National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η διαφύλαξη της πολιτιστικής κληρονομιάς: αστικολογική και διεθνολογική προσέγγιση
Abstract
dc:descriptionAbstract This dissertation explores the preservation and safeguarding of cultural heritage, a matter of fundamental significance to human beings and their well-being. International law presents a diversity of definitions in this regard. According to UNESCO, heritage represents our legacy from the past, our experiences in the present, and what we pass on to future generations. Cultural and natural heritage are considered irreplaceable sources of life and inspiration. The dissertation is structured into three chapters: The first chapter examines the significance and content of cultural heritage, as well as its protection in all its forms. The second chapter investigates the legal rights over monuments and their circulation, with particular emphasis on the prohibition of illicit trafficking. The third chapter focuses on the repatriation of monuments as a human right, highlighting the removal of cultural property from its place of origin as a form of "cultural genocide" and ethnic cleansing. It also addresses the process of repatriation, as well as specific cases involving the removal of monuments in armed conflict and the reunification of fragmented monuments. Cultural heritage has suffered destruction throughout history. As early as the 2nd century B.C., the historian Polybius condemned the looting of cultural property during Roman conquests, calling it an act of madness. The monuments of the Acropolis of Athens and Palmyra in Syria stand as prominent examples of violence and looting during the 19th and 20th centuries. In contemporary times, the illegal trade of cultural objects—through auctions and increasingly via the internet—poses significant threats to heritage. UNESCO has identified this illicit trafficking as one of the most persistent illegal activities worldwide, alongside drug and arms trafficking, due to its high financial stakes. The protection of cultural property in international legal texts is articulated through prohibitions on damage, destruction, looting, and illicit excavation; obligations for preservation; bans on illegal trafficking; and duties of restitution. Additionally, states are required to cooperate internationally. In the context of armed conflict, the body of legal norms regulating the obligations of parties falls under International Humanitarian Law and is recognized as customary international law. Current developments also consider the emergence of a customary rule on the protection of cultural property in times of peace, following the methodology of the International Law Commission. The convergence of human rights law and humanitarian law further supports the application of human rights provisions in cultural heritage protection cases. Hellenic law grants heightened constitutional protection to the cultural environment and monuments, benefiting both current and future generations. Law 4858/2021 codifies the protection of all monuments within Greek territory and extends it to those linked to Greece, regardless of location or time of removal. Monuments and archaeological sites are classified as inalienable public goods with use rights, and public enjoyment thereof constitutes an expression of individual personality. Legal rights over monuments are a prerequisite for lawful circulation, as legitimacy of origin is contingent upon these rights. International treaties portray monuments as public goods. At the international level, legal authority over monuments and their circulation is determined by the laws of the State of origin. Cultural rights, as recognized by the international community, aim to ensure the protection of individuals as fully developed personalities. Monument circulation relates to the human right to participate in cultural life through access and preservation. The principle of monument integrity requires that monuments remain undivided and whole to fulfill their purpose and social function as cultural identity markers and historical testimonies. Separated parts are inherently linked to the original monuments and cannot be treated as independent legal entities. A key example is the statues of Poseidon and Athena from the west pediment of the Parthenon, divided between the British Museum and the Acropolis Museum. According to Law 4858/2021, rights over monuments are accompanied by numerous obligations, as they serve the public interest and possess intrinsic value. Ownership and possession acquire a distinct meaning based on their status as public goods, the recognition of human rights, and the principle of equal access to national heritage. Illegal trafficking of cultural property during armed conflict is prohibited under international humanitarian law. Legal circulation requires prior verification of lawful provenance, an emerging norm in customary international law. UNESCO’s 1970 Convention imposes an obligation on States Parties to act against illegal import, export, and transfer of cultural goods. The ICOM Code of Ethics mandates that museums retain only those artifacts accompanied by valid legal documentation. The due diligence principle requires meticulous scrutiny of provenance in all transactions, evaluating acquisition conditions, compensation, export certificates, and checks against stolen art registries. Unauthorized circulation of artifacts—particularly through auctions—is prohibited under Hellenic law. A landmark decision on June 9, 2020, by a U.S. Court of Appeals in Sotheby’s v. Hellenic Ministry of Culture upheld Greece’s sovereign right to demand the withdrawal of an artifact from auction and confirmed the state's sovereign immunity. The issue of repatriation is rooted in the understanding that cultural property must remain in its place of origin due to its cultural significance. The emotional and identity-related bond between people and their monuments frames repatriation as a matter of human rights, enshrined in numerous legal instruments, as the right of access to heritage constitutes participation in cultural life. The removal or destruction of monuments, particularly in armed conflict and occupation, is interpreted as "cultural genocide" or ethnic cleansing. The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia recognized cultural destruction as a key aspect of genocide. Similarly, the International Court of Justice acknowledged the elimination of Armenian cultural elements by Azerbaijan in its December 7, 2021 ruling, describing it as an effort to legitimize occupation and permanently estrange displaced persons. Turkey has pursued similar tactics since the 1974 invasion and continued occupation of northern part of Cyprus, engaging in systematic destruction and erasure of the region's cultural heritage to "Turkify" the occupied territory and assert permanent presence. The conversion of Hagia Sophia into a mosque is also viewed as an act of monument distortion. Various legal instruments govern the repatriation of cultural property. Under the 1970 UNESCO Convention, States Parties are obliged, upon request by the State of origin, to take necessary actions for the recovery and return of illegally exported artifacts. Even for illicit imports predating the Convention, States are encouraged to reach agreements aligned with its principles. Hence, pre-1970 imports are not legitimate grounds for non-compliance. The 1995 UNIDROIT Convention further addresses the return of stolen and illegally exported cultural objects. At the EU level, relevant Directives apply. Illegal trafficking necessitates restitution. Once both the origin and unlawful acquisition of an object are substantiated, repatriation must follow. This documentation process is often protracted and complex. On January 22, 2024, three artifacts were repatriated from the University of Atlanta Museum after evidence confirmed their illegal excavation and export from Greece. Greek citizens’ right—and the corresponding obligation of the Hellenic State—to pursue repatriation of national heritage is grounded in the legal imperative to preserve cultural property, which shapes national identity, nurtures social cohesion, and serves as a source of knowledge. A notable case is the "Chian Decree" or "Chian Column"—the world's earliest constitution, dating from the 8th or 6th century B.C. Allegedly, Solon drew inspiration from it to draft laws that laid the foundation for Athenian democracy. Discovered embedded in a wall in Ottoman-occupied Chios in 1907, the artifact was published in 1909 and remains in the Istanbul Archaeological Museum. Numerous international instruments mandate repatriation during armed conflict. Binding UN Security Council Resolutions stress all member states' obligation to ensure the safe return of unlawfully trafficked cultural property. This duty has been upheld by the ICJ in the Preah Vihear Temple case (Cambodia v. Thailand) and by Italy’s Supreme Administrative Court regarding the return of the Aphrodite of Cyrene to Libya. The obligation to reunite fragmented monuments derives from the principle of integrity. When monuments are disassembled and scattered, they must be restored to their original form. The ICJ affirmed this obligation in the Cambodia v. Thailand decision. Judicial rulings and bilateral agreements supporting reunification reflect the emergence of a customary international norm. Notable cases include the mosaics of Kanakaria and Edessa, and the Heracles of Perge. A quintessential case is the Acropolis Monuments (e.g., 60% of the Parthenon’s pediments and metopes, the 6th Caryatid, Erechtheion column segments), now housed in the British Museum. These elements were illicitly removed under Ottoman occupation. Particularly noteworthy is the Caryatid from the Erechtheion, which remains in London despite no formal repatriation request—though it structurally completes the set of six columns held at the Acropolis Museum. Safeguarding cultural heritage has become a defining challenge of our era. Legal regimes continue to evolve through ongoing enrichment of provisions across multiple fields of law. This dissertation centers monuments themselves, highlighting their intrinsic value, public function, status as public goods and cultural identity symbols, and the principle of their integrity. Its contribution lies in the simultaneous study, analysis, and synthesis of legal branches—domestic and international—considering also soft law instruments, aiming at a holistic treatment of increasingly complex legal challenges. The findings of this research raise original, innovative issues and open new paths in legal thought regarding cultural heritage protection and rights thereto, such as the potential emergence of a customary rule on monument reunification and the entitlement of Greek citizens to demand repatriation. Its originality further lies in adopting a holistic methodology for examining cultural heritage protection, enabling a multidimensional approach to the evolving legal framework. As international principles increasingly shift toward more robust protection of heritage, such safeguarding clearly constitutes a common interest of humanity, in line with Aristotle’s definition of justice: “Justice is the political good, and this is the common interest.”(Politics III 1282b16–18; Nicomachean Ethics IX 1160a14–16).
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Vergou, Maria
- Βέργου, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 23- Πολιτιστική κληρονομιά
- Ακρόπολη
- Επανένωση μνημείων
- Επαναπατρισμός μνημείων
- Διακίνηση μνημείων
- Προστασία μνημείων
- Πολιτιστικά δικαιώματα
- Ανθρώπινα δικαιώματα
- Διεθνές Εθιμικό Δίκαιο
- Cultural heritage
- Acropolis
- Reunification of monuments
- Repatriation of monuments
- Movement / Trafficking of Monuments
- Protection of monuments
- Cultural rights
- Human rights
- International Customary Law
- Νομική Επιστήμη
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Δίκαιο
- Law
- Social Sciences
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59337