Institutes outside Greece
Social rights as transindividual rights: a law and ethics approach to the European social crisis
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe thesis assesses how social rights have been conceived and legally addressed during the late financial crisis in Europe and against the austerity backdrop in Greece and Portugal by fostering a critical, comparative, and interdisciplinary approach from a law and ethics perspective. The analysis commences by illustrating the various crisis narratives that developed during austerity and records the latter’s historical backstory and impact on the protection and conceptual realization of social rights. In this context, the research reviews exemplary cases brought before Portuguese, Greek, and European Courts, and challenges the concepts of ‘cause lawyering’ and ‘judicial activism’ as these have been employed in the debate regarding the justiciability of social rights. Informed by these insights, the research proceeds to critically evaluate the standard argument that social rights are cost-generating rights and scrutinizes the normative de-categorization between economic, social, and cultural rights and civil and political rights found in international human rights law. Against this background, the study identifies that legal analyses showcase a lack of engagement with the ontological and ethical assumptions that underpin conceptions of social rights and delves into recent inquiries, which call for the need to revise long-established social justice schemes and employ the notions of solidarity and vulnerability towards that end. Subsequently, the analysis sketches how solidarity has been theoretically and normatively assessed in the frame of the late crisis in Europe and examines this together with the idea of mutual aid. Following this, the study problematizes the concept of vulnerability in latest contributions coming broadly from virtue ethics and liberal moral theory and from critical legal studies. Despite their differences, a common philosophical topos identified in these accounts is that human nature and social reality are perceived on the basis of a reductively negative social ontology, configured in terms of ideally stable and finite forms. Mindful of these limitations, this study concludes by resorting to the idea of ‘transindividuality’ as this has originated in the philosophical thinking of Baruch Spinoza and Gilbert Simondon and continues to be shaped in current interpretations of their work. Transindividuality is introduced in this respect not only as a linguistic but significantly as a conceptual framework that is different from atomist or holistic ontologies in the sense that it questions both the reduction of collectivity to individuality and of individuality to collectivity and advances instead a transindividual social ontology on the basis of relationality and process. Through this lens, this thesis proposes that this ontological framework unbinds the notion of the social in the conceptualization of social rights from a merely distributional demand imposed on the state or from the utilitarian bias of an individualistic model of rights. At the heart of this research lies the idea that it is neither a morally naturalized state of humanity nor structural social determinism but it is rather relationality as an ontogenetic process upon which social rights are grounded. In this regard, humans acquire social rights not simply by being positioned to each other or by being subjected to pre-existing structures, but, critically, by being related to each other. Within this framework, this thesis recasts social rights as transindividual rights.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutes outside Greece
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Pavlidou, Kyriaki
- Παυλίδου, Κυριακή
Subjects
dc:subject × 66- Κοινωνικά δικαιώματα
- Κοινωνικό δίκαιο
- Θεωρία δικαίου
- Φιλοσοφία δικαίου
- Πολιτική και κοινωνική θεωρία
- Κοινωνική φιλοσοφία
- Κοινωνική οντολογία
- Διατομικότητα
- Ηθική
- Μεθοδολογία του δικαίου
- Συγκριτικό δίκαιο
- Συγκριτική μεθοδολογική ανάλυση
- Διεπιστημονικότητα
- Φιλοσοφία της διαδικασίας
- Κριτική θεωρία
- Οντολογία
- Κοινωνικά δικαιώματα και οικονομική ύφεση
- Εργασιακά και κοινωνικά δικαιώματα
- Ευρωπαϊκή Ένωση
- Ευρώπη
- Social rights
- Social law
- Legal theory and philosophy
- Political and social theory
- Social philosophy
- Social ontology
- Transindividuality
- Ethics
- Methodology of Law
- Comparative law
- Methodology of Comparative law
- Interdisciplinarity
- Process philosophy
- Ontology
- Social rights and economic recession
- Labour and social rights
- Jurisprudence
- Critical theory
- European Union
- Europe
- Soziale Rechte
- Sozialrecht
- Rechtstheorie und Rechtsphilosophie
- Politische und soziale Theorie
- Sozialphilosophie
- Sozialontologie
- Transindividualität
- Ethik
- Methodologie des Rechts
- Interdisziplinarität
- Rechtsvergleichung
- Methodologie der Rechtsvergleichung
- Prozessphilosophie
- Ontologie
- Soziale Rechte und wirtschaftliche Rezession
- Arbeits- und Sozialrecht
- Jurisprudenz
- Kritische theorie
- Europäische Union
- Europa
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Νομική επιστήμη, διεπιστημονική προσέγγιση
- Law
- Social Sciences
- Law, interdisciplinary
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58254