National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Exploiting olive sector residues: a sustainable path to bioenergy and added-value products
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of this PhD thesis is the exploitation of the olive sector residues as a feedstock for bioenergy and added-value products. Olive sector residues consist of mainly agricultural residues such as olive tree prunings (OTP), olive leaves and agro-industrial residues such as olive pomace and vegetation water. The PhD focuses mainly on the valorization pathways of OTP as it is the most unexploited biomass resource from the above. The untapped potential of such agricultural residue is evident from the fact that, only in Greece, annually more than 2 Million dry tons of OTP are either burned in open fires or mulched onto soil. The former damages unconditionally the environment, whereas the latter possess risks of transmitting plant diseases through the soil. The aim of the thesis was to address the whole value chain, starting from the field and the harvesting of such agricultural residue, through its haulage and storage, up to its pretreatment into hog fuel or pellets and finally its validation via its conversion into bioenergy or other added value products e.g. particleboards, thus offering a holistic view of OTP valorization. The thesis commences with a thorough assessment of biomass availability from the olive sector in Greece. Protocols were developed in order to conduct initial on-field measurements of OTP. The measurements were performed at various geographical locations and involving different olive tree varieties in order to provide a robust foundation for estimating the national OTP potential. Building upon this data, the research supported the development of a GIS-based tool that empowered users to estimate the OTP potential within their desired sourcing radius. This tool facilitates informed decision-making regarding OTP utilization in specific regions. Through field measurements and the development of a GIS tool, the study estimates the available OTP to be around 2 dry Mt annually. This substantial biomass resource, primarily treated as waste through open-field burning, presents a significant opportunity for bioenergy production and the development of a circular economy in the olive sector. The research emphasizes the importance of accurate biomass assessment to guide efficient harvesting and logistics strategies. Continuously, the thesis delves into the logistics of harvesting and transporting OTP. It details a two-year mechanized harvesting campaign in central Greece. In total, for both years, the harvesting campaign lasted for 20 days where around 81 ha of olive groves were harvested, that amounted to 252 dry tonnes of harvested prunings. The aim was to evaluate an agricultural residue mobilization value chain in terms of performance, economics and fuel analyses of the harvested OTP. Via detailed monitoring, the present thesis compares the harvesting demonstration results for both years. In brief, the average material capacity increased from 2.2 dry t/h (first year) to 2.4 dry t/h (second year), whereas the corresponding harvesting and haulage costs of these harvesting campaigns were calculated at 62.3 €/t (dry basis) and 63.7 €/t (dry basis), with an estimated commercial operation cost at 46.0 €/t (dry basis). The study results that mechanized harvesting of OTP is economically feasible and environmentally friendly, especially when strategically planned and optimized. Moreover, the research further examines the impact of storage of OTP hog fuel on the solid biofuel itself. Through the thesis, the monitoring of feedstock losses during a five-month storage period was performed, by comparing two storage solutions: i) uncovered, open-air storage and ii) fleece-covered open-air storage. For this task, two identical conical piles of harvested OTP were built and monitored for calculating the changes in dry matter and energy value of the stored material over time. One pile was left uncovered, while the other was covered with a breathable fleece. For each pile, net bags were used in order to obtain samples for analysis. Overall, the covered pile showed improved storage performance than the uncovered pile, with the latter one getting more influenced by weather conditions. The covered pile presented i) lower dry matter losses after five months of storage with an average value of 1.1% compared to 4.6% of the uncovered pile; ii) stable moisture content throughout the storage period at around 10%, compared to the fluctuating moisture content of the uncovered pile from 11% to 24%; and finally, iii) recoverable energy gain with an average pile value of 12.1% compared to recoverable energy loss of 5.1% in the uncovered pile after the storage period. The results demonstrate that covering piles with fleece significantly reduces dry matter losses and preserves fuel quality, offering a cost-effective storage solution for OTP-based value chains. After having secured the supply of OTP, the current thesis investigates the conversion of OTP into solid biofules such as pellets and their validation at commercial applications. At first the pelletization process is described in detail. The production cost of pellets amount to 80 €/t, whereas the energy consumptions to produce one dry ton of OTP pellet amount to 1,340 kWh primary energy. Then the fuel properties of OTP pellets and hog fuel are analyzed, revealing their potential as industrial solid biofuels. In general, OTP fuels have a good energy content but differ to forest biomass in terms of higher ash content (at 5.5% (dry basis)). Thus, this type of biomass requires boilers with higher requirements in the systems dedicated to ash removal and mainly, based on fuel properties, addresses the industrial fuel market. Continuously, the research validated the use of OTP fuels in commercial boilers, comparing their performance and emissions to conventional fuels such as sunflower husk pellets and exhausted olive cake. More specifically, OTP pellets were validated at a 1.2 MWth biomass boiler of a greenhouse, on a 0.5 MWth biomass boiler of an olive mill and finally, at a 1 MWe biomass gasifier in operating conditions. In all three tests, the efficiency of the conversion technology was calculated along with the performance of emissions tests. The performance of the OTP fuels was compared with the reference fuels used at these industries. For example, in the first case, OTP pellets slightly decreased the boiler’s efficiency by 3.5 percentage points compared to the reference fuel. The loss of efficiency was mostly related to the increased energy density of the OTP pellets compared to the sunflower pellets (24.8% higher). The higher energy density led to the decrease of the feeding rate by the boiler operator. However, the setting of the boiler was not optimum, thus higher losses were observed (high flue gas temperature). Apart from the slightly decreased efficiency, the emissions for OTP pellets were lower for CO, NOx and CO2. On the other hand, OGC emissions were much higher with OTP pellets compared to SH pellets. With both fuels, the boiler emissions were within the MCPD limits for NOx and SO2 emissions. However, dust emissions were high for both fuels. Overall, the results of the emission measurement campaigns highlighted the importance of choosing a modern combustion system, compatible with this type of biofuels that has all the necessary automations that will ensure a high efficiency and low emissions (e.g. automated control with lamda sensors, cyclone/ESP) and ease of use (automatic ash extraction). Adding to that, the fuel properties of the olive tree prunings are similar and, in some cases, even better than other industrial fuels. The thesis further evaluates the economic feasibility of different olive tree pruning exploitation concepts towards bioenergy production, including the establishment of Integrated Biomass Logistic Centers (IBLCs), by meaning new business activities that could be implemented by agro-industries of the sector. Such concepts include: i) harvesting and selling OTP hog fuel in local industrial consumers; ii) producing OTP pellets and selling to the market; and iii) generating electricity from OTP in a power plant and selling it to the grid. A detailed cost analysis and discounted cash flow analysis were performed for each concept. The results indicate that the power plant concept, with guaranteed demand and fixed tariffs for electricity, is the most economically viable option, offering a sustainable and profitable way to valorize OTP. Apart from bioenergy, the current thesis investigates the feasibility of producing particleboards from OTP, partially substituting conventional wood. The study evaluates the mechanical and physical properties of the produced particleboards, comparing them to commercial wood-based panels. More specifically, the mechanical properties of the panels were reduced by increasing the content of OTP. On the other hand, particleboard properties such as the formaldehyde emissions of the boards, along with the thickness swelling were reduced by increasing the substitution level, which makes the panels safer in terms of indoor pollution and human health and more consumer friendly, and attractive for the market. The results demonstrate that OTP can replace up to 40% of wood in particleboard production without compromising quality, offering a sustainable alternative and addressing timber shortages. Further to the pilot production of particleboards, the current thesis explores the valorization of olive sector residues, such as olive mill wastewater (OMW), olive leaves, exhausted olive cake and two-phase/ three-phase pomace into added-value products like phenols. The research investigates the extraction and identification of phenols from the above-mentioned feedstock performed at laboratory tests in WFBR (Wageningen Food & Biobased Research, the Netherlands). The extracted phenols were investigated for their potential applications in cosmetics, pharmaceuticals, and nutraceuticals. The study investigates various extraction methods and solvents, emphasizing the importance of selecting appropriate techniques for maximizing phenol recovery and quality and discusses identified barriers and supportive policies for their commercialization. The final chapter summarizes the main conclusions of the thesis highlighting the potential of an agricultural residue, such as OTP, as a valuable resource for bioenergy and added-value products. The research emphasizes on the importance of efficient harvesting, storage, and processing techniques to maximize the benefits of OTP utilization. In this light, the current thesis researches the whole OTP valorization value chain by also providing key-information and ready-to-implement solutions for addressing unexploited biomass resources such as OTP. The study also identifies areas for future research, such as fuel mixtures of OTP with other unexploited biomass feedstock, exploitation of OTP with alternative biomass conversion technologies along with the integration of carbon capture and storage technologies and/or biochar production, and production of other biochemicals (5-HMF, furfural, tetrahydrofuran) from OTP. By addressing these aspects, the research contributes to the advancement of a circular economy and sustainable development in the olive sector, with the aim of exploiting all the residues of the sector towards bioenergy and added-value products production.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kougioumtzis, Michael-Alexandros
- Κουγιουμτζής, Μιχαήλ-Αλέξανδρος
Subjects
dc:subject × 22- Βιομάζα
- Βιοενέργεια
- Βιοπροϊόντα
- Εφοδιαστική βιομάζας
- Αειφορία
- Biomass
- Bioenergy
- Bioproducts
- Biomass logistics
- Sustainability
- Άλλες Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογίες
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Μηχανική και Τεχνολογίες, άλλοι τομείς
- Περιβαλλοντική Μηχανική
- Ανανεώσιμη ενέργεια, Αειφορία και Περιβάλλον
- Ενέργεια και Καύσιμα
- Other Engineering and Technologies
- Engineering and Technology
- Engineering and Technologies, miscellaneous
- Environmental Engineering
- Renewable Energy, Sustainability and the Environment
- Energy and Fuels
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58122