Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

The reconstruction of the pre-Eudoxean theory of ratios of magnitudes based on the equality of anthyphaireses

Abstract

dc:description

In the present thesis, I obtain the reconstruction of Theaetetus’ theory of ratios of magnitudes based, according to Aristotle’s Topics 158b, on the definition of proportion in terms of equal anthyphairesis. This reconstruction is built on the anthyphairetic interpretation of the notoriously difficult Theaetetus 147d3-e1 passage on Theaetetus’ mathematical discovery of quadratic incommensurabilities, itself based on the traces it has left on Plato’s philosophical definition of Knowledge in his dialogues Theaetetus, Sophist and Meno. Contrary to earlier reconstructions by Becker, van der Waerden and Knorr, my reconstruction reveals a theory that (a) applies only to the restricted class of pairs of magnitudes whose anthyphairesis is finite or eventually periodic, and (b) avoids the problematic use of Eudoxus’ definition 4 of Book V of Euclid’s Elements. The reconstructed theory of ratios consequently leads to the restoration of Book X of the Elements to its original Theaetetean, pre-Eudoxean form. This is achieved in two separate ways. First, I restore the considerable mathematical content of Book X, by correlating Book X with Plato’s account of Theaetetus’ mathematical discoveries and Plato’s imitations of these discoveries for his philosophy. Thus, Theaetetus proved [1] the eventual periodicity of the anthyphairesis of lines a to b, satisfying Ma^2 = Nb^2, for MN not square number, as deduced from Plato’s Theaetetus and Sophist, and not simply their incommensurability with arithmetical means, as suggested by the mathematically flawed Proposition X.9; [2] the anthyphairetic palindromic periodicity of the anthyphairesis of the surds √N for any non-square number N, as deduced from Plato’s Statesman, not mentioned at all in Book X but containing all the essential mathematical tools for its proof, and of relevance to the general Pell’s Diophantine problem, not mentioned in Book X but containing the essential mathematical tools for its proof; [3] the eventual periodic anthyphairesis of lines a to b, satisfying more general quadratic expressions, including the Application of Areas in defect, and employing this to show that 12 classes of alogoi lines, including the minor, despite being alogoi, are determined by an eventually periodic Application of Areas in defect, of relevance to the structure of the regular icosahedron in Book XIII of the Elements, and crucial for Plato’s Timaeus, who has indicated his interest in the method in the Meno 86e-87b; [4] the Pell theorem: if N is a non-square number, then find natural numbers x, y such that y^2 = Nx^2 + 1. Theaetetus’ interest for the general Pell problem (the case N = 2 had been studied by the Pythagoreans) is obvious from the second criterion for the ordering of the apotome and the binomial lines into six kinds. A general solution is possible through the use of the palindromic periodicity theorem, mentioned in [2]. From the analysis of the above achievements of Theaetetus, drawn from the juxtaposition of Platonic dialogues with Book X of the Elements, it is obvious that Theaetetus would have been interested in a theory of ratios of magnitudes that would not include just any ratio a/b, but only the class of ratios a/b such that the anthyphairesis of a to b is finite or eventually periodic. The Anonymon Scholion X.2 to the Elements, written by some follower of Plato’s philosophy, makes clear the commentator’s disdain for Eudoxus’ theory of ratios and his preference towards a theory of ratios that is focused on ratios with eventually periodic anthyphairesis. Secondly, I restore the proofs of all propositions of Book X, in such way that these are proofs based on Theaetetus’, and not on Eudoxus’ theory of proportion of magnitudes, in particular not making any use of Eudoxus’ condition (namely of definition 4 of Book V). The restoration is based on my reconstruction of Theaetetus’ theory of proportion for magnitudes, for the limited class of ratios a/b such that either a, b are commensurable or the anthyphairesis of a to b is eventually periodic, without employing Eudoxus’ condition, and its success provides a confirmation of this reconstruction.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Protopapas, Dimitrios
  • Πρωτοπαπάς, Δημήτριος

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/59320

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Protopapas, Dimitrios; Πρωτοπαπάς, Δημήτριος. The reconstruction of the pre-Eudoxean theory of ratios of magnitudes based on the equality of anthyphaireses. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/59320