University of Patras
Αναλύοντας κριτικά τη ρητορική μίσους: αναπαραστάσεις των προσφύγων/ισσών σε κείμενα πλειονοτικών και μεταναστών/τριών μαθητών/τριών
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn this thesis, I explore the positions of students attending the 5th and 6th grade of the Greek primary school (10–11-year-olds) regarding refugees and the coordinated discourses with these positions. In particular, I study the representations of refugees as they emerge from the positions of majority students and students of immigrant origin attending the 5th and 6th grade of the Greek primary school on the occasion of current affairs texts. The study aims to examine whether and to what extent hate speech is reproduced and from which discourses it draws each time. Also, I seek to identify the similarities and/or differences that majority and immigrant students present concerning the ways in which they construct refugees and the discourses they reproduce. In order to carry out the research, I visited three primary schools in Attica Region, where refugee students also attend. Participants in the research are 84 students, 56 from the 5th and 28 from the 6th grade. Out of all the students, 28 belong to the majority group, while 56 have an immigrant background. First, I collected television excerpts of news programs that refer to refugee issues and images that project refugees. I proceeded to select, transcribe and analyze two indicative television excerpts. Then, I created a questionnaire consisting of open-ended questions, in which I use the above texts as well as two images that display corresponding topics as stimuli with the aim that students express their opinions about refugees. This questionnaire was my main data collection tool. Furthermore, I utilized the observation notes to collect additional ethnographic data and trace the attitudes of majority and immigrant students towards their refugee classmates. The observation took place during the lessons attended by majority, immigrant, and refugee students and my role in this process was that of a non-participating observer. My research draws from the field of Critical Discourse Studies, which focuses on how speakers with their (linguistic) choices at the micro-level position themselves in relation to dominant discourses at the macro-level (see among others van Dijk 2008). For the analysis of the texts and the data of the questionnaires, I used the Discourse-historical Approach, which employs a set of discursive strategies, that is, discursive practices, adopted to achieve a specific social, political, psychological or linguistic goal (Reisigl & Wodak 2001). In addition, I carried out a quantitative analysis on the questionnaires to examine the extent to which majority and immigrant students promote specific discourses and reproduce hate speech against refugees, as well as to identify any similarities or differences between the majority and immigrant students. From the analysis it emerged that students, both majority and immigrant, draw from the racist discourse, promoting the exclusion or the assimilation of refugees. In addition, they draw on anti-racist discourse, denouncing racism and promoting equality. At the same time, I identified representations that combine both above discourses, promoting the discourse of liquid racism. Regarding the results of the quantitative analysis, although I detected some differences between the two groups, I found that the majority and immigrant students show more similarities, as both groups promote more the racist discourse and the discourse of liquid racism and less the antiracist discourse. The identification of the immigrant students with the majority group highlights that the former have internalized the homogenizing values that the majority group has indirectly and implicitly imposed on them. Finally, the results of the observation confirm the above, as it turned out that refugee school students are usually marginalized. Considering these findings, most students, both majority and immigrant, reproduce hate speech, and actually, hate speech that is not prosecuted according to anti-racist legislation (hard hate speech), but soft hate speech that indirectly and implicitly devalues and undermines refugees.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Patras
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Panagaki, Nikoletta
- Παναγάκη, Νικολέττα
Subjects
dc:subject × 24- Ρητορική μίσους
- Κριτικές σπουδές λόγου
- Πρόσφυγες/ισσες
- Μετανάστες/τριες
- Μαθητές/τριες
- Ρατσιστικός λόγος
- Αντιρατσιστικός λόγος
- Ανθρωπιστικός λόγος
- Ρευστός ρατσισμός
- Hate speech
- Critical discourse studies
- Refugees
- Immigrants
- Students
- Racist discourse
- Anti-racist discourse
- Humanitarian discourse
- Liquid racism
- Γλώσσα και Λογοτεχνία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Γλώσσα και Γλωσσολογία
- Languages and Literature
- Humanities and the Arts
- Language and Linguistics
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58222