Back to search

Ελληνικό Μεσογειακό Πανεπιστήμιο

The impact of the European Central Bank's monetary policy on security returns and bank credit expansion: a complete approach using quantitative methods

Abstract

dc:description

One of the dominant research topics of the last decades in the field of financial economics is the impact of monetary policy on various financial assets. Studies concerning the period before the global financial crisis analyze mainly Fed’s conventional monetary policy . In the 1990s, many researchers used vector autoregressive (VAR) models to explore the long term influence of regular monetary policy on equity returns (Patelis 1997; Thorbecke 1997). Ehrmann and Fratzscher (2004) as well as Bernanke and Kuttner (2005) used event study analysis to examine how the Fed’s policy rate changes affect the US financial markets. When the severe economic crisis hit financial markets in 2007, ECB, in collaboration with other major central banks, launched new unconventional monetary policy measures to stabilize capital markets, revive economic activity and enhance credit expansion. New non-conventional monetary policy tools were a historic milestone in global monetary policy having decisively contributed to the solvency of the whole financial system. More specifically, during the financial and sovereign debt crisis the ECB reduced its key interest rates to zero lower bound, offered unlimited liquidity in fixed interest rate to euro area MFIs, extended the maturity of longer term refinancing operations, expanded the list of eligible collateral in refinancing operations and conducted small scaled purchases of assets via the first and second Cover Bond Purchasing Programs (CBPP I-II) and the Securities Markets Program (SMP). ECB also announced the Outright, open market, Monetary Transactions program (ΟMTs) which was never activated. In the low inflation period, ECB engaged in credit easing measures (targeted longer term refinancing operations) and quantitative easing measures (large scaled security purchases through the expanded asset purchasing program- APP) to address the risk of deflation. Also, the ECB lowered the deposit facility rate to negative territory and offered forward guidance on the future direction of its monetary policy. In the covid-19 crisis period ECB announced a pandemic emergency (asset) purchasing programme (PEPP) and non-targeted pandemic emergency longer-term refinancing operations (PELTROs) to neutralize the covid-19 related risks. Several research papers have explored the impact of the ECB’s non-conventional monetary policy decisions on stock prices (see among other Rogers et al. 2014; Georgiadis and Gräb 2016; Haitsma et al. 2016; Fratzscher et al. 2016; Pacicco et al. 2019; Chebbi 2019; Weale and Wieladek 2022; Van der Zwan et al. 2024). Furthermore, recent previous studies have examined the efficiency of the ECB’s non-conventional operations on bank credit supply (see, among others, Gambacorta and Marques-Ibanez 2014; Boechx et al. 2017; Martins et al. 2019; Grandi 2019; Boechx et al. 2020; Benetton and Fantino 2021; Burietz and Picault 2023; Sleibi et al. 2023).Considering previous research, the aim of this doctoral thesis is to contribute to the literature by investigating as well as by explaining the effect of non-conventional monetary policy measures on stock prices and on credit growth of the euro area. The impact of ECB’s monetary policy on Eurozone has become crucial to the research field because the unified monetary policy carried out by the ECB concerns member states with separate fiscal policy, heterogeneous economic systems and state structures, as well as different business cycles. The first chapter of the doctoral dissertation describes analytically the evolution of the ECB’s unconventional monetary policy measures from the eruption of the financial crisis to the covid-19 pandemic crisis. The second chapter of this thesis studies whether expansionary conventional and non-standard monetary interventions introduced by the ECB, affected market equity returns of eight eurozone countries in the medium run. In addition, to investigate whether stock markets reacted heterogeneously to expansionary monetary policy innovations and to other covariates we grouped our country sample into two sub-samples, core countries and peripheral countries. Results showed that expansionary conventional monetary policy has a positive and statistically significant lagged impact on equity market returns with different levels of statistical significance for the entire country sample, the core countries, and the peripheral countries. We also documented that ECB’s non-conventional expansionary interventions had a positive and statistically significant lagged impact on core eurozone markets that were less influenced by the economic crisis. Peripheral countries experienced credit rating downgrades and were forced to apply economic adjustment programs that increased investors’ uncertainty during and after the sovereign debt crisis, boosted capital outflows from these markets and decreased expectations about unconventional monetary policy measures. The second empirical study explores the impact of the ECB’s monetary policy on stock returns of the four systematically important Greek regional MFIs for the period January 2007 to August 2018. We used event study analysis with multivariate panel regression models and a data set of 103 important interventions introduced by the ECB, for both traditional and non-standard monetary measures. We classified the ECB’s monetary interventions into four categories: interest rate increases, interest rate cuts, monetary easing (i.e. asset purchases), and extra ordinary liquidity. For overlapping announcements that contain two or more interventions the study adopts the procedure of Ricci (2015), Fiordelisi and Galloppo (2018), to select the most relevant intervention. For each intervention we calculate cumulative abnormal reruns (CARs) up to three days event window (-1,+1). By estimating a panel regression model using dummy variables procedure we found that interest rate cut announcements (introduced mainly in the first stages of crisis), had positive and statistically significant impact on Greek MFIs΄ CARs in a very short event period of three days. On the other hand, the harmful consequences of Greek debt crisis, the three economic and adjustment programs implemented by the Greek government, the restructuring of public debt and the recapitalization of the systemic Greek banks from the official sector, limited the effectiveness of non-standard measures, because investors gradually lost confidence towards Greek economy and the local banks. The third study employs event study and panel econometric analysis similar to the second in order to examine the stock response of fourteen large European banking institutions to the announcement of the ECB’s expansionary policy interventions from July 2007 to December 2020. The main difference with the second study, is that the third study deals with overlapping announcements that contain two or more measures with out to use subjective criteria to select the most relevant measure because it could lead to the loss of a significant number of observations. To keep all expansionary measures in the sample we include a specific set of dummy variables in our model to process overlapping announcements. Findings suggest that investors give great attention to the ECB’s actions as both standard and non-standard expansionary policies have a positive impact on bank stocks in different event windows. Among the expansionary measures, asset purchases have the largest and longest impact on bank stock returns. In the fourth empirical study we explore the effectiveness of the ECB's nontraditional measures in boosting bank credit in the euro area. In contrast with previous studies which use bank-level credit data (see, among others Gambacorta 2005; Gambacorta and Marques-Ibanez 2014; Grandi 2019; Boechx et al. 2020, Burietz and Picault 2023) this research employs country aggregate loan data for fifteen euro area economies for the period July 2007 to June 2021. We process monthly data from three main categories of aggregate loans, and more specifically, total loans in euro area residents, loans to the private sector and loans to non-financial corporations and use panel regression analysis with different model specifications to analyze credit channel. Empirical findings suggest that the ECB’s non-regular measures (proxied by alternative variables) indeed support credit expansion and are in line with the results of previous studies. Moreover, the cross-country analysis indicates the presence of heterogeneity in the transmission of non-regular policy on credit, revealing weaker effects for distressed eurozone economies as they were more affected by the financial and debt crisis. In comparison with previous studies, the current doctoral thesis contributes to literature in several ways. More specifically, the first research study uses panel regression models with monthly data and the dummy variables method in order to analyze the medium-term effect of expansionary monetary policy measures on stock market indices returns. Previous papers use either event analysis studies with panel regression models and daily data (Falagiarda and Reitz 2015; Georgiadis and Gräb 2016; Rici 2015; Haitsma et al. 2016; Fiordelisi and Galloppo 2018; Pacicco et al. 2019; Chebbi 2019) in order to investigate the very short-term effect of monetary policy on security returns (Georgiadis and Gräb 2016; Rici 2015; Haitsma et al. 2016; Fiordelisi and Galloppo 2018; Pacicco et al. 2019; Chebbi 2019), or use VAR models to investigate the medium to long run relationship (Boechx et. al. 2017, Lewis and Roth 2019; Evgenidis and Papadamou 2021; Weale and Wieladek 2022, Van der Zwan et al. 2024)The motivation for the second empirical study was the fact that there was no research in the literature that exclusively concerns the effect of monetary policy on the stock prices of the four systemic Greek banks. These banks operated in a national economy that was disproportionately affected by the debt crisis, as it was in recession for a long period of time, faced significant budget deficits, and had to implement three fiscal adjustment programs to avoid default. The third empirical study, in relation to previous papers, not only examines the influence of each expansionary monetary policy measure on the stock returns of large-sized European banks, but also proceeds to the evaluation of the strength and persistence of each measure. Finally, the fourth study contributes to the literature by demonstrating a structural change in the impact of non-regular interventions on credit as it finds a limited (smaller) effect in the first, pre zero bound subperiod, due to the smaller size of these interventions during this subperiod.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Ελληνικό Μεσογειακό Πανεπιστήμιο
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Petrakis, Nikolaos
  • Πετράκης, Νικόλαος

Subjects

dc:subject × 22

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/58553

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Petrakis, Nikolaos; Πετράκης, Νικόλαος. The impact of the European Central Bank's monetary policy on security returns and bank credit expansion: a complete approach using quantitative methods. Ελληνικό Μεσογειακό Πανεπιστήμιο, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/58553