Back to search

University of Patras

Essays on textual analysis of accounting disclosures

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation examines initially the association of the information content of corporateaccounting disclosures with firm performance and liquidity policy, and secondly, it assesses the effectiveness of two important regulations on the enhancement of the information quality of accounting disclosures (the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and the XBRL mandate). For the analysis of accounting disclosures, an algorithmic approach in the Python programming language was implemented and, in specific, the dictionary method suggested by Loughran and McDonald (Loughran and McDonald, 2011). The database that was created after the implementationof textual analysis of U.S. annual reports (10-Ks) was merged with the database containing financial data from Compustat. Furthermore, Stata software was used for the regression analyses of this thesis. This thesis includes three chapters that consist of three pillars of empirical research in the field of textual analysis of accounting disclosures. The first chapter is: “Textual analysis of accounting disclosures and firm performance”, the second chapter is: “Textual analysis of accounting disclosures and firm liquidity”, and the third chapter is: “Accounting disclosures, regulation, and firm performance”. The first chapter (Textual analysis of accounting disclosures and firm performance) consists of two self-contained essays: The first essay is: “Complexity of accounting disclosures, tone ambiguity, and firm performance: Textual analysis of readability of U.S. annual reports”, and the second essay is: “Manager’s tone of accounting disclosures and firm performance”. The first essay examines the association between readability and tone ambiguity of firms’ annual reports and performance of U.S.companies. The following hypotheses are tested: a) whether managers try to hide poor performance by disclosing complex accounting information and b) whether managers use ambiguous tone to obfuscate negative information. Specifically, the relationship between readability of financial reports and firm performance is examined. Furthermore, the impact of poor performance on the use of uncertain and modal weak tone is tested. The dictionary method is used for textual analysis to measure readability and tone ambiguity of reports. The results of textual analysis of 10-Ks are combined with financial data of U.S. firms. The findings of this study indicate that managers tend to disclose less readable reports with vague information to overshadow negative performance. The second essay (Manager’s tone of accounting disclosures and firm performance) investigates the relationship between manager’s tone in annual reports and firm performance. Specifically, the following relationships are examined: the impact of firm performance on annual reports’ tone, the association of firm performance with the managers’ decision to use positive, negative, uncertain, and litigious words in annual reports, and the impact of positive, negative, uncertain, and litigious toneof 10-Ks on firm performance. The sample consists of annual reports (10-Ks) of U.S. companies. Financial data are retrieved from the merged Compustat/Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) annual database. The dictionary method is used to process textual information of accounting disclosures. The findings of this study suggest that firm performance and tone of 10-Ks are significantly related. Furthermore, textual attributes of annual reports have a statistically significant impact on company’s performance. The reverse relationship is also examined, and the empirical results suggest that firm performance has a significant effect on managers’ choice of positive, negative, uncertain, and litigious words in 10-Ks. The second chapter (Textual analysis of accounting disclosures and firm liquidity) consists of two independent essays. The subject of the first essay is: “Tone, complexity, and ambiguity of accounting disclosures and corporate liquidity”, and the second essay focuses on: “The impact of litigation risk on corporate financial policy”. The purpose of the first work is to shed light firstly on the association between corporate liquidity and textual information included in accounting disclosures of U.S. companies and secondly to examine whether there is an association between complexity of annual reports, as well as ambiguity of managers’ tone and firms’ cash holdings policy. The following hypotheses are tested: First, whether the tone of accounting disclosures has an impact on firm liquidity. Specifically, legal risk, level of confidence, complexity, and optimistic tone of annual reports are examined. Second, whether more complex information in annual reports is associated with a higher level of cash holdings, and third, the association of vague corporate disclosures with the amount of cash that managers hold. Financial data are retrieved from the merged Compustat/Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) annual database and used along with data from textual analysis of accounting disclosures. The dictionary method of Loughran and McDonald is adopted to process textual information (Loughran and McDonald, 2011). The empirical results of this work indicate that the measures of tone of accounting disclosures examined in this study (percentage of positive, litigious, modal weak, and modal moderate words, as well ascomplexity of 10-Ks) have a significant relation with firm liquidity. Moreover, the findings reveal that managers that disclose more complex and vague information in 10-Ks tend to hoard cash. The second essay of the second chapter (The impact of litigation risk on corporate financial policy) examines whether there is an association between litigious risk and firm’s cash holdings. The sample consists of annual reports of U.S. companies from 1998 to 2017. Financial data from the Compustat/Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) database are merged with data from textual analysis of accounting disclosures. This study implements the dictionary method of Loughran and McDonald to process textual information (Loughran and McDonald, 2011). The empirical results reveal that when firms face higher legal risk, they tend to decrease the level of cash holdings. Managers’ decision to decrease corporate cash holdings when dealing with litigation risk could be interpreted as an attempt to reduce the value of the claim and additionally, to avoid being a target to future plaintiffs. The results of this study aim to equip researchers, managers, financial analysts, and investors with further knowledge as they contribute to the better comprehension and analysis of the corporate cash holdings policy. This study adds empirical evidence to a research question that is not widely examined by the literature: the impact of litigation risk on corporate financial policy. It contributes to two important strands of literature: cash holdings literature and literature of litigation risk. In addition, it enriches the measures used by accounting research by applying the textual analysis methodology of accounting disclosures. Finally, the third chapter (Accounting disclosures, regulation, and firm performance) consists of two self-contained essays. The subject of the first essay is: “The impact of SOX on the informativeness of corporate reports revisited: An analysis of textual attributes of accounting disclosures”, and the second essay examines: “The impact of the XBRL mandate on readability of U.S. annual accounting disclosures”. The first research work investigates whether there is a systematic change in the informativeness of annual reports after the Sarbanes-Oxley Act and SEC regulations of 2003, analyzing the textual attributes of accounting disclosures. The sample consists of annual reports of U.S. companies from 1998 to 2017. Financial data are retrieved from the merged Compustat/Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) database and analyzed along with data from textual analysis of accounting disclosures. The empirical results reveal that although the informativeness of 10-Ks’ tone has decreased after 2003, more specific measures of textual information included in annual reports are more informative after the establishment of the regulations. The assessment of the quality of accounting information after the SOX Act with more sophisticated textual analysis tools aims to equip with deeper comprehension the users of accounting information - managers, investors, analysts, auditors, and policymakers. This study augments and updates the empirical evidence on the debatable research question concerning the effectiveness of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, examining the textual attributes of 10-Ks. It adopts a comprehensive textual analysis framework, broadening the spectrum of measures that are used in the literature. The second essay (The impact of the XBRL mandate on readability of U.S. annual accounting disclosures) aims to investigate the readability of firms’ annual reports after the implementation of the XBRL mandate in U.S. financial reporting. XBRL was adopted in three different phases. First, this research work focuses on the initial phase right after the adoption, and the implications of the mandate in the first group of firms that had to use XBRL in their 10-Ks are examined. Furthermore, the study investigates the impact of the XBRL mandate on the readability of firms’ reports after the phase-in period. The dictionary method is used for measuring readability of accounting disclosures. Financial data and ratios are retrieved from the merged Compustat/Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) annual database. The results of this research work indicate that the mandate had a significant impact on the readability of accounting disclosures of firms in the first phase. Furthermore, the mandate had a greater impact on the readability of 10-Ks with more quantitative disclosures. The findings suggest that the XBRL had a significant impact on firms after the phase-in period as well. This study contributes to the existing literature as it extrapolates the research regarding the impact of the XBRL mandate, which is a very significant regulation concerning financial reporting, on readability of accounting disclosures. Specifically, this research work examines the longitudinal effect of this mandate as it investigates the impact of the XBRL not only on the first adopters but on all the firms that had to implement it after the initial phase. Moreover, this study uses alternative measures of readability of 10-Ks that have not been used in prior literature to investigate these research questions, as far as I know. Finally, the implications of this study are important for researchers, managers, financial analysts, and investors as they provide a deep insight into the impact of this mandate on the quality and transparency of accounting information.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Patras
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Sotiropoulou, Virginia-Athanasia
  • Σωτηροπούλου, Βιργινία-Αθανασία

Subjects

dc:subject × 21

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/58213

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Sotiropoulou, Virginia-Athanasia; Σωτηροπούλου, Βιργινία-Αθανασία. Essays on textual analysis of accounting disclosures. University of Patras, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/58213