Abstract
dc:descriptionAbstract The current PhD thesis introduces a new theory to explain and study the phenomenon of strategic surprise. Until now, the study of strategic surprise started from the discrete point of the military attack and focused either on how it was planned and executed by the attacker, or on how the victims of surprise failed to anticipate it, prepare, and respond properly. However, in the contemporary international environment, strategic surprise has been transformed from a simple principle of war, used exclusively in the preparation of an operational plan, to a high strategy tool. The effects of surprise are no longer limited to the field of battle or in the sphere of military operations, but they have a direct influence in the overall high strategy of a state. Therefore, in the current thesis we consider that although the culmination of a strategic surprise is the military attack, which is carried out at the merge of the strategic and operational level, the phenomenon is not located there. The military attack as such it’s not the strategic surprise but its culmination. We understand strategic surprise in the current thesis as the final act of a gradual process, which has started a long time ago and specifically at that particular point in time that the aggressor's perception of the international environment, his position within it and the projection of this position in the future has changed. The proposed theory is consisting of four hypotheses: Hypothesis 1. Surprise is a systemic phenomenon. It occurs after a change in the relative balance of power between states has taken place. Hypothesis 2. Strategic surprise is based on the indirect approach doctrine. Hypothesis 3. Strategic surprise is a process that unfolds in three main phases and consists of political deception, technological surprise, and military surprise. Hypothesis 4. In each phase of the process, correspond different main errors with different causes and different responsible for them. Failure to warn begins at a high strategic and political level and becomes cumulatively more difficult at each subsequent level. In conclusion, to focus on just an image, namely only the military attack, from the general picture - no matter how dramatic - although it helps in the detailed and thorough analysis of that specific image, neglects other dimensions, which are necessary for a complete understanding of the phenomenon in its entirety. Studying the phenomenon of strategic surprise as a process, while at the same time considering both actors, the surpriser and the surprised, is the basis of the proposed theory, which explains the overall range of strategic surprise and not just the final phase, the military attack. Such a concept, we believe can contribute both to the understanding and the prediction of the phenomenon in the future. The proposed theory draws from the lessons of the realist theory of international relations, the strategy of indirect approach and from the existing literature on the pathologies of intelligence and the causes of the intelligence services failure to timely predict and warn of upcoming attacks. To test the theory, two emblematic cases of strategic surprise were examined, Japan's attack on the US at Pearl Harbor in 1941 and Egypt's and Syria's attack on Israel in October 1973.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Panteion University of Social and Political Sciences
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Nizamis, Konstantinos
- Νιζάμης, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 28- Στρατηγικός αιφνιδιασμός
- Πληροφορίες
- Αποτυχία πληροφοριών
- Στρατηγική προειδοποίηση
- Υπηρεσίες πληροφοριών
- Πέρλ Χάρμπορ
- Αντιληπτικά σφάλματα
- Γνωστικά σφάλματα
- Τεχνολογικός και δογματικός αιφνιδιασμός
- Ενδείκτης και ενδείξεις
- Υομ Κιππούρ
- Ραμαντάν
- Strategic surprise
- Intelligence failure
- Strategic warning
- Cognitive and perception biases
- Technological and doctrinal surprise
- Intelligence cycle
- Politicization of intelligence
- Pearl Harbor
- Yom Kippur war
- Prospect theory
- Πολιτικές Επιστήμες
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Διεθνείς σχέσεις
- Political Science
- Social Sciences
- International Relations
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/57995