Back to search

International Hellenic University

Improving the efficiency of the catalytic hydrogenation of CO2 via intensified process concepts and novel catalysts

Abstract

dc:description

The on-going use of fossil fuels leads to the persistent increase of carbon dioxide emissions, which in turn contribute to global warming and climate change. To mitigate this threat, technologies devoted to CO2 conversion into value-added products are increasingly been developed and deployed in industry. A substantial part of research on Carbon Capture and Utilization technologies (CCU) has been devoted to the catalytic hydrogenation of CO2 to methanol (or DME) that can serve both as a fuel and as a platform chemical for the production of numerous useful products. Methanol synthesis via CO2 hydrogenation reaction is exothermic, favored at high pressures and low temperatures. However, CO2 is a fully oxidized, thermodynamically stable, and chemically inert molecule that requires relatively high activation temperature. The reaction is therefore limited due to thermodynamics at high temperature and due to kinetics at low temperature. The key for CO2 hydrogenation to pose an attractive process for the production of methanol in an industrial scale lies in the development of highly active and selective catalytic materials, able to activate and convert carbon dioxide to methanol at low temperature. Another important parameter is the stability of such catalysts under realistic industrially relevant conditions and in the presence of common impurities found in CO2-containing flue gases. Additionally, the development of intensification strategies to circumvent thermodynamic limitations is also crucial for the efficient conversion of CO2.The purpose of the present thesis is to improve the efficiency of CO2 hydrogenation to value-added products, such as methanol or dimethyl ether, by developing novel catalysts and intensified process concepts with special emphasis on the experimental development of the sorption-enhanced (SE) methanol synthesis process. More specifically, novel catalyst preparation routes, such as 3D printing, sol-gel auto-combustion etc., and novel active components, such as Mo2C-based materials, were developed and investigated, focusing on the relation of the structural and physicochemical with the catalytic performance, which led to significant insight on the nature of the active sites. Additionally, the catalytic stability of a commercial Cu-based methanol synthesis catalyst after exposure to typical impurities present in flue gases was investigated. To circumvent the thermodynamic limitations of CO2 hydrogenation, processes based on the continuous removal of one of the reaction products were investigated. Special focus was dedicated to the development of an experimental protocol for the validation of the sorption-enhanced methanol synthesis concept, i.e. enhancement of methanol production by continuously removing water via the use of solid sorbents, as an attractive intensification strategy. The effect of various parameters, including operating conditions and material selection, on the process performance were also explored.Initially, molybdenum carbide-based catalysts were developed and systematically studied to address the kinetic constraints of CO2 hydrogenation. Cu promotion and various preparation routes (sol-gel auto-combustion, solid-state mixing, and solvothermal synthesis) were explored to understand their impact on the catalysts' physicochemical properties and reaction performance. Catalytic activity tests showed that hydrogenation of CO2 over the developed Mo2C-based catalysts leads to the production of CH3OH, CO and CH4. Cu promotion of the solvothermally prepared Mo2C catalyst led to a decrease of activity by 10 – 15 %, but significantly increased methanol selectivity at T < 275 °C. The catalytic performance of the 20 wt.% Cu-Mo2C catalysts was significantly affected by the preparation route as well, with the sol-gel carbide presenting the highest activity and methanol selectivity and the solid-state catalyst the lowest. The catalytic performance was directly linked to the nature and population of the different active sites on the catalysts’ surface. The low population of active sites, and thus poor catalytic performance of the carbide prepared via solid-state mixing, was attributed to excessive carbon deposition thus showing the importance of preparation conditions. By combining the information obtained via XPS analysis and temperature-programmed desorption studies, the nature and the role of the active sites in CO₂ and H₂ activation were elucidated. Cu addition leads to the formation of active sites that can activate CO2 and H2 at lower temperatures than the Mo2C sites. The improved methanol selectivity over the Cu-Mo2C catalysts prepared via the solvothermal and sol-gel routes was attributed to the stronger interaction between Cu and Mo2C leading to the formation of large number of Mo2C-Cu+ moieties that favor methanol synthesis. Further on, the deactivation and stability of a commercial CuO/ZnO/Al2O3 methanol synthesis catalyst, poisoned with typical contaminants present in steel-work off-gases, in the hydrogenation of CO2 to methanol were investigated. Catalyst poisoning with S and N was performed ex-situ in the gas phase by exposing the catalyst to a flow of H2S or NH3 respectively, while poisoning with metals Ca, Fe, Na was achieved by wet impregnation. By comparing the nominal content of each contaminant with the experimentally determined bulk concentration, the known affinity of S to the catalyst components was confirmed. The opposite was shown for N whose concentration was measured to be one order of magnitude lower than the nominal. Differences between the bulk and surface content measured via XPS were observed as well, with the non-metals (N, S) presenting lower surface concentration than in the bulk. Na, Ca and Fe on the other hand were shown to segregate on the catalyst surface. Poisoning of the catalyst caused a clear decrease of the Cu surface exposure, with a concurrent surface segregation of Zn suggesting preferential deposition of the contaminants on the Cu sites. The presence of impurities led to a degradation of the performance of the CuO/ZnO/Al2O3 catalyst. The extent of the activity loss was proportional to the poison-induced decrease in the exposed Cu surface area, suggesting that the poisons do not modify the nature, but rather the number of active sites. The Na-poisoned sample however suffered from more severe activity losses than expected due to the strong basicity of sodium. Deactivation with increasing time-on-stream was also observed over all catalysts, including the un-treated one, caused by thermal sintering. Apart from the reduction in CO2 conversion, all samples demonstrated a progressive decrease in methanol selectivity with time-on-stream, which was attributed to the disruption of Cu/ZnO synergy -which is crucial for methanol synthesis- caused by thermal sintering. Having gained useful insight on the catalytic materials that can be employed for the CO2 hydrogenation to methanol reaction, the next step was the development of intensification strategies to overcome the strong thermodynamic limitations that restrict methanol yield to low levels. The feasibility of the sorption enhanced methanol synthesis was demonstrated experimentally using admixtures of commercial Cu/ZnO/Al2O3 catalyst with zeolite FAU-13X as water sorbent. First, a robust experimental protocol that allows monitoring and quantification of the transient sorption phenomenon was developed, by combining continuous high frequency analysis of the reactor gas exit stream with rigorous calculations and multiple reference experiments. In the presence of the 13X zeolite, the integrated CO2 conversion for 120 min reaction time increases by 56 % compared to the corresponding experiment with the catalyst only and exceeds the equilibrium CO2 conversion at the specific conditions. The reaction temperature strongly affects activity and product distribution in both conventional and sorption enhanced CO2 hydrogenation. Highest methanol production was achieved at 275 °C, due to the significant increase in activity under these reaction conditions. However, the highest sorption enhancement occurs at 225 °C, with the methanol yield increasing by 115 % compared to the conventional process. Consecutive reaction – regeneration cycles lead to ~ 25 % activity reduction, due to changes in the textural properties of both catalyst and sorbent and incomplete regeneration of the zeolite. Increasing the regeneration temperature from 275 °C to 300 °C facilitates the products’ desorption and results in higher sorption capacity after each successive cycle, thus improving the cyclic stability of the process. The investigation was extended to explore the effect of different zeolites, namely zeolites LTA-3A, LTA-4A, LTA-5A and FAU-13X as suitable water sorbents for the process. The water and methanol adsorption/desorption capacity and kinetics of the zeolites were first investigated in a setup equipped with a thermogravimetric analyzer and a mass spectrometer and were correlated with the behavior of the sorbents in the sorption-enhanced process. Higher adsorption temperatures result as expected in significant decrease of the zeolites’ water adsorption capacity, with zeolite 13X presenting the highest water uptake at 250 °C, followed by 4A. Exposure of the zeolites to methanol and water-methanol vapors at 250 °C indicates that the zeolites adsorb methanol as well. Zeolites 3A and 5A were shown to possess mostly sites for preferential methanol adsorption as opposed to zeolites 4A and 13X, which mostly have sites where competitive H2O-CH3OH adsorption occurs. Desorption experiments showed that zeolites 5A and 13X require higher temperatures for complete regeneration that zeolites 3A and 4A. The different enhancement effect in the sorption-enhanced process in the presence of each zeolite strongly correlates to their adsorption/desorption properties. Zeolites 4A and 13X (with the highest water adsorption capacity) exhibited the highest enhancement effect (~56 % for CO2 conversion and ~70 % for methanol yield). The relative increase of methanol selectivity was attributed to the co-adsorption of methanol in the zeolites. The stability of the system varied depending on the employed sorbent, with zeolites 5A and 13X (which require higher temperatures for complete desorption) exhibiting the lowest stability and zeolite 4A the highest. Finally, considering that the thermodynamic equilibrium can be shifted by further converting one of the reaction products, 3D printing was explored as means to prepare structured acidic supports and bifunctional catalysts for the methanol dehydration and the one-step CO2-to-DME reaction, respectively. Using ZSM-5 based zeolites as acidity providers for the methanol dehydration reaction, structured supports were prepared by (i) indirect 3D printing, (ii) direct 3D printing, and (iii) direct 3D-printing of α-alumina support structures followed by in-situ hydrothermal synthesis of ZSM-5. Bifunctional catalysts were also prepared by impregnating the direct 3D printed acidic supports with optimal binder concentration with different loadings of Cu and Zn. The indirect 3D printed monoliths did not preserve the zeolite’s properties and were found to be inactive in the methanol dehydration reaction. Using the same starting material, direct 3D printed monoliths with varying binder concentration were prepared. Increasing bentonite binder content improved their printability and mechanical properties, but led to lower surface area and acidity due to the dilution with bentonite. However, it was evidenced that ZSM-5 crystallites retain their properties and remain unaffected by the additive manufacturing process. The direct printed monoliths were active in the methanol dehydration reaction. A clear correlation between the number of accessible acid sites and activity was evidenced, with the highest DME production (which was the only carbon product) achieved over the monolith with bentonite content 40 wt.%. This monolith also exhibited higher stability and resistance to coke formation compared to its powder counterpart. Impregnation of the optimal direct 3D printed monolith with Cu-Zn led to significant changes in acidity. The total acidity increased but Bronsted acid sites were not detected, indicating surface coverage of the acid sites of the monolith. The bifunctional catalysts presented poor activity but higher DME selectivity compared to the reference experiment with commercial CuO/ZnO/Al2O3 and ZSM-5 based zeolite powder admixture due to the improved metal-acid sites synergy. Substitution of zeolite powder with crystalline ZSM-5 in the optimal binder content for direct 3D printing led to the production of a highly active structured catalyst which -as the rest of the direct printed catalysts- retained the crystallite properties of ZSM-5 and reached equilibrium methanol conversion at T > 225 °C. In-situ crystallization of ZSM-5 on a direct 3D printed α-alumina substrate also led to the production of a highly active structured catalyst for the methanol dehydration reaction despite its low ZSM-5 loading. The conclusions drawn from the preparation, characterization and performance evaluation of the catalysts developed and investigated in this work, are expected to contribute to the efforts of the scientific community to create new, improved stable and low-cost catalysts for efficient CO2 utilization through its catalytic hydrogenation to value-added products. Based on the findings discussed in this thesis, future research should be directed in optimizing the parameters that can increase the population of the active sites for CO2 hydrogenation and enhance the synergy between the catalytic components as required for selective methanol or DME synthesis. Process wise, by studying the deactivation of commercial Cu-based methanol synthesis catalyst, the necessity to employ tailored systems for the purification of flue-gases intended for use as feed in CCU processes was evidenced. Concerning process intensification, the experimental verification of the sorption-enhanced concept combined with valuable insights into the effects of key parameters—such as operating conditions, sorbent properties, and cyclability—on the enhancement effect is expected to contribute towards its implementation in an industrial scale. To achieve this, further steps must be taken to upscale the process and bridge the gap between laboratory findings and industrial application.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
International Hellenic University
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Koidi, Vasiliki
  • Κοΐδη, Βασιλική

Subjects

dc:subject × 17

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/58321

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Koidi, Vasiliki; Κοΐδη, Βασιλική. Improving the efficiency of the catalytic hydrogenation of CO2 via intensified process concepts and novel catalysts. International Hellenic University, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/58321