National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Ανάπτυξη μεθοδολογίας γεωμετρικής τεκμηρίωσης και προσδιορισμού παραμορφώσεων έργων ζωγραφικής αξιοποιώντας μεθόδους ακρίβειας
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis dissertation focuses on the study and creation of a methodology that combines the fields of geodesy and precision measurements with the technical examination requirements for the preservation and restoration of cultural heritage assets. Specifically, this methodology refers to the geometric documentation of paintings and the study of their deformations over different epochs. The motivation was the combination of two thoughts: the importance of safeguarding cultural heritage and the assets it encompasses, and the integration of geodesy and precision measurements into a field where photogrammetric data are predominantly used. The originality of the dissertation lies in:▪The precision measurements and geodetic knowledge which is used for the geometric documentation of paintings. ▪The use of advanced measuring systems such as articulated measuring arms and laser trackers (which are mainly used in industrial applications) and now are used for the study of cultural heritage objects, such as paintings. ▪The multi-criteria analyses for the selection of the appropriate equipment and documentation method. ▪The geodetic deformation models which are utilized and tested for detecting and predicting position changes of points in a painting. ▪The statistical analysis which is performed to draw conclusions regarding the existence or not of deformations in paintings. ▪The geodetic networks that are utilized to merge clouds, avoiding the scanning of a large overlap between them. ▪A flexible documentation methodology for paintings, which can be "moved" and performed in various environments. ▪A documentation methodology for paintings, which can extract three-dimensional information in real time, unlike other geometric methods, such as photogrammetry. ▪The methodology that is developed for tracking and modeling lost brushstrokes in artworks that have undergone damage. ▪The new ways of depicting deformations in three dimensions. ▪The recoding of all the stages regarding the implementation of the proposed methodology. The dissertation is divided into three parts, structured into respective chapters. First Part This part consists of six chapters (1–6) and addresses the literature review and detailed recording of related issues. Specifically, the dissertation is based on combining the core principles of technical examination for the preservation and restoration of cultural heritage assets with the field of precision measurements and deformation analysis in geodesy. Each chapter of Part One delves into a specific scientific area for completeness. In the first chapter, the value of cultural heritage and the assets it encompasses are described, with particular emphasis placed on their preservation and restoration. The basic principles of conservation, the importance of the conservator’s role, and their work are presented, while the terms invasive conservation, restoration, as well as preventive conservation and maintenance, are clarified. Lastly, significant emphasis is given to the documentation of conservation, outlining what it should include and why it is the most critical tool for a cultural asset. In the second chapter, all diagnostic methods for the technical examination of paintings are recorded and analyzed in detail. These are essentially non-destructive methods used to examine, identify, and document the damages and alterations of a painting, which may also include dating processes. More specifically, imaging and chemical methods are analyzed, which study spectroscopic data to identify the materials and other characteristics of the artwork. Additionally, measurement methods are examined, utilizing photogrammetric data to extract geometric features and create three-dimensional models of the paintings. In the third chapter, the concept of positional change and deformation analysis is described, as defined within the field of geodesy, with particular emphasis on models for detecting changes in spatial points. Descriptive models as well as cause-effect models are analyzed, and deformation detection algorithms currently applied to paintings are presented. In the fourth chapter, methods and processes for predicting the positional change of a point are introduced, with special emphasis on the requirements for predicting deformations in paintings. The fifth chapter records and thoroughly analyzes all aspects of precision measurements. After describing their scope, the equipment currently in use is presented in detail. Precision geodetic total stations, coordinate measure machines, laser trackers, as well as articulated measuring arms are analyzed. For each of these, the principles of operation, measurement methodologies, and error sources are discussed, along with the calibrations and checks required to ensure accurate and reliable results. Finally, in the sixth chapter, information is provided regarding the selection of the most suitable equipment and method for the specific dissertation. A multi-criteria decision analysis is conducted among the equipment presented in the fifth chapter, examining the characteristics and requirements of conservators for accurate and reliable geometric documentation of paintings. Based on the evaluation criteria, the use of an articulated coordinate measuring arm is chosen for smaller paintings, while a combination of an arm and a laser tracker is selected for larger paintings. Additionally, in this chapter, the most appropriate algorithm for determining deformations in paintings is identified, with the methods C2C and M3C2 found to deliver the best results. Second Part In this part of the dissertation, which consists of four chapters (7, 8, 9, and 10), the proposed methodology for geometric documentation, deformation determination, and prediction in paintings is fully analyzed and documented. Each step of the methodology is described in detail, and its application to various paintings is presented to assess its functionality. Specifically, in the seventh chapter, every step of the methodology for geometric documentation of paintings is described. This includes:❖ Selection of the most suitable equipment based on the size of the painting and its preparation❖ Geometric documentation, or scanning of the painting❖ Data processing for the point cloud❖ And finally, creation of the three-dimensional model. To ensure accuracy and reliability in the measurements, specific checks and calibrations must be carried out on the measurement systems during the preparation stage. These are described in detail in the eighth chapter and concern both laser trackers and articulated measuring arms. In the ninth chapter, the methodology for determining and predicting deformations in paintings is presented in detail. For deformation determination, the following steps are carried out:❖ Alignment of models from different epochs,❖ Statistical testing for the presence or absence of deformations,❖ Deformation calculation,❖ And, finally, visualization of the results. For prediction, time-series data and information related to the pigments of each painting are required. Finally, in the tenth chapter, the proposed methodology is applied to four different paintings. These include works on canvas, paper, or wood, with variations in both their pigments and the deformations they have undergone. Each painting was subjected to controlled deformation, geometrically documented at least at two different time periods, and the differences (deformations) between these periods were calculated. The experiments conducted are summarized as follows:Α/Α Support Size (cm x cm) Pigments Deformation1ο Wood 35 x 24 Icon painting colors Scratching/Material removal2ο Paper 200gr 29.7 x 42 Alcohol-based markers Exposure to high humidity3ο Canvas 40 x 60 Oil paints Color removal4ο Paper 640gr 42 x 76 Watercolors Spraying with water Third Part The final part of the dissertation consists of a single chapter (11), where the overall conclusions and proposals are presented. It is demonstrated that the proposed documentation methodology can produce immediate and highly accurate results (within a margin of ±50μm),generating three-dimensional data for artworks before, during, and after the conservation process. In the eleventh and final chapter, the findings are summarized, and several suggestions are made for further research continuation.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Ioannidou, Stefania
- Ιωαννίδου, Στεφανία
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Γεωμετρική τεκμηρίωση
- Εντοπισμός παραμόρφωσης
- Μετρήσεις ακρίβειας
- Συντήρηση έργων ζωγραφικής
- Geometric documentation
- Deformation detection
- High precision measurements
- Conservation of paintings
- Άλλες Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογίες
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Μηχανική, διεπιστημονική προσέγγιση
- Other Engineering and Technologies
- Engineering and Technology
- Engineering, interdisciplinary
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58896