University of Thessaly (UTH)
Διατροφικές προκλήσεις και φυσιολογία θρέψης σε εκτρεφόμενους υδρόβιους οργανισμούς
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe aim of the present study was to evaluate the effect of partially or totally replacement of fishmeal and fish oil by low trophic organisms, with or without the use of fishmeal trimmings in conventional and organic gilthead sea bream’s (Sparus aurata) growth performance, feed utilization, digestibility, metabolism, proximate composition of white muscle, amino acid and fatty acid profile of white muscle, midgut microbiota and histological alteration of liver, anterior and posterior gut. Such low trophic ingredients included single cell proteins from Methylococcus capsulatus, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Schizochytrium limacinum and Phaeodactylum tricornutum, insect meal from Hermetia illucens and tunicate meal from Ciona intestinalis. In total, four experimental trials were conducted in the Aquaculture Laboratory of the University of Thessaly, in Greece. In the first feeding trial the fishmeal was partially replaced by a mixture of fishmeal trimmings, M. capsulatus, S. cerevisiae and sunflower meal, and fish oil was totally replaced by fish oil trimmings, rapeseed oil and Schizochytrium sp. in the diet. In the second feeding trial the organic fishmeal trimmings were replaced by a blend of M. capsulatus and S. cerevisiae and organic fish oil from fish trimmings was replaced by rapeseed oil and Schizochytrium sp. in organic diet. In the third feeding trial, fishmeal was partially replaced by H. illucens or C. intestinalis and totally replaced by a mixture of H. illucens, C. intestinalis, P. tricornutum και Schizochytrium sp. and in the fourth feeding trial was evaluated the use of Schizochytrium sp. as lipid source in diet without fish oil instead of the use of fish oil in combination with P. tricornutum in the diet.In the first feeding trial, 360 S. aurata juveniles with initial mean weight 5.91±0.03 g and initial mean length 7.74±0.01 cm were randomly allocated in 12 tanks. Four isonitrogenous (48.6% protein) and isolipid (16.5% lipids) diets were formulated, where fishmeal of Control diet was 50%, 75% and 100% replaced by LFiFo mixture at 20% (LFiFo20), 25% (LFiFo25) and 30% (LFiFo30) levels accordingly. LFiFo mixture contained fishmeal trimmings, bacterial protein (M. capsulatus), yeast (S. cerevisiae) and sunflower meals. Furthermore, the fish oil of Control diet was completely replaced by fish oil trimmings, rapeseed oil and Schizochytrium sp. Fish fed the experimental diets to apparent satiation for 45 days and at the end of the experimental trial, fish fed LFiFo diets had significantly (p<0.05) reduced feed consumption and growth performance, with no effect on their feed efficiency (p>0.05). Nonetheless, the intermediary liver metabolism remained unaffected (p>0.05) by dietary treatments, and only lactate dehydrogence (L-LDH) decreased (p<0.05) in fish fed LFiFo diets. In addition, muscle lipid content significantly (p<0.05) increased, and the protein content decreased (p<0.05) in the fish of LFiFo dietary treatments, as a result of dietary lipids usage for muscle storage instead of oxidizing for energy. In the second feeding trial, 480 S. aurata juveniles with initial mean weight 6.87±0.07 g and initial mean length 8.26±0.02 cm were randomly allocated in 12 tanks. Fish were fed three times a day at apparent satiation for 60 days with four organic isonitrogenous (48.2% protein), isolipid (16.2% lipids) and isoenergetic (21.3 Kj) diets, to evaluate the fish growth performance. After the end of 60 days, fish fed twice a day for 30 days, to evaluate the digestibility of feeds. The Control diet contained fishmeal trimmings and fish oil trimmings as the main protein and lipid sources, which were partially replaced at 5% (SCI12), 20% (SCI15) and 35% (SCI18) by a SCI mixture and rapeseed oil. SCI mixture consisted of bacterial protein (M. capsulatus) and yeast (S. cerevisiae) meal, with the addition of 1% Schizochytrium sp. At the end of the 60-day feeding trial, the results indicated that the replacement of fishmeal trimmings with SCI mixture at all tested levels significantly (p<0.05) increased the feed consumption, feed digestibility (lipid, starch, energy) and growth rate of the fish. Furthermore, citrate synthetase activity (CS) decreased (p<0,05) in fish of SCI dietary treatments, suggesting difficulties in using the Kreb’s cycle for energy supply. In addition, muscle lipid content increased, and protein content decreased (p<0.05) in fish fed SCI12 and SCI18 diets. SCI feeds had a positive impact on midgut bacteria of gilthead sea bream, causing an increase in host-beneficial bacterial families. Moreover, the histological observation of the liver revealed that fish fed SCI diets had small lipid droplets in hepatocytes, that were in accordance with the increased (p<0.05) hepatosomatic index. The anterior and posterior gut had a normal structure with no signs of inflammation. In the third feeding trial, 720 S. aurata juveniles with initial mean weight 6.57±0.04 g and initial mean length 8.16±0.01 cm were randomly allocated in 12 tanks and fed four diets using low-trophic-level ingredients for 65 days at apparent satiation. For this feeding trial, four isolipid (15% lipid) diets were formulated, where the fishmeal of the Control diet was replaced at 21.14% by insect meal (H. illucens) (IM) or at 21.12% by tunicate meal (C. intestinalis) (TM). An additional diet was formulated to completely replace the fishmeal and fish oil of Control diet with a mixture of Schizochytrium sp., insect (H. illucens), tunicate (C. intestinalis) and microalgae (P. tricornutum) meals (0%FMFO). At the end of the feeding trial the results showed that the fish fed the IM and ΤΜ diets had reduced (p<0.05) growth performance. Fish fed IM diet had significant (p<0.05) increased muscle and liver lipid content, although in the present study the insect meal was defatted. Histological observation of the liver revealed large lipid droplets around the pancreatic islets and nuclei displacement in hepatocytes of IM-treated fish. Growth performance of fish fed the 0%FMFO diet was unaffected (p>0.05) by the absence of fishmeal and fish oil in the feed, however voluntary feed intake was significantly (p<0.05) increased, without adverse effects on proximate composition of the muscle. However, excess fat accumulated in the liver, caused large lipid droplets around pancreatic islets. In all dietary treatments, the presence of beneficial bacteria in the midgut of fish and normal structure of anterior and posterior gut were observed. In addition, the fishmeal replacement feeds activated different metabolic pathways due to the different combinations of feed ingredients, without causing stress response in fish.In the fourth feeding trial, 360 S. aurata juveniles with initial mean weight 6.43±0.06 g and initial mean length 8.1±0.02 cm were randomly allocated in 6 tanks. For this feeding trial two isonitrogenous (44.4% protein), isolipid (14.8% lipids) and isoenergetic (22.6 Kj) diets were formulated. The PA diet contained 8% microalgal meal (P. tricornutum) and fish oil as the main lipid sources, while the HA diet contained 8.23% Schizochytrium sp., without fish oil. The fish were fed at apparent satiation for 45 days and at the end of the experimental trial the feed consumption and growth performance of the fish remained unaffected (p>0.05) by the dietary treatment, indicating that the use of Schizochytrium sp. instead of fish oil did not adversely affect the fish growth. Voluntary feed intake increased significantly (p<0.05) in fish fed the HA diet and resulted in a higher feed conversion ratio. Although both diets were isolipid, they activated different lipid metabolic pathways caused by the different dietary lipid sources. In addition, PA and HA feeds induced similar (p>0.05) stress response in fish. Regarding midgut microbiota, fish fed PA diet were observed with increased bacterial abundance, although bacterial diversity was similar between dietary treatments and included bacterial communities of nutritional interest. Regarding histological observation of fish liver, both diets caused the accumulation of lipid droplets in the tissue. In conclusion, the findings of the present Ph.D. thesis show that 50%-100% fishmeal replacement by a mixture of fishmeal trimmings, bacterial protein, yeast and sunflower meals with simultaneous fish oil replacement by fish oil trimmings, rapeseed oil and Schizochytrium sp. suppressed the growth performance of S. aurata juveniles. Feed intake reduced and dietary lipids induced the lipid accumulation in white muscle. However, the mixture of bacterial protein, yeast meal and Schizochytrium sp. can successfully replace 35% of organic fishmeal trimmings, and 55% fish oil trimmings can be replaced by rapeseed oil, without adverse effects on growth performance, feed digestibility, fish metabolism and midgut microbiota. The aforementioned mixture of ingredients enhanced the growth and physiological status of fish. In addition, the combination of Scizochytrium sp., insect, tunicate and microalgae meals can successfully completely replace fishmeal and fish oil in feeds, without affecting growth rate and feed utilization of fish. Furthermore, the total replacement of fish oil by Schizochytrium sp. is as effective as using fish oil and P. tricornutum in feeds, inducing similar growth rate in fish. The different lipid sources of both feeds activated different lipid metabolic pathways, without affecting the proximate composition of fish white muscle. The use of a mixture of low-trophic organisms in feed could lead the fish feed industry and aquaculture towards a sustainable, conscious and environmentally friendly future.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tampou, Anna
- Τάμπου, Άννα
Subjects
dc:subject × 32- Τσιπούρα
- Sparus aurata
- Ιχθυάλευρο
- Ιχθυέλαιο
- Υποπροϊόντα φιλετοποίησης ιχθύων
- Μονοκύτταρες πρωτεΐνες
- Βακτηριακή πρωτεΐνη
- Ζυμομύκητας
- Schizochytrium
- Εντομάλευρο
- Ασκίδιο
- Μικροφύκη
- Βιολογική ιχθυοκαλλιέργεια
- Αειφορία
- Gilthead sea bream
- Fishmeal
- Fish oil
- Fishmeal trimmings
- Single cell proteins
- Bacterial protein
- Yeast meal
- Insect meal
- Tunicate meal
- Microalgae
- Organic aquaculture
- Sustainability
- Γεωπονία, Δασολογία και Αλιεία
- Γεωπονικές Επιστήμες και Κτηνιατρική
- Αλιεία
- Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
- Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences
- Fisheries
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59314