National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Contextualizing the emergence of engineering ethics: the case of Al ethics
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn this dissertation, I seek to offer a contextualization of engineering ethics with a focus on AI ethics. My research aimed at making such contextualization part of the formulation of a framework for the reconceptualization and resolution of concrete problems and dilemmas. This framework is deemed necessary for the whole spectrum of engineering practice from the engineering education and research, to the implementation of specific technologies and the designation of short- and long-term engineering policies. The concerns and challenges involved pervade all fields of engineering and the whole range of engineering practice. They are constitutive of ICT engineering, biomedical engineering, and environmental engineering. They are, similarly, ubiquitous in and constitutive of the general education, edification and formation of engineers both as professionals and individuals, of the implementation of specific technological configurations, of the advancement of specific research projects, of the management of both human and material resources, of the designation of long-term engineering policies. Therefore, the outcome of my research will constitute a substantive contribution to all the aforementioned areas and aspects. More specifically, regarding the academic impact, my research hoped to advance the self-consciousness of the field by enabling a deeper and better understanding of engineering practice. This entails the coherence and more efficient integration of the different engineering fields in a unified whole. To that effect, the formulation of a framework for the reconstruction and resolution of dilemmas, problems, and impasses concerning both technological research and implementation is deemed necessary for the educational formation of the engineer and the enlightened designation of research possibilities. The formulation of such a framework designates, at the same time, that the social impact of my research output is equally valuable. First, it seeks to foster a socially and ethically responsible stance of the engineer as a professional and educator. More crucially, my research responds to the great contemporary challenges. Thus, in turn, it enables the informed designation of concrete short- and long-term technological policies in all the aforementioned engineering fields. First, I offer a general introduction related to engineering ethics, technology ethics, and AI ethics. In the second chapter, I begin with a brief introduction to the history of engineering and technology ethics to clarify two key points: first, that engineering is not about some neutral progress of technology; and second, technology ethics is not the same as engineering ethics. Next, I review ethical theories within the context of technology ethics, as these frameworks are commonly applied by ethicists, philosophers, and engineers to interpret the relationship between technology and society in ethical terms. Drawing on Actor Network Theory and the Strong Program, I examine STS perspectives on technology’s non-neutrality and the “black box” concept, which are essential for constructing a comprehensive framework for technology ethics. In the third chapter, I focus on engineering ethics, offering a contextual overview of the key issues, codes of ethics, and relevant cases associated with this field. In the fourth chapter, I argue that a comprehensive approach to AI ethics should encompass the following five elements. First, a critical history of AI that examines the social, economic, and political contexts in which AI is designed, developed, and utilized, rather than focusing solely on technical advancements. Second, a review of commonly discussed AI ethics topics—such as fairness, accountability, and transparency—to highlight gaps in these frameworks. Third, an exploration of AI’s “black box,” not just from a technical viewpoint but also in terms of the political, social, and economic forces that shape and sustain it, uncovering hidden social relations, labor, and the lack of true “intelligence” in these systems. Fourth, a critical analysis of specific AI cases through perspectives that consider capitalism and its interconnected social, political, and economic dynamics, where biases, inequalities, and discriminations are seen not as flaws but as intrinsic aspects of AI. Fifth, an investigation of AI’s hidden labor and the implications for the future of work, critiquing AI’s perceived autonomy while exposing the harsh working conditions of certain laborers. Discussions on the future of work should move beyond simplistic notions of capitalism’s cycle or abstract ideas of ethical AI in the workplace; they should instead address the social, political, and economic foundations of our society and critically assess the current capitalist model. Together, these elements form the basis for an adequate AI ethics study. In the fifth chapter, I start with an introduction to the secondary literature on Institutes, Centers, labs, groups, and initiatives that focus on engineering ethics and AI ethics. Next, I explain the methodology for selecting some of them, contextualizing their activities, and categorizing their research areas and topics. Finally, I conclude the chapter with an evaluation of the primary research findings. In the sixth chapter, I begin with a review of secondary literature on engineering ethics and AI ethics Initiatives. Here, “Initiatives” refers to courses, modules, programs, curricula, resources, and teaching materials. This review is essential for understanding the importance that universities place on engineering ethics and AI ethics, and their efforts to prepare (engineering) students to navigate these ethical challenges. Next, I explain the methodology of my primary research. Third, I present the primary research, focusing on various Initiatives, especially courses and modules. Fourth, I evaluate the primary research, assessing the proportion of universities that have developed such Initiatives, which underscores the significance of addressing challenges in AI and engineering ethics. In the seventh chapter, I begin with an overview of the role of professional engineering societies in promoting engineering ethics, raising various questions about how these societies support engineers. Next, I examine the case of IEEE and its involvement in the development of the ethics of engineers, drawing on both primary and secondary literature.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Konstantis, Konstantinos
- Κωνσταντής, Κωνσταντίνος
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Ηθική της Μηχανικής
- Ηθική της Τεχνολογίας
- Ηθική της Τεχνητής Νοημοσύνης
- Σπουδές επιστήμης και τεχνολογίας
- Σπουδές Μηχανικής
- Engineering Ethics
- Technology Ethics
- Artificial Intelligence (AI) Ethics
- Science, Technology, Society and Science and Technology Studies
- Engineering Studies
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Ιστορία και Φιλοσοφία της επιστήμης
- Ηθική
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
- Humanities and the Arts
- History and Philosophy of Science
- Ethics
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/58924