National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Integrated framework for seismic risk assessment of oil refineries: insights into structural vulnerabilities and operational interdependencies
Abstract
dc:descriptionCrude oil refining facilities are critical infrastructure for modern society facilitating the refinement of crude oil, through a network of interconnected and complex structures. These structures include assets directly involved in the refining process as well as containment assets to store the crude oil, the intermediate products and the final oil-based liquids and gasses. The seismic risk associated with these facilities is significant: an earthquake can lead to severe structural damage, operational disruptions, and financial losses. Moreover, cascading hazards such as fires, explosions, and pollution can pose threats to surrounding communities and the environment. To investigate the intricacies of assessment studies of refineries, a virtual mid-size oil refinery located in a high-seismicity region in Greece has been developed as a comprehensive testbed. This testbed provides detailed estimations of structural damage caused by seismic events and serves as a tool for improving resilience assessment methodologies. It includes a robust dataset, accessible via a dedicated repository, comprising probabilistic seismic hazard analysis results, site-specific hazard-consistent ground motion records, and a detailed exposure model encompassing critical assets like storage tanks, pressure vessels, process towers, chimneys, a flare, and equipment-supporting buildings. Additionally, nonlinear dynamic analyses using reduced-order numerical models provide record-specific asset demands and fragility estimates. Contextual descriptions of each asset’s role in the refining process are also included, along with a damage state homogenization methodology that translates asset-level damage into facility-wide consequences. This integrated framework highlights the role of each asset in maintaining the refinery’s structural and operational integrity and sets a foundation for broader risk assessment studies. Using the testbed, the consideration of the refinery’s operational status alongside its significance and influence in seismic performance is explored. Fuel production levels, internal product circulation, and storage vessel fill ratios fluctuate due to production cycles, seasonal demand, and maintenance schedules. These variations, particularly in fill ratios, are critical for storage assets, yet they are often overlooked or rather simplified in traditional risk assessments. Alternative operational scenarios are modeled to reflect periods of high demand, low demand, routine operations, and maintenance shutdowns. The study identifies the most probable damage states for assets under these scenarios, demonstrating how seismic outcomes vary depending on operational conditions. Comparisons with typical simplified scenarios underscore the biases implied by those simplifications, and thus the importance of considering operational variability in seismic risk assessments. It is important to note that the refinery’s performance is evaluated both at the asset level and system-wide. Metrics such as damage distributions, the percentage of assets in specific damage states, and business continuity indicators provide a comprehensive view of the facility’s resilience. Additionally, the testbed challenges the conventional fragility curve approach, which assumes an aggregation of responses from different ground motions. By retaining the correlations between ground motions and asset responses, the study highlights biases in conventional methods when examining systems of structures and demonstrates the potential of distortions in risk assessment results when such correlations are ignored. The alternative methodology proposed emphasizes the need for improved approaches to account for the interconnected nature of refinery systems, ultimately enhancing their seismic resilience.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Karaferis, Nikolaos
- Καραφέρης, Νικόλαος
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Σεισμική διακινδύνευση
- Κρίσιμες υποδομές
- Σεισμική τρωτότητα
- Διυλιστήρια πετρελαίου
- Seismic risk assessment
- Critical infrastructures
- Fragility analysis
- Refineries
- Επιστήμη Πολιτικού Μηχανικού
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Δομοστατική
- Civil Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
- Structural Engineering
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59120