Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Διερεύνηση των δικαστικών αποφάσεων αμέλειας και των γνώσεων και στάσεων των επαγγελματιών υγείας στην εφαρμογή πληροφορημένης συναίνεσης

Abstract

dc:description

ΑBSTRACT Introduction: Informed consent of the patient is an obligation of both ethical and positive law for doctors and nurses in the health systems of the international legal order. Its theoretical background was structured not only through legislation and case law but also through philosophical, political and social perceptions produced over time for given societies. Although the practice of informing the patient has not been uniform over time, but has been, and still is, evolving, it is inspired by ethical principles of global scope which constitute the 'guideline' of relevant court decisions, ethical and legal regulations, health policies, but also the knowledge and attitudes of doctors and nurses. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to investigate and compare judicial decisions from common law and civil law courts regarding cases in which health professionals demonstrated negligent behaviour during the informed consent process. Also, to develop a tool for investigating the knowledge and attitudes of health professionals (doctors and nurses) in the Greek public system regarding the implementation of informed consent. Method: A mixed methodology was used, namely qualitative for the analysis of judicial, administrative and professional regulatory decisions, as well as findings of independent authorities regarding cases in which it was decided that there was negligent behaviour by health professionals (mainly doctors) when obtaining informed consent. Subsequently, the material resulting from the qualitative study was used, along with a review of the relevant literature, to construct a questionnaire. International practice was followed for the development of the questionnaire. The study sample consisted of 474 doctors and nurses from 9 hospitals of the National Health System (NHS). The statistical analysis of the data was carried out using the "triangulation" method, in order to ensure their validity and reliability. Results: From the analysis of the qualitative data, two main Central Themes emerged: the first, ‘Negligible information of the patient/health service user during the informed consent process’ had two categories, namely:- ‘Category 1.: ‘Failure to inform the patient/health service user’, with three (3) Subcategories, and – ‘Category 2.: ‘Deliberate information of the patient/health service user’, with nine (9) Subcategories. The second Central Theme: ‘Inaccurate information (Invalid consent)’ was excluded from the study as, by definition, it is different from negligence (i.e. failure to demonstrate due diligence during information) which was the purpose of the quantitative part of the investigation. Regarding the results of the quantitative part on the knowledge of health professionals on informed consent, a percentage: - less than 61% were trained, in a formal academic program (60.4%), and considered it good practice for doctors and nurses to assign the patient's information to a health professional from another field (51.1% in total for both fields), - from 62% and above knew different aspects of the institution (about its binding nature 73.3% about the Code of Medical Ethics (CME) and 62% about the Code of Nursing Ethics (CNE), 94.5% that through information the patient's autonomy is preserved, 98.3% that during the relevant procedure the same measure of care is due as during the performance of other acts, and 94.3% that the time of information is before their implementation), - ranging from 1.3% (the lowest) was unaware of the due diligence measure during the procedure, 47.6%, in total, of the existence of binding provisions for it (20.7% for the CME and 26.9% for the CNE), 24.7% of the need for special information, up to and including 52.8 (the highest) of the legislative guarantee of the patient's right not to be informed. Regarding the corresponding results for the attitudes of health professionals towards informed consent, it was found that: - over 80% “agreed/strongly agreed” with informing the patient about different aspects (83% regarding the actual state of their health, 90% regarding the content and results of the proposed actions and 88.3% regarding their alternatives and 86.5% regarding the diagnosis), and 90.9% that appropriate information to the patient before obtaining consent is a very important prerequisite, - over 70% had a positive attitude (“agree/agree/strongly”) about different aspects of information (72.1% regarding financial issues and 78% regarding the binding nature of the relevant provision in the CME and CNE). - less than 1/3 (13.4%) had a negative-neutral attitude ("I completely disagree/I disagree/I neither disagree nor agree") regarding informing the patient about their diagnosis, and about financial issues (27.9%). Conclusions: Regarding the qualitative part, it was found that the practice of informed consent is regulated on multiple levels: directly and impersonally by positive law regulations, case law, and ethical rules (of national and supranational origin) and indirectly by the knowledge and attitudes of health professionals who carry out the procedure in health units. Regarding the quantitative part, the ignorance of the participating health professionals about specific aspects of informed consent ranged with a measurable range of values from the lowest, intermediate to the highest percentage. The highest percentage of knowledge was almost absolute (due diligence) while equally high (> 9/10) concerned the time of information provision. The above heterogeneity may possibly be attributed to the greater importance that participants attribute to the regulation of informed consent by ethical and less by legal rules. Similarly, the high percentage (>9/10) of “agreement/absolute agreement” on the importance of prior informed consent of the patient, compared to the lower (almost 8/10) for the binding nature of corresponding provisions for the institution, is possibly due to the more positive attitude of professionals towards the ethical/moral and less towards the legal aspect. The relatively high percentage of negative-neutral attitude (almost 1/3) towards informing the patient on financial issues is related to the origin of the participants from public sector health units. Specialized training in the field of human rights (which includes informed consent) for health professionals, both at the academic and health unit level, as well as the building of a corresponding culture of respect for them in the work environment, will strengthen their relevant knowledge and (positive) attitudes towards the institution.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Sakellarios, Themistoklis
  • Σακελλάριος, Θεμιστοκλής

Subjects

dc:subject × 14

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/59356

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Sakellarios, Themistoklis; Σακελλάριος, Θεμιστοκλής. Διερεύνηση των δικαστικών αποφάσεων αμέλειας και των γνώσεων και στάσεων των επαγγελματιών υγείας στην εφαρμογή πληροφορημένης συναίνεσης. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/59356