Back to search

University of Crete (UOC)

Η σημασία της αντιλογικής παράδοσης στη διαμόρφωση της φιλοσοφίας

Abstract

dc:description

The subject of this thesis concerns the tradition of antilogic and examines how and whether this tradition contributed, and to what extent, to the formation of what we would call philosophy during the period of the 5th and 4th centuries BC. What was the art and practice of antilogic? Who were the thinkers who shaped its basic principles (if any)? How did the art of antilogic contribute, if it indeed contributed, to the emergence of a way of thinking that—from Plato onwards—we call philosophy, particularly in its classical form? Was antilogic a practice for philosophical thinking that was widely known? Who and at what points criticized the art of dialectic (and for what purpose)? These are the main questions that the present research seeks to answer.Antilogies, the pairs of opposing arguments, seem to have primarily aimed at provoking or even confusing the audience—and not necessarily at supporting a position or defeating the opponent. In fact, in the most 'successful' and meticulously constructed antilogies, the audience could be left in a state of confusion, in the sense that they would not be able to discern which side is the one that holds the truth. Antilogies essentially represent an innovation that, for specific reasons, developed in fifth-century Athens, indicating that this city provided the favorable conditions for their flourishing. However, for many decades, and even from ancient times, it seems that antilogies were neglected. It is a fact that during the last two centuries, scholars’ focus on the role that antilogic played in the formation of philosophy has not been extensive nor centered on this particular question.Attempting a chronological examination of antilogic and taking into account Plato’s references, I begin from its origins (as Plato at least perceives the matter), namely the Eleatics and the Eleatic tradition. The research then focuses on the figure most closely associated with antilogic, Protagoras. Due to the lack of other sources, the analysis turns to the two unique and most representative works of the antilogic tradition: the Dissoi Logoi and the Tetralogies. The study concludes with an analysis of Plato’s views as presented in the ancient texts. also highlighting the role of his teacher, Socrates. Socrates appears to share common elements with the antilogikoi, such as the evocation of surprise, the interlocutor’s inability to respond in dialogue, and aporia (puzzlement or impasse). Plato’s objection to antilogic and the antilogikoi is not unambiguous: at times, his criticism focuses on their problematic relationship with the formulation of definitions, while at others it targets their claim to be able to speak about everything. However, we cannot claim that Plato is entirely negative toward antilogic: it is possible that the philosopher had in mind two forms of antilegein—a correct and an incorrect one.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Crete (UOC)
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Samarkou, Sevastiana - Eyangelia
  • Σαμάρκου, Σεβαστιάνα-Ευαγγελία

Subjects

dc:subject × 42

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/58107

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Samarkou, Sevastiana - Eyangelia; Σαμάρκου, Σεβαστιάνα-Ευαγγελία. Η σημασία της αντιλογικής παράδοσης στη διαμόρφωση της φιλοσοφίας. University of Crete (UOC), 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/58107