissions trading system. The directive constitutes a dual regulatory measure: initially, pollution allowances, referred to as emission quotas, are allocated; subsequently, these allowances are either utilized by companies within their operations or traded on an organized market. The Directive was inspired by Ronald Coase’s theorem, articulated in his 1960 article *"The Problem of Social Cost,"* which emphasizes achieving economic efficiency in the presence of externalities, such as pollution. This research analyzes the efficiency of the Directive in creating the world’s largest carbon market for trading greenhouse gas emission allowances. The analysis goes beyond market efficiency, as the climate crisis requires an evaluation of the broader framework of environmental measures rather than isolated legislative actions. Upon its adoption, the Directive’s initial objective was not full carbon efficiency but the establishment of a transitional mechanism towards a net-zero emissions economy. Since the carbon market functions as an organized platform, overly efficient regulation could lead targeted companies to remain confined to stable, existing regimes without further investments in emission reduction. For this reason, the evaluation of the carbon market focused on understanding its economic structure, identifying inefficiencies arising from the regulatory framework, and analyzing how legislative interventions addressed them. One of the primary inefficiencies was information asymmetry, mitigated through measures promoting market transparency. The centralization of transactions on an organized platform, where information is provided in real time, combined with oversight by a specialized regulatory body (AMF), ensured transparency and balance in trading. This strategy to minimize information asymmetry extended to include data on companies’ environmental performance under the carbon trading system, ultimately contributing to improved market efficiency. Furthermore, Coase’s theorem played a central role as the theoretical foundation for legislative intervention. According to the theorem, efficiency in the presence of externalities can be achieved if transaction costs are negligible—a condition that does not exist in practice due to the necessary role of the state. Nevertheless, Coase’s ideas inspired the creation of a regulatory framework that aims not only for environmental protection but also for economic efficiency. This dissertation explores the conceptualization of regulatory efficiency in applied legislation, using a sociological perspective that defines efficient regulation as one whose outcomes align with the legislator’s original objectives. The study analyzed the operation of the carbon market during the first two phases of the Directive’s implementation, highlighting significant shortcomings in relation to the purity and perfection of initial economic assumptions. The low cost of allowances during the first period underscored the need for improvements, with the most alarming issue being large-scale fraud (e.g., VAT fraud in emissions allowances), which was termed “the fraud of the century.” To address these challenges, the legislator opted to include most allowance transactions within an organized financial market, enhancing transparency and reducing information asymmetry. The presence of a regulator, closely monitoring the flow of information in market transactions, reinforced this approach. This strategy for disseminating information was extended to include environmental activity data from the involved companies, further improving the carbon market’s overall efficiency. Finally, the dissertation emphasizes that the efficiency of legal regulation does not necessarily encompass a binding regulatory content. Evaluating the efficiency of a regulation helps recognize its effectiveness, but such analysis only acquires practical significance when its conclusions inform new legislative adaptations. Nevertheless, this process is not always a mandatory step. In conclusion, the dissertation demonstrates that, despite initial inefficiencies primarily due to information asymmetry, the integration of the carbon market into a centralized and controlled platform—where information is easily accessible—helped rationally address this asymmetry, leading to more reliable regulatory framework efficiency.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutes outside Greece
Year dc:date
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Mikropoulou, Charalampia-Panagiota
  • Μικροπούλου, Χαραλαμπία-Παναγιώτα

Subjects

dc:subject × 33

Rights

Language dc:language
fre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/57903

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Mikropoulou, Charalampia-Panagiota; Μικροπούλου, Χαραλαμπία-Παναγιώτα. Le système européen des quotas d’émission de gaz à effet de serre: recherche sur la notion d’efficacité juridique. Institutes outside Greece, 2023. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/57903