Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

The dynamics of eros in Euripides and Plato: a comparative study of the Medea, the Hippolytus, the Symposium and the Phaedrus

Abstract

dc:description

This dissertation is a comparative study of specific works by Euripides and Plato and focuses on examining the theme of eros. This approach aims to shed new light on the study of eros in ancient Greece by attempting to examine systematically and in their entirety the convergences and divergences between the two authors in their works under consideration, in both content and their methods of addressing and presenting the theme of eros. By revitalizing the link between poetic and philosophical thought, the dissertation brings back to the fore and supports the position that Euripides’ drama is inherently philosophical and that Plato’s philosophy possesses a significant poetic dimension, particularly evident in the theme of eros. Both Euripides and Plato depict the complexities of erotic desire and relationships, albeit through distinct philosophical and poetic lenses. However, a detailed comparative analysis of their various concepts is currently lacking. The dissertation contends that comparing their approaches to eros can enhance the understanding of how eros was portrayed and philosophically explored in instances of Euripidean and Platonic creativity. This study re-examines classical texts by comparing two tragedies by Euripides, the Medea and the Hippolytus, and two dialogues by Plato, the Symposium and the Phaedrus, where eros emerges as a complex and multifaceted theme. The dissertation observes that current research does not readily offer answers to this perspective, prompting him to establish his own approach to addressing the issue at hand. In examining the commonalities between Euripides and Plato concerning eros, the dissertation emphasizes their shared approaches in content, expressive means, and purposes. About the content of eros, both explore eros intellectually, delving into its cosmic, psychological, emotional, and intellectual dimensions beyond mere physical desire. Moreover, Euripides and Plato utilize dialogue, myth, and several other poetic and dramatic elements as expressive means to convey their ideas about eros. Both Euripides and Plato use their works as a platform to raise questions that contribute to reflection and moral and intellectual development. However, their commonalities encompass elements of both convergence and divergence. The dissertation highlights the similarities between Euripides and Plato, addressing the expected differences due to their distinct literary genres when necessary. The dissertation posits that alongside Socrates, Euripides might have significantly influenced the intellectual development of the young Plato, despite the lack of direct historical evidence. This assumption is based on their shared cultural and intellectual milieu and the analysis of their works. Thus, the dissertation underlines that Plato acted as a reformer in the field of theater as well, connecting the Platonic dialogues with the poetry of Euripides through the prism of eros. However, this study does not focus solely on understanding Plato’s works. The dissertation, through the comparative study of the specific works of the tragic poet and the philosopher, attempts to go back to the deeper structure of the cultural and ideological background that shapes the portrayal of eros in both authors and both genres. By doing so, the dissertation seeks to enhance the understanding of both Euripides’ and Plato’s works. After the acknowledgments and the table of contents, the study begins with the first, introductory, chapter, followed by three core chapters that form the foundation of the research, culminating in the concluding chapter. The second chapter “From Tragedy to Plato” deals with a connection in content and form between Euripides and Plato. The third chapter “Poetic Dramaturgy of Eros” focuses on the expressive means and examples of their common poetic dramaturgy of eros. The fourth chapter “Content of Eros” presents the content and meaning of eros from both sides. The introduction begins by recognizing the extensive discourse on eros over time, which has equipped scholars with valuable tools and interpretative frameworks for re-examining classical texts and uncovering new insights (section 1.1.). It outlines the objectives of comparing the treatment of eros in Euripides’ two tragedies and Plato’s two dialogues, emphasizing the aspirations of this project (section 1.2.). The author of the dissertation explains the selection of the Medea, the Hippolytus, the Symposium, and the Phaedrus as the focal works for exploring this theme (section 1.3.). This is followed by an outline of the dissertation’s structure (section 1.4.) and a comprehensive review of existing literature, identifying both the basic works that inform this study and the gap it aims to address (section 1.5.). Key terms and concepts are then defined to ensure clarity and understanding before the reader proceeds with the exploration of eros in the selected works (section 1.6.). The introduction concludes by addressing interpretative approaches to Euripides’ and Plato’s texts, discussing elements such as layers of meaning, authorial intent, and the intellectual and artistic depth, present in their writings (section 1.7.).The second chapter explores the shared framework between Euripidean drama and Platonic philosophy, which form the foundation and context for their treatment of eros in Euripides’ Medea and Hippolytus, and Plato’s Symposium and Phaedrus. It examines how these seemingly distinct forms of expression –poetry and philosophy– interact and converge in these works. By focusing on their sociocultural context, this chapter highlights how both tragedy and philosophy were integral to Athenian society, serving as reflective mirrors of political and moral issues and exerting significant educational influence (section 2.1.). The chapter further discusses Plato’s reformation of tragedy, aligning it with philosophical ideas and virtues rather than emotional aspects (section 2.2.). Then, it illustrates the intersection between Euripides’ tragic poetry and Plato’s philosophy, noting that each incorporates aspects of the other, resulting in a blend of philosophical poetry and poetic philosophy (section 2.3.). According to this chapter, plays like the Medea and the Hippolytus explore philosophical themes such as virtue, justice, fate, human cognition, and eros, essential for philosophical inquiry, even though they do not form a cohesive philosophical system. Meanwhile, Plato’s work embodies a seamless integration of poetry and philosophy, using poetic elements like dialogue, character development, and narrative context to infuse his philosophical reflections with poetic depth. These insights reveal a connection in content and form, marking the transition from Euripides’ poetry to Plato’s philosophy. Consequently, this chapter serves as a bridge to the in-depth analysis presented in the following chapters. The third chapter explores how Euripides and Plato, within the comparative framework of two tragedies and two Platonic dialogues, employ a poetic dramaturgy of eros marked by several convergences. Both authors, each in their unique poetic style, utilize expressive means and techniques not to build a unified theory but to craft a diverse array of images and metaphors surrounding eros. This chapter highlights specific aspects of this shared dramaturgy, building on insights from the previous chapter. A key focus is the commonality in language and rhetoric concerning eros, as both Euripides and Plato infuse their works with rhetorical flair and poetic language about eros, intertwining these elements with their dramaturgy (section 3.1.). The use of myth is another focal point since both authors incorporate myth as a narrative form that aligns with the central values of their texts, as tools for uncovering truth, and as expressive means in their works (section 3.2.). Furthermore, this chapter presents the religious and ritual language as a component of poetic dramaturgy, linking eros to religious practices and sometimes involving mystery cults (section 3.3.). Additionally, the shared imagery and intertextual references to eros suggest that Euripides and Plato possess a mutual –to some extent– understanding of the power of eros imagery (section 3.4.). In discussing composition, this chapter delves into how Euripides and Plato combine dialogue with other narrative techniques (section 3.5.). The dialogue form in their works encourages spectators or readers to engage critically with the presented arguments, while techniques like frame narration and temporal shifts enhance the engagement. Special attention is given to the dramatic structure of the Symposium, noting its similarities with tragic poetry or its role as an advanced example of Plato’s poetic dramaturgy (section 3.5.1.). The chapter also identifies common ground in constructing and utilizing dramatic characters involved in eros, whose complexity is vital to the dramatic impact of these works, focusing on characters such as Medea, Phaedra, Socrates, and Alcibiades (section 3.6.). The final section emphasizes the significance of dramatic scenery in shaping the overall experience, setting the tone and atmosphere, creating a sense of time and place, accommodating the action, and reinforcing overarching themes (section 3.7). All these parallels underscore the interconnectedness of Euripides’ and Plato’s perspectives on eros at the level of literary expression. These interpretative insights allow for a unified prism of analysis and help substantiate the thesis that eros in Plato’s dialogues shares numerous elements with its portrayal in Euripides’ tragedies. Building on the previous chapters that examined socio-cultural and grammatological aspects as well as expressive techniques in erotic poetic dramaturgy, the fourth chapter delves into the deeper meanings, interpretations, and content that Euripides and Plato attribute to eros. It argues that numerous points of convergence and divergence can be identified in how eros is portrayed in the four selected works. This chapter first explores the cosmic setting and the relationship between eros and the divine in each work, asserting that the portrayal of eros as a divine or cosmic force is a significant common thread in both Euripidean and Platonic representations, albeit depicted in various ways (section 4.1.). It then examines the physiology of the soul in relation to eros, focusing on the emotions elicited by erotic desire and their influence on human thought and action (section 4.2.). It highlights the internal conflict within the soul of characters like Medea, Phaedra, and the Platonic lover, where emotions and reason contest for dominance in decision-making (section 4.2.1.). Both authors see emotions as integral to the soul, profoundly affecting cognition and actions, with knowledge also emerging from emotional intensity (section 4.2.2.). This chapter also investigates how erotic madness is depicted as a disease in each work, exploring the symptomatology of eros as a physical and mental affliction (section 4.3.). Both Euripides and Plato employ medical vocabulary related to emotional suffering to express erotic passion, particularly concerning the brain and mental health. Subsequently, the balance between rational and irrational elements regarding eros is discussed, suggesting the existence of an “erotic rational madness”, a blend of reason and madness in one of humanity’s most potent experiences, eros (section 4.4.). Further, this chapter discusses some physiological aspects of eros as a comparative field between the four works (section 4.5.). It examines how beauty is perceived through the eyes and how erotic desire is incited (section 4.5.1.). Then, it offers some of the key distinctions between Euripides’ and Plato’s conceptions of the physiological aspects of eros, focusing on three crucial elements: the nature of the erotic object and aim, the distinction between bodily and mental eros, and the role of eros as an agent of moral goodness and happiness (section 4.5.2.). The interpersonal dynamics of erotic relationships are also explored, highlighting how these aspects are reflected in each author’s works (4.5.3.). By investigating these physiological aspects, this section highlighted additional aspects of their shared perceptions and contrasting ways they conceptualize eros and desire, elucidating the differing philosophical and literary treatments of eros. The chapter concludes by examining the complex interplay of gender elements within eros, as depicted by Euripides and Plato (section 4.6.). This section challenges societal norms and offers new perspectives on gender dynamics in eros during the fifth and fourth centuries BCE, particularly focusing on how each gender adopts elements of the other. This approach reveals another convergence point in the understanding of eros between the two authors’ works and emphasizes these texts as repositories of gender perspectives. Overall, this chapter elucidates the deeper meanings attributed to eros by both authors, demonstrating numerous parallels in how Euripides and Plato conceive eros in their respective works. In the concluding chapter, a concise summary of the previously presented chapters is provided (section 5.1.), along with interpretations of both tragic and Platonic eros (section 5.2.). This chapter emphasizes the complex narrative structures used to depict and dramatize the dynamics of eros (section 5.3.) and highlights how Plato evolved the concept of tragic eros, enhancing our understanding of the period’s perception of eros (section 5.4.). Additionally, this chapter discusses the reflections and explorations prompted by both genres (section 5.5.). It also outlines the challenges and opportunities for further research in this area (section 5.6.). Finally, the bibliography includes the works cited throughout the dissertation. Based on the presentation that was outlined above, the dissertation reaches specific conclusions about the exploration of eros in Euripides’ two tragedies and Plato’s two dialogues. The alignment between Euripides and Plato concerning the essence of eros stems from their mutual recognition of its enduring qualities. These characteristics of eros encompass its connection to the divine, its influence on the human soul and the soul’s complexity, its irrational and rational dimensions, and its formative and social facets, but are also linked to the poetic and dramatic methods used in the depiction of these features. This alignment suggests that both thinkers, through their keen observations, identified fundamental aspects of eros that remain consistent across different contexts. Their agreement, more profound than what might be expected from their shared historical or cultural backdrop, indicates a deep understanding of eros’ intrinsic characteristics. Nonetheless, the way each side articulates this understanding diverges significantly. Euripides explores eros through the lens of drama and tragedy, where personal narratives and emotional complexities come to the fore leading to severe tragic consequences. Plato, on the other hand, examines eros with a philosophical approach, seeking to understand its role within broader metaphysical and ethical frameworks and presenting it as a catalyst for the ascent toward knowledge. Thus, their perceptions of eros manifest distinctively within their respective poetic and philosophical milieus. Nevertheless, despite their divergences, this dissertation proves that the study of Euripides and Plato reveals significant commonalities in their approach to the subject of eros, employing similar expressive means, concepts, and objectives related to moral inquiry and reflections on human nature. The dissertation introduces new insights and paves the way for further exploration into the connection between tragic poetry and Platonic philosophy in relation to eros. It brings to the surface the question about the connection between Euripides and Plato by examining specific aspects of their works, providing a convincing explanation of the nature and form of this connection. The critical stance Plato takes toward tragic poetry is well-known and has been extensively noted. However, as this dissertation demonstrates in its introduction, systematically exploring Plato’s convergence with tragedy is limited and almost non-existent in what concerns the connection between Euripides and Plato through their treatment of eros in the four works examined in this study. This dissertation fills this significant research gap, offering a modern approach to the topic.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Katsarelis, Evangelos
  • Κατσαρέλης, Ευάγγελος

Subjects

dc:subject × 24

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/58370

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Katsarelis, Evangelos; Κατσαρέλης, Ευάγγελος. The dynamics of eros in Euripides and Plato: a comparative study of the Medea, the Hippolytus, the Symposium and the Phaedrus. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/58370