Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Βυζαντινή αισθητική και φυσικό περιβάλλον

Abstract

dc:description

Greek philosophical thought persisted throughout the Byzantine period, where it continued to shape the contours of intellectual and aesthetic discourse. Byzantine philosophy, though permeated by Christian theological frameworks, retained profound influences from Plato, Aristotle, and Plotinus. Classical Greek aesthetics, as articulated by these thinkers, addressed not only the nature of the aesthetic object but also the ethical implications arising from it. In Platonic terms, artistic creations are construed as imitations—or eidola—of the higher, intelligible realm of Ideas. This paper explores the philosophical and aesthetic conceptions of ‘Sublime’ and ‘Beautiful’ from antiquity to medieval, and modern eras, with particular emphasis on their significance within Byzantine aesthetics. These aesthetic categories have been central to the evolution of philosophical thought and artistic production, shaping both taste and the criteria of elegance from antiquity the medieval period through the Enlightenment and into the present. These concepts have captivated the attention of thinkers across historical epochs, and from the eighteenth century onward, they have come to significantly inform prevailing standards of elegance and aesthetic judgment. The concept of calisthesia - a mental faculty that governs aesthetic discernment and guides human preferences and behavior - is foregrounded as a key element in this discourse. Importantly, the sublime and the beautiful, as they have been defined and problematized by various philosophers, extend beyond representations of quotidian experience to engage deeply with the nature and purpose of art itself. Special emphasis is placed on the articulation of beauty as it appears in the visual arts, including painting, architecture, monumental art, and, notably, iconography. It examines how the Byzantine worldview integrates natural environment, theological cosmology, and artistic expression in a way that transforms classical ideas of beauty and sublimity. Through an analysis of key Byzantine monuments of Chios, including Nea Moni, the Monastery of Moundon, and the church of Panagia Krina, the paper traces how Byzantine aesthetics reconfigures the tension between transcendence and immanence, horror and harmony, elevation and intimacy. In doing so, it contributes to a broader understanding of how the Sublime in Byzantine art is not merely an emotional or perceptual experience, but a theophanic event-an encounter with the divine through nature and form.In the first two chapters, the notions of the beautiful and the sublime are examined through the lenses of classical philosophers such as Plato, Aristotle, and Plotinus, as well as major thinkers of the medieval period. According to Plato, the beauty perceived in the material world is but an image, a shadow of true beauty, which exists in the realm of Ideas. While he admits art as a pedagogical instrument, it remains for him a representation of an ideal that transcends materiality. For Plato, the beautiful is that which elicits admiration, and the genuine apprehension of beauty is an act of knowledge. Ugliness and ignorance stand in antithesis to beauty and truth. Notably, in Timaeus, he emphasizes the connection between beauty and moderation, highlighting symmetry and order as expressions of the Good. By contrast, Aristotle anchors beauty in the material and empirical realm. For him, beauty arises from the order and proportion of parts and is thus logically and objectively grounded. Art imitates nature’s perfection, and the beautiful is defined by measurable qualities such as symmetry and harmony. Plotinus, on the other hand, situates beauty within the metaphysical sphere, associating it with spiritual purity and inner virtue. Matter is considered a degradation of being, while true beauty is linked to the soul’s alignment with the divine. For Plotinus, artistic beauty reflects the inner moral and spiritual state of the creator. Art, therefore, is a means of ascending from the sensible to the intelligible world. In medieval philosophy, beauty becomes deeply entangled with the divine. Augustine identifies God as the ultimate source and artist of beauty, while Thomas Aquinas and Pseudo-Dionysius the Areopagite assert that beauty originates in the relationship between God and the human soul. The beautiful becomes an expression of divine harmony and anagogic symbolism. In the modern period, philosophers developed more analytical approaches to beauty and the sublime. Spence defined beauty as the result of uniformity among the features of an aesthetic object, while Hutcheson emphasized the sensory pleasure beauty evokes, in contrast to rational or intellectual judgment. Hume proposed that aesthetic judgments are subjective, shaped by individual perception and mental faculties. Burke, in distinguishing the beautiful from the sublime, associated the former with gentle pleasure and the latter with a mixture of awe and fear—an experience linked to the removal of pain and the encounter with vastness or terror. Reid sought to restrict the generalization of beauty by tying it to concrete experiences, such as landscapes or works of art, suggesting that aesthetic appreciation is a specialized function of the intellect. Kant, in his Critique of Judgment, distinguished the beautiful as finite and harmonious, and the sublime as infinite and overwhelming. Beauty, he argued, soothes the soul, whereas the sublime evokes awe, elevating the moral self. For Kant, natural beauty holds primacy over artificial beauty, and art imitates nature rather than embellishing it. The sublime resists sensory comprehension, engaging reason beyond empirical experience. Heidegger later reframed the relationship between the artist and the artwork, asserting that each brings the other into being. He challenged the dominance of both subjectivism and objectivism in aesthetics, advocating for a more ontological understanding of art's role in revealing truth. The third chapter investigates the presence of the sublime in Byzantine art and aesthetics. Emerging around 330 AD, Byzantine artistic production encompassed a wide array of forms including painting, mosaics, architecture, and woodcarving. Christian artistic expressions, which initially adorned catacombs, evolved through ecclesiastical traditions and theological imperatives. Byzantine painting, developing from the sixth century onward, emphasized on spiritual depth over naturalism. Art became the expression of the inner person, a medium through which faith in God was both manifested and cultivated. Ancient Greek aesthetics informed this visual culture, yet the tragic view of human existence found in antiquity was transfigured into a hopeful vision of salvation through Christ. In this context, the sublime emerges as the central aesthetic category expressing the divine ideal. According to Michelis, beauty pertains to form, while the sublime pertains to content, the metaphysical and theological depth within the artwork. Unlike the monumental and sensory grandeur of Western ecclesiastical art, which externalizes the sublime, Byzantine art internalizes it, embodying calm, restraint, and an idealistic spirituality that preserves core principles of the Hellenic spirit. Light plays a central role in Byzantine aesthetics, especially in sacred architecture such as Hagia Sophia. The structure’s interplay between dome and window fosters an atmosphere of suspension, symbolizing divine transcendence. Here, the icon becomes one with architecture and light, eliciting not simply a visual response but an inward spiritual ascent. The icon is not approached with secular aesthetic criteria; rather, its contemplation demands doctrinal understanding and spiritual preparedness to enter into the mystery it communicates. The concept of aesthetic Byzantinism, as elaborated by Professor George Arambatzis, and the phenomenological interpretations of Michel Henry, highlight the deep integration of art, spirituality, and perception within the Byzantine world. The fourth chapter offers a detailed analysis of the architectural and iconographic heritage of Byzantine Chios, focusing on temples, mosaics, and sacred spaces. As part of the Byzantine Empire for six centuries, Chios became a vibrant center of monasticism, fostered by imperial patronage and the island’s wild natural beauty. Early Christian basilicas and monasteries remain as testimonies to the island’s spiritual and aesthetic vitality, preserving invaluable historical and artistic legacies. The fifth chapter traces philosophical attitudes toward nature from Pre-Socratic philosophy to Byzantine theology. For early thinkers, the divine and the natural were intrinsically interwoven, constituting the fundamental mystery of existence. With the advent of Christian theology, this relationship evolved into a triadic model—God, nature, and humanity—where the divine becomes the ultimate reference point for all aesthetic and existential inquiry. The idea of the Sublime, as developed by Longinus in Peri Hypsous, connects rhetorical elevation with spiritual grandeur, opening the path for later philosophical interpretations by Edmund Burke and Immanuel Kant, in which the Sublime emerges as an experience of overwhelming vastness or power that destabilizes the rational subject. Yet, the Byzantine understanding of such experiences differs fundamentally: it does not isolate the sublime from the beautiful, nor does it oppose the soul to the world. Rather, in the Byzantine worldview, the aesthetic categories are embedded within a cosmology of divine order, wherein the visible world is not autonomous but a symbolic vehicle for divine presence. This synthesis is nowhere more evident than in Byzantine art, where landscape, architecture, and iconography interweave to mediate theophany—manifestations of the divine within created reality. The natural world is not depicted for its own sake but as a reflection of the uncreated light; form becomes a threshold through which the sacred reveals itself. Beauty, in this context, is not simply the harmonious or the pleasant, but that which draws the soul upward, anagogically, toward the divine. The Sublime, accordingly, is not located in terror, vastness, or contradiction, but in the tension between immanence and transcendence: the divine made visible in matter, without being contained by it. Chios, with its remarkable Byzantine monuments, provides a unique microcosm in which these aesthetic principles are embodied. The Nea Moni, an 11th-century monastery inscribed in a secluded mountainous landscape, presents a spatial and symbolic synthesis of cosmology and ascetic elevation. Its mosaics, suffused with golden backgrounds and hieratic figures, reflect a transcendent light that is not of this world, yet intimately intertwined with it. Similarly, the Monastery of Moundon, with its painted depictions of the Heavenly Ladder (Klimax), reveals the drama of salvation not as abstract theology, but as visual liturgy, structured around the ascent of the soul through struggle and grace. The church of Panagia Krina, embedded in the fertile valley of central Chios, exemplifies how nature and sacred architecture coalesce to create a space where the boundary between the earthly and the heavenly becomes porous. In these examples, we see how Byzantine aesthetics does not separate the beautiful from the sublime, nor does it merely aestheticize theology. Instead, it manifests a third path, one where the aesthetic is a mode of knowing—a way of participating in truth through symbol and form. The Sublime becomes a theophanic event, not merely a heightened emotional response but a metaphysical encounter. Beauty leads to awe not through its perfection, but through its capacity to reveal something beyond itself, something eternal and uncontainable. Thus, the Byzantine Sublime is not the experience of being dwarfed by nature’s chaos or vastness, as in the modern notion, but the quiet astonishment before the divine order that shines through the visible. It is an experience marked by silence rather than violence, reverence rather than rupture. In this light, the aesthetic categories of the Sublime and the Beautiful find new meaning - not as oppositional poles, but as intertwined modes of divine disclosure.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Varoni, Maria-Markella
  • Βαρώνη, Μαρία-Μαρκέλλα

Subjects

dc:subject × 32

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/58815

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Varoni, Maria-Markella; Βαρώνη, Μαρία-Μαρκέλλα. Βυζαντινή αισθητική και φυσικό περιβάλλον. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/58815