Ionian University
Εκπαιδευτικά δωμάτια απόδρασης: μια εποικοδομητική εναλλακτική για την ανάπτυξη δεξιοτήτων πληροφοριακής ιδιωτικότητας
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe protection of information privacy is a salient and enduring concern, as the pervasiveness of the Internet has become integral to nearly every aspect of contemporary life. It is frequently observed that internet users lack an adequate understanding of privacy, a phenomenon that has been documented in relevant literature. This inadequacy may be attributed to the absence of theoretically grounded pedagogical approaches, that can support the teaching and learning of information privacy. Concurrently, the development of educational interventions to enhance privacy awareness persists as a focal point of pertinent research, as privacy appears to be a growing concern among internet users. The incorporation of reflective and interactive elements represents a promising approach, yet the lack of a robust learning theory to ground these elements and ensure their effectiveness and systematic design remains a challenge. Despite the recent emphasis in research on the necessity of reassessing traditional educational approaches to information privacy, the majority of proposed strategies continue to prioritize the dissemination of information and the acquisition of general knowledge. New research efforts underscore the necessity for targeted educational initiatives that equip users with the requisite skills to safeguard their privacy from the potential risks associated with the Internet. In response to these needs, researchers are focusing their attention on the design and development of innovative educational interventions, with the aim of refining the learning objectives and more effectively equipping users to protect their personal data and privacy. In response to this research gap this dissertation entitled "Educational Escape Rooms: A Constructive Alternative for Developing Information Privacy Competencies," aims to present an inclusive approach to effective teaching and learning in the field of information privacy. The scope of this dissertation is to propose an alternative educational method for developing and enhancing specific privacy competencies, that has been demonstrated to be highly effective in achieving learning objectives, in comparison to existing methods. The introductory part of the dissertation analyses and thoroughly studies the literature on privacy awareness, privacy competencies and existing educational approaches to enhance them. This analysis confirms the researchers' findings on the lack of effectiveness of privacy awareness techniques and privacy learning in general. At the same time, it leads to conclusions concerning a) the need to specify the competencies that internet users need to acquire in order to protect their privacy, b) the lack of a theoretical framework that can provide detailed and clear guidance for the creation of effective educational interventions for privacy learning, and c) the need for further conceptual and empirical exploration of the field in order to find alternative proposals. The introductory section of the dissertation presents a comprehensive analysis and detailed study of the existing literature on privacy awareness, privacy competencies, and the educational approaches that have been developed to enhance them. This analysis confirms the researchers' findings regarding the ineffectiveness of privacy awareness techniques and privacy learning in general. Consequently, the study yields conclusions regarding the necessity to: (a) delineate the competencies that internet users must attain to safeguard their privacy; (b) develop a theoretical framework that can offer comprehensive and lucid guidance for the design of efficacious educational interventions for privacy learning; and (c) undertake further conceptual and empirical investigation of the field to identify alternative proposals. In order to explore the research problem, we have established four research questions that are addressed in this dissertation. In order to respond to the first research question, "How might we, in accordance with the constructivist learning theory, develop a constructivist teaching practice that incorporates specific guidelines for the design of a constructivist educational intervention regarding privacy?" we conducted a comprehensive examination of the principles of constructivism and proposed a constructivist pedagogy that is notably absent from the existing literature on the field. The proposed pedagogy is based on a set of theoretically grounded requirements, which provide clear and detailed guidance for the design and development of any constructivist educational activity. In order to achieve this objective, we provide illustrative examples of practical applications for each requirement, thus developing a constructive pedagogy for information privacy. Furthermore, in order to more accurately delineate the learning objective, we present an illustrative scenario for the use of the constructivist pedagogy, intended for the development of an educational intervention pertaining to Privacy Enhancing Technologies (PETs).Addressing the second research question "What form should a playful alternative educational approach for increasing privacy competencies, according to constructivist teaching practices, take?" was formulated following a comprehensive examination of the literature on contemporary educational approaches that incorporate constructivist elements. In light of the requirements of constructivist pedagogy, it can be posited that game-based learning represents a particularly salient area of interest for constructivist educators. From the multitude of possibilities within this field, we propose escape rooms as the most appropriate constructivist learning tool, as they align directly and explicitly with the requirements of constructivist pedagogy. The third research question "How can we design an escape room according to the theoretically grounded specifications of a constructivist didactics for information privacy?" was approached as a natural continuation of the previous one, as we drew on the requirements of the constructivist pedagogy to design a comprehensive scenario for an educational escape room focused on developing and/or enhancing competencies related to information privacy. This scenario fully exploits the potential of technology to create and utilise a digital escape room, with a clear and direct correlation between the game's puzzles and challenges and the subject matter being explored. To answer the fourth research question "Can an escape room equip an internet user with specific privacy skills (visible and indiscernible)?" we followed a complex methodological approach, in order to implement an educational escape room for information privacy learning and to experimentally evaluate its effectiveness in developing and/or enhancing privacy competencies. We conducted a mixed-model study in which 81 people volunteered to participate as players in a two-dimensional (2D) digital privacy mystery escape room. The game scenario was the one developed as part of the implementation of Constructivist Pedagogy for Information Privacy. In addition, we created and used a closed-ended questionnaire to measure the players' level of five (5) privacy competencies before and after their participation in the game in order to identify any differences and thereby evaluate the effectiveness of the method. The results of the study showed that privacy competences were significantly enhanced after the mediation of the educational intervention, even in competencies that are difficult to change, as they are inherent personality traits of each individual. A complete conceptual and methodological framework is developed in the context of this dissertation: •to support the design of constructive educational activities, concretising all those characteristics that an effective educational intervention for privacy skills should bring together; and •to validate the effectiveness of an educational intervention implemented on the basis of these characteristics. Our research makes contributions at the theoretical, methodological and practical levels. Specifically, the contribution of the dissertation at the theoretical level can be identified in the following points: •Formulating and introducing a constructivist teaching theory based on the principles and axioms of constructivist learning theory, •Enriching the existing literature with a new theoretical framework to support the creation of innovative educational interventions for privacy and more generally, •To provide empirical evidence that educational interventions based on a game-based approach to learning are more effective than traditional privacy-enhancing methods, •There is empirical evidence that not only skills related to knowledge and competences are cultivated and/or enhanced, but also skills related to the social role and personality of the individual, •There is empirical evidence of the malleability of skills related to knowledge and competencies, •There is empirical evidence that it is possible to cultivate skills related to more general notions of privacy, •Constructive pedagogy for privacy provides a springboard for use and research in other areas of computing, •To the best of our knowledge, the implementation and experimental application of our proposal is the first such project in the relevant literature. The contribution of the dissertation on a practical level can be identified in the following points: •The requirements of constructivist pedagogy can be used by educational institutions, privacy awareness program designers, information security software companies, organizations, companies and educational material providers to design and create constructive activities and educational interventions for learning about information privacy, and beyond, •Important information is provided to policy makers on information privacy to focus on effective methods to enhance privacy learning, •Educational project providers benefit from the findings as empirical research material is provided as an illustrative implementation to orient their attention to adopting new and alternative approaches to the broader field of information privacy and security, •Formal education institutions can make use of the proposed indicative implementation and the empirical results in order to integrate into their curricula alternative educational interventions that will empower internet users with the appropriate competencies to protect their privacy. At the methodological level, the contribution of the dissertation can be identified in the following points:•A fully structured and theoretically grounded framework is provided, which follows a linear step-by-step process for creating constructive educational privacy interventions, •Methodological approaches to the practical implementation of innovative educational privacy interventions are provided, •Finally, a questionnaire is provided to measure specific privacy competencies, designed on the basis of pre-existing privacy conceptual constructs.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Ionian University
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Papaioannou, Thanos
- Παπαϊωαννου, Θάνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 28- Ιδιωτικότητα
- Πληροφοριακή ιδιωτικότητα
- Δεξιότητες πληροφοριακής ιδιωτικότητας
- Εποικοδομητισμός
- Προστασία της ιδιωτικότητας
- Προστασία προσωπικών δεδομένων
- Εκπαιδευτικά δωμάτια απόδρασης
- Εποικοδομητική διδακτική της πληροφοριακής ιδιωτικότητας
- Privacy
- Information privacy
- Information privacy competencies
- Constructivism
- Privacy protection
- Personal data protection
- Educational escape rooms
- Information privacy Constructive pedagogy
- Επιστήμη Ηλεκτρονικών Υπολογιστών και Πληροφορική
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Διεπιστημονικές εφαρμογές επιστήμης ηλεκτρονικών υπολογιστών
- Εκπαίδευση
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση, άλλοι τομείς
- Computer and Information Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Computer Science Interdisciplinary Applications
- Education
- Social Sciences
- Education, miscellaneous
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58086