National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η έμφυλη διάσταση στο δίκαιο: ταυτότητα, λόγος, σώμα
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe PhD thesis proposes a critical perspective on modern law, as well as on leading legal categories, focusing on the examination of the gender dimension in law. To this end, it draws on key contributions from critical theory, critical legal studies and primarily from feminist theory and feminist legal theory, particularly second-wave feminism and French difference feminism. The thesis attempts a retrospective look at the roots of modern legal thought, arguing that its structural core was constituted on the basis of a subject paradigm that only ostensibly reflected a universal ideal-type. The examination of its ontological and metaphysical constitution, alongside its positioning in terms of its historical, social and cultural context highlights the androcentric characteristics upon which the modern legal subject was constructed in contrast to female otherness. As it is embedded in this perspective, law is studied as an influential parameter of the broader context of modern Western thought and the cultural meanings upon which it was founded. In parallel, legal conceptualizations and institutions are re-examined in the light of their dialectical relation to structural elements of modern social formation, such as the public-private dichotomy. Developing the inherently hierarchical constitution of this dichotomy, alongside other homologous binary dichotomies, the thesis argues for the necessity of a positive reaffirmation of feminine difference, as the foundation of a potentially different, yet equivalent subject. The thesis divides its analysis into three interrelated sections. The first section sets identity as its thematic focus. It analyses the fundamental characteristics of the modern subject and the subject of law, while drawing attention to the historical, political, social and especially the cultural, cognitive and conceptual terms of its formation. Abstraction, autonomy, universality, rationality are analysed as conceptual constructions produced on the basis of the male position, experience and condition. It is further emphasized that modernity has been an era of unconditional faith in the subject and its solemn legal safeguarding, but also an era of women’s exclusion from the realm of the subject, with a notable contribution of law to this end. Finally, the foundations that a potential feminine identity could oppose are explored. The second section refers to discourse. Pointing out the decisive importance of discourse in the formation of the subject, as established in recent decades within the framework of social and critical theory, it contrasts the one-dimensional rationality of modern legal discourse with a potentially feminine discourse. The subject-object relation demonstrated as the focus of legal regulation is opposed to the subject-subject relation introduced by feminine discourse as the key for restoring equal gender relations. However, the inherently difficult access of women to discourse is underlined, due to their long-standing marginalization within the discursive field. Consequently, the terms and contents that are potentially capable of shaping a feminine discourse are interrogated. The third section addresses the issue of embodiment. It examines the radical devaluation and disregard for the embodied existence in Western culture, as a result of the juxtaposition of the body against the superior concept of the mind and reason. The significant contribution of law to this disregard is analysed, as the legal subject was also founded on the mind and reason in contrast to the body. Given that women were conceived as connected to the body in modernity, the hostile attitude towards it functioned as a focal point of female subordination. The section aligns with the feminist theory argumentation that body, identity, and subjectivity are inseparable factors from the feminine viewpoint and calls for the restoration of the positive meaning of female embodiment.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2012
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsakistraki, Christina
- Τσακιστράκη, Χριστίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Φεμινιστική θεωρία
- Φύλο και δίκαιο
- Κριτικές νομικές σπουδές
- Θεωρία δικαίου
- Κοινωνιολογία δικαίου
- Λυς Ιριγκαρέ
- Feminist theory
- Gender and law
- Critical legal studies
- Theory of law
- Sociology of law
- Luce Irigaray
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Νομική επιστήμη, διεπιστημονική προσέγγιση
- Law
- Social Sciences
- Law, interdisciplinary
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58808