National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Experimental (and theoretical) study on inhibition or promotion of hydrates formation for applications of high industrial impact
Abstract
dc:descriptionHydrates are ice-like, non-stoichiometric, crystalline materials that are formed from self-assembled water molecules under appropriate pressure and temperature conditions when certain guest molecules are present as well. The guest molecules play a crucial role in stabilizing the three-dimensional water cages/cavities that are formed. Within these cages a significant amount of the guest molecules can be selectively enclathrated. This particular characteristic property of hydrates has resulted in the consideration of hydrates for gas-storage and transportation applications (e.g., “energy carrier” gases such as hydrogen and methane), and their use in gas-mixture separation applications. Furthermore, the exclusion of ions from the classical hydrate crystals has rendered hydrates attractive to be used in water desalination or water purification processes. In either case, in order to design a particular industrial application, it is essential to have reliable values for the hydrate equilibrium pressure and temperature conditions. In order to obtain such information, one can perform either:• molecular level simulations• macroscopic level phase equilibria calculations• experimental measurements Comprehensive reviews of hydrate-related studies at the molecular level have been presented, including extensive discussion of Monte Carlo (MC) simulation methods in clathrate hydrate studies. Phase equilibria calculations using Molecular Dynamics (e.g., following the phase coexistence approach) have been reported for the case of pure (CH₄, CO₂, H₂) or mixed (CH₄ + CO₂) hydrates. On the other hand, MC-based approaches for hydrate phase equilibria have also been reported. Phase equilibria calculations can also be performed on a macroscopic level, based on the coupling of an equation of state and the van der Waals–Platteeuw statistical theory. Such an approach can produce results fast (as opposed to the molecular level simulations which require heavy computations) and is the preferred approach of the industry. However, the accurate calibration of the methodology requires the availability or performance of a number of experimental measurements. Experimental methods that are commonly used in hydrate-related systems to measure phase equilibria conditions include: the isochoric pressure search (IPS), the phase boundary dissociation (PBD), the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), the high-pressure DSC, the micro-DSC, the Cailletet apparatus, etc. An extensive collection of experimental data on hydrate phase equilibria (Hydrate–Liquid water–Vapor, H–Lw–V; or Hydrate–Ice water–Vapor, H–I–V) of pure and mixed hydrate-forming systems has been reported, focusing primarily on three-phase equilibrium studies published before 2009.Depending on the industrial application of interest, hydrate formation can be either encouraged or discouraged. For example, if the application of interest is “Flow Assurance” during oil/gas production and transportation, the inhibition of hydrate formation is required within the flow lines since possible hydrate formation can disrupt oil/gas production and may result in significant additional cost. Hydrate inhibition can be either thermodynamic or kinetic. During thermodynamic inhibition, effort is devoted to shifting drastically the hydrate equilibrium line (i.e., avoid hydrate formation), while during kinetic inhibition the effort is focused on controlling the kinetics of hydrate formation and hydrate particle agglomeration in such a way that the produced fluids from the oil/gas wells are out of the flow lines before any hydrate-based blockage can occur. On the other hand, if the application of interest is gas storage (e.g., in the form of hydrate) or gas mixture separation, the promotion of hydrate formation is desirable since it can result in lowering the capital and operational cost. Hydrate promoters are hydrate-forming components that can be either gases or water miscible/immiscible liquids that result in shifting the hydrate equilibrium line to more favorable conditions (i.e., lower pressures and higher temperatures). Hydrate formation at more moderate conditions with the help of a promoter is an attractive feature for a number of applications (e.g., gas storage in mobile applications) since the more moderate conditions can function towards increasing the safety features of the industrial application. Typical hydrate promoters that are employed in experimental studies include among others tetrahydrofuran (THF), ethylene oxide (EO), cyclopentane (CP), cyclohexane (CH), methylcyclopentane (MCP), etc. Of special interest to the current study is the binary gas mixture (CO₂ + CH₄) that is encountered primarily in natural gases. Due to quality specifications of the natural gases, purification processes are required in order to achieve CH₄ purity according to standards and regulations. Extensive reviews and discussions have been presented on conventional and emerging process technologies for the purification of natural gases. Conventional industrial methods (i.e., currently used by industry) for gas purification include absorption, adsorption, etc., while emerging methods (i.e., under study for possible future use) include among others the use of hydrates for gas mixture separations. Studies have examined the use of gas hydrates for the purification of natural gases with high CO₂ content, as well as the decontamination of well-gas streams using hydrates to obtain a methane-enriched gas product. These studies considered the use of hydrates for separation without the presence of any additives. Additional studies have also considered the effect of hydrate promoters on the particular gas mixture separation.1.2 Hydrate StructureGas hydrates are solid inclusion compounds which are formed when water and gas come into contact under high pressures and low temperatures. Small guest molecules—such as methane, carbon dioxide and nitrogen—are enclathrated by hydrogen-bonded water molecules that form 3-dimensional cavities. The most common hydrate structures encountered in nature are Structure I (sI), Structure II (sII) and Structure H (sH). Structure I is the most common in the natural environment and contains small guest gases (0.4–0.55 nm). Each unit cell of the sI hydrate consists of 46 water molecules that form two types of cavities: the small, a pentagonal dodecahedron (5¹²), and the large, a tetrakaidekahedral cage (5¹²6²). There are 2 small and 6 large cavities per unit cell of sI hydrate. Structure II generally occurs with larger guest gases (0.6–0.7 nm) in mostly man-made environments. Each unit cell of the sII hydrate consists of 136 water molecules that form two types of cavities: the small (5¹²) and the large (5¹²6⁴). There are 16 small and 8 large cavities per unit cell of sII hydrate. Structure H is a hexagonal structure that may occur in any environment, with mixtures of both small and large molecules (0.8–0.9 nm). Each unit cell of the sH hydrate consists of 34 water molecules that form three types of cavities: a smaller cage (5¹²), a medium-sized (4³5⁶6³) cage, and a large icosahedral cage (5¹²6⁸). There are 3 small, 2 medium, and 1 large cavities per unit cell of sH hydrate. Water molecules form hydrogen bonds in a basic building block for all structures I, II and H, called the 5¹² (pentagonal dodecahedra). Within the cavity, small guest molecules are enclathrated, with limited translation motion but substantially more rotation and vibration ability. The 5¹² building blocks are joined to other 5¹²s either through the vertices (structure I) or through the 5¹² faces (structure II).All structures need to fill space within their cavities to prevent hydrogen-bond strain and breakage. The 5¹² basic building blocks cannot fill space without bond breakage, so interstices are filled with other cavities to relieve the strain. This includes incorporating hexagonal faces: two in the 5¹²6² cavity of structure I, and four in the 5¹²6⁴ of structure II. Thus, the cages can contain larger guest molecules. The cages form basic repeating unit crystals with ratios of 2•5¹² + 6•5¹²6² in structure I and 16•5¹² + 8•5¹²6⁴ in structure II. In structure H, the unit crystal consists of 3•5¹² + 1•5¹²6⁸ + 2•4³5⁶6³. Although both large and small cages are present in each crystal structure, sometimes single guests are too large for the smaller cage, which must go empty. However, smaller molecules can fill both cages. In all three structures, typically there is only one guest molecule per cage. However, at very high pressure, it is possible to have multiple-cage occupancy with very small guests, such as hydrogen or noble gases. For example, hydrogen can form hydrates with up to two occupants in the small cage and four in the large cage of structure II. Such multiple occupancies are considered an exception. Remarkably, when all hydrate cavities are filled, the three crystal types have similar component concentrations: 85 mol% water and 15 mol% guest(s). Hydrate formation most likely occurs at the interface between the bulk guest and aqueous phases. The solid hydrate film at the interface acts as a barrier, requiring fluid surface renewal for continued clathrate formation. The type of structure formed depends primarily on the size of the guest molecule. Methane fits into both the small and large cages of sI, whereas propane is too large for the sI large cage but fits into the sII large cage, thus forming sII. Gas hydrates in oil and gas pipelines are mainly sII due to the presence of methane and heavier hydrocarbons. Conversely, most naturally occurring deposits are sI because they are composed mainly of methane. Thermogenic deposits with heavier hydrocarbons may form sII or, in rare cases, sH.1.3 Objectives Of primary interest are gas mixtures that have significant industrial applications and include components such as carbon dioxide, nitrogen, hydrogen, methane, ethane, propane, hydrogen sulfide, and oxygen. The examined mixtures include at least one of the aforementioned gases. These hydrate-forming systems are encountered during the production and transportation of gas/oil (“upstream” industry) or during the separation/purification of gas mixtures relevant to refineries and petrochemical (“downstream”) industries. The main scope of this study was to design, construct, and test/validate a novel experimental apparatus for measuring the three-phase equilibrium conditions of pure gas and gas mixture hydrates. The novel experimental apparatus was designed to successfully perform the following tasks:• Measure the pressure (P) and temperature (T) conditions during two-phase (Lw–V) or three-phase (H–Lw–V or H–Lw–Lg) equilibria of pure gases or gas mixtures.• Perform quantitative analysis of the liquid phase (i.e., solubility measurements) under two- or three-phase equilibrium conditions. A significant novelty of the constructed apparatus was that it successfully performed both tasks while maintaining construction costs within the limited available budget. Finally, an extensive evaluation of a simple model for three-phase equilibrium calculations of mixed gas hydrates (relevant to gas-mixture separations) was performed. The model calculations were compared with: (i) extensive experimental data, and (ii) results from a commercial simulator.1.4Structure of Thesis In the third chapter of this study, we review the experimental studies that have reported three-phase hydrate equilibrium measurements. We focus primarily in studies that were published after the year 2008. Furthermore, we report only studies that examine gas mixtures of two or more components that contain any one of the nine components considered in Section 1.2. The results of this literature study have been published in a review paper. In the fourth chapter of this study, we discuss the construction and test/validation of the novel experimental apparatus. Experimental data that are related to the measurement of three-phase equilibrium conditions are routinely reported in the literature by standard experimental studies. For example, Sloan and Koh provided a detailed list of experimental measurements and techniques, and a detailed archive of hydrate experimental measurements is presented by NIST. T. Eslamimanesh et al reported an extensive review of experimental hydrate studies that are of interest to applications related to gas mixture separation. On the other hand, the quantitative analysis of the liquid phase is significantly more complicated and, therefore, only a limited number of studies (i.e., when compared to those related to the first task) have been reported that proceed to address the particular issue of measuring the hydrate guest solubilities in the liquid phase. While the majority of those experimental studies focus on the measurement of the guest-gas solubilities of pure gas hydrate systems, a limited number of studies focus on the measurement of solubilities of gas-mixture hydrate systems. The experimental device consists of a high-pressure PVT cell with a gas and a liquid sampling branch, enclosed in a thermostated air cabinet, along with electronics and monitoring equipment. The gas sampling branch consists of a sample loop between two valves, while the liquid sample branch consists of a similar sampling loop and an adjacently placed pressure relief cell, where the liquid sample is flashed and left to expand. Both sampling branches are connected to a Gas Chromatograph (GC) through a three-way valve for the analysis of the gas mixture composition. A temperature control sleeve is firmly mounted around the PVT cell and is connected to a temperature control system. The PVT cell is fed by the gas preparation manifold. A gas mixture of the desired composition is prepared in the primary vessel. To produce the gas mixture, the primary vessel was first cleaned by purging with high purity nitrogen followed by vacuuming with a turbomolecular pump (10-6 mbar). Then the filling of the vessel was done by introducing each gaseous component separately up to a certain pressure. After filling, the gas mixture should be thoroughly mixed to ensure that all components are evenly distributed throughout the vessel contents. Subsequently, the gas mixture was compressed by the booster into the empty high-pressure cell, until the desired initial experimental pressure would be achieved and analyzed through the gas sampling branch to have the initial composition. The sampling branches, the PVT cell, the GC branch, as well as the primary vessel are connected to a high vacuum turbomolecular pump assisted by a rotary pump so that they can be evacuated when necessary. For the case of experiments with binary gas mixtures the use of a GC is necessary, so that the composition of gas mixtures could be accurately measured. In particular, GC analysis is performed for the following three cases: (i) during the preparation of the initial gas mixture that is fed to the PVT cell, the composition of the gas mixture in the preparation manifold is obtained. (ii) The final gas phase composition (i.e., after full equilibration is attained) is also obtained through GC analysis. (iii) A liquid sample that is obtained after full equilibration is attained is expanded in the pressure relief cell and the resulting gas phase is analyzed with GC. The first and second cases are facilitated through the gas sample branch, while the third case through the liquid sample branch. The gas sample is analyzed by flashing the sample through the GC, until the sample pressure is equal to atmospheric. In such a way the GC results are pressure independent. The results are obtained in molar gas percentage form. The liquid sample is obtained by expansion of the vapor phase from the pressure relief cell to the GC loop, which is under high vacuum. The resulting pressure is often lower than atmospheric pressure. The GC results are obtained in partial gas pressures form. In chapters 5-7, the experimental results that were carried out during this study are presented. In particular: In chapter 5, the apparatus was validated by performing hydrate equilibrium measurement experiments for two systems of pure gas hydrates (i.e., CO2 + H2O and CH4 + H2O). To this purpose, two different experimental methods are utilized. In particular, the isochoric pressure search method was implemented for the measurement of seven, three-phase equilibrium P–T points for the first system, while two for the second system. Alternatively, the phase boundary dissociation method was implemented for the measurement of four, three-phase equilibrium P–T points for the first system, while one for the second system. In total, twenty experimental measurements are reported regarding the three-phase equilibrium P–T conditions for two systems of pure gas hydrates examined in the current study. The measurements obtained are compared against reported experimental values in the literature and very good agreement is found for both systems examined. Based on our experimental measurements in the close neighborhood below and above the upper quadruple point (i.e., four phases are at equilibrium: H−LW–Lg–V), Q2, for the case of the CO2 + H2O system we were also able to provide an estimate of the location of Q2. To this purpose our experimental data below and above Q2 are fitted to two optimum curves and Q2 is estimated as the point where the two curves intersect. Following such an approach we estimate Q2 at K and MPa. The current values are in good agreement with the average values reported in literature, as well as the value calculated using the commercial simulator CSMGem. We also reported measurements of gas solubilities in the aqueous phase during three-phase (H–Lw–V or H−LW–Lg) equilibrium conditions. Good agreement, between measured and literature-reported experimental or calculated values, is observed for the case of CH4 solubilities, while reasonable agreement is found for the case of CO2. In addition to validating the apparatus we also reported measurements in pressure/temperature areas where gaps in literature existed. The novel experimental device, along with the pure gases experimental results, have been published. In chapter 6, The experimental device was then utilized to perform experimental measurements to measure the hydrate equilibrium measurements and gas solubility measurements at either three-phase or two-phase equilibrium conditions for the ternary system CO2 + CH4 + H2O. The isochoric pressure search (IPS) method was implemented in order to measure thirteen, three-phase equilibrium P – T points for the ternary system CO2 + CH4 + H2O. Additionally, the phase boundary dissociation (PBD) method was implemented for the measurement of two, three-phase equilibrium P – T points for the same ternary system. Effort was made in order to perform experimental measurements under conditions that no other experimental measurements are reported in the literature. The obtained hydrate equilibrium measurements were compared against reported experimental values in the literature and calculated values with the commercial simulator CSMGem and very good agreement was found for the ternary system examined. The current study also reports measurements of gas solubilities in the aqueous phase during three-phase equilibrium conditions. Reasonable agreement, between measured and reported experimental or calculated values, was observed. Additional solubility measurements were also performed at conditions that are close to the three-phase equilibrium line. The experimental results for the ternary system CO2 + CH4 + H2O have been published69. Finally, in chapter 7, a further series of experimental measurements of the ternary methane – carbon dioxide – water system under two phase (Vapor–Liquid) equilibrium conditions was performed at conditions where hydrates are not forming. Experiments for the solubility measurement were performed at 100 bar, 323.15 K and various compositions of the gas mixture. The solubilities of the pure gases in the aqueous phase have been also measured for the cases of carbon dioxide and methane, respectively. The experiments for the aqueous solubilities of the pure gases deviate by only 2.8% and 3.6% for carbon dioxide and methane respectively from the values calculated with the correlative models of reported experimental data by Duan et al., and Sun and Duan for carbon dioxide and methane, respectively. We observe good agreement between the new experiments and the measurements by Al Ghafri et al. performed at equimolar gas composition. It should be noted, that the new experimental measurements clearly indicate that the solubility of each gas decreases by the addition of the other gas. The particular conclusion is in excellent agreement with the conclusion obtained from the re-examination of the experimental data from Dhima et al. at 344.25 K and from Qin et al. for at 324.5 K and 375.5 K. The experimental results for the experimental measurements of the ternary methane – carbon dioxide – water system under two phase (Vapor–Liquid) equilibrium conditions have been published. In the eighth chapter, an extensive evaluation of a simple model for three-phase equilibrium calculations of mixed gas hydrates that are of practical interest to gas-mixture separations was performed. The model of interest calculates the equilibrium pressure of the mixed gas hydrate using a simple combination rule that involves: (i) the hydrate dissociation pressures of the pure gases involved, and (ii) the gas mixture composition. In particular, we examine the methodology presented by Lipenkov and Istomin. The particular approach has been used extensively and successfully in polar science studies, as well as, research related to space science where the temperatures are very low (i.e., below the freezing point of pure water, which is also close to the lower quadruple point (i.e., four phases are at equilibrium: H−I–Lg–V), Q1, of the corresponding hydrate systems). However, to the best of our knowledge, the particular method has not been examined systematically for cases of higher temperatures, which are going to be of interest to practical industrial applications of gas mixture separations. Gases of interest to the current study include those that are discussed in section 1.2. (i.e. carbon dioxide, nitrogen, hydrogen, methane, ethane, propane, hydrogen sulfide). Such gases are encountered in typical industrial applications. The purpose of the study is twofold: (i) to extend the Lipenkov–Istomin methodology to mixed gas hydrate systems of industrial interest by calculating the parameters of pure components that are not available, with emphasis at conditions above the Q1, and (ii) to evaluate the quality of the predictions of the three-phase equilibrium conditions by comparing to experimental measurements. Reported experimental measurements (i.e., the recent experimental data collection reported by Kastanidis et al. is utilized for the current analysis) are compared against: (i) calculations using the examined Lipenkov–Istomin methodology, and (ii) estimations based on a commercial simulator (CSMGem). As a result the range of applicability of the Lipenkov–Istomin method is delineated. An extensive series of calculations using the examined methodology was performed and the calculations were compared against available experimental measurements, as well as with the CSMGem simulator. It should be noted that the intent of the study was not to replace the CSMGem simulator with the proposed methodology but to examine if a simpler and more computationally efficient methodology can produce reasonable results (at least within some specific temperature, pressure and composition range) that can be used during the preliminary stage of the design of processes. After all the theoretical basis behind CSMGem or other similar van der Waals-Platteeuw-based models is significantly stronger than the simplified Lipenkov-Istomin approach. Reasonable agreement between experiments and calculations was obtained considering the simplicity of the methodology. The agreement was better at lower values of the hydrate equilibrium pressure. The results of the evaluation of the simplified model for three – phase equilibrium calculations of mixed gas hydrates, and their comparison to reported experimental measurements, as well as the results of simulations using the commercial CSMGem simulator have been published. Finally, in the ninth and final chapter, the conclusions that resulted from this study are reported in addition with recommendations for future work. In brief, a novel device for experimental measurements of phase equilibria was designed, constructed and validated, which was able to perform, i. vapor – liquid, and ii. hydrate – liquid - vapor phase equilibria experimental measurements with results that are in good agreement with other reported experimental results, as well as with values calculated via simulations. The construction of this device is deemed successful, as it provided reliable results within the available budget set by the funding grant. Experimental measurements were performed under conditions that no other experimental measurements are reported in the literature. We have also considered the simple methodology proposed by Lipenkov – Istomin for the calculation of the hydrate equilibrium pressure of gas mixtures. Comparison with experimental results and the results obtained by the commercial simulator CSMGem have also been performed. Gas mixtures of interest to this study were binary or ternary mixtures that were made up of different combinations of components. Such gas mixtures are encountered in practical industrial applications of gas mixture separations.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kastanidis, Panagiotis
- Καστανίδης, Παναγιώτης
Subjects
dc:subject × 22- Υδρίτες αερίων
- Πειραματικές μετρήσεις
- Τριφασική ισορροπία
- Μετρήσεις διαλυτότητας
- Ισορροπία Υδρίτη
- Τριμερές σύστημα Μεθανίου - Διοξειδίου του Άνθρακα - Νερού
- Διαλυτότητα
- Διαχωρισμός μιγμάτων αερίων
- Εφαρμογές βιομηχανικού ενδιαφέροντος
- Gas Hydrates
- Experimental measurements
- Three-phase equilibrium
- Solubility measurements
- Hydrate equilibrium pressure
- CH4 Hydrates
- CO2 Hydrates
- Methane + Carbon Dioxide + Water Ternary System
- Επιστήμη Χημικού Μηχανικού
- Επιστήμες Μηχανικού και Τεχνολογία
- Χημική μηχανική
- Chemical Engineering
- Engineering and Technology
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59178