Back to search

University of the Aegean

Development of a science base for digital governance: taxonomies, methodologies and tools

Abstract

dc:description

Since the middle of the twentieth century, Information and Communication Technologies have greatly assisted public sector organisations in their quest to provide better services to citizens and businesses. Currently, at a worldwide scale, governmental units at any level and sector are accelerating their efforts to utilize ICTs, due to their tremendous potential to enhance service quality, openness, transparency and ultimately quality of life and sustainable growth. Digital Governance has been recognized as a well- established application domain studying the problems related to the needs of public sector organisations and proposing novel methods and frameworks for enhancing service quality through the use of ICT. Substantial progress has been made through European and national funded research in a number of areas, yet the lack of scientific rigor in the Digital Governance domain seems to hinder unlocking the real transformative value and full potential to all its stakeholders, from researchers to industry and SMEs. Such a scientific “science base” would document the existing knowledge and open the pathway for systematic and reproducible solutions to identified problems, without the danger of repeating research or missing opportunities for application. The research presented in this doctoral dissertation offers a comprehensive exploration of the development and implementation of a Digital Governance Science Base (DGSB), addressing the complex challenges and opportunities presented by the digital transformation of public sector organizations. The rapid evolution of digital technologies and their penetration into governance processes, is the enabler of this study, as it leads to a pressing need for a structured, scientific approach to Digital Governance (DG). The dissertation hypothesizes that the establishment of a comprehensive science base for DG will improve the effectiveness, efficiency, and responsiveness of public sector organizations in the digital age. In order create such a scientific discipline a framework that bridges theoretical concepts and practical applications is more than important. Such a framework includes the development of taxonomies, methodologies and tools since such technological advancements often improve faster than policy and regulatory frameworks. The primary objective of this research is to develop a comprehensive science base for DG. This main objective is broken down into smaller parts: to identify and categorize the key components of DG across various domains and applications; to develop a systematic taxonomy that organizes the knowledge and practices within DG; to present methodologies for evaluating and implementing DG initiatives based on scientific principles; and to introduce tools that can support the practical application of DG concepts in real- world scenarios. These objectives are designed to address the multifaceted nature of DG, which encompasses technological, organizational, and societal dimensions. To achieve these objectives, the study addresses four key research questions: Why do we need a Science Base for Digital Governance? What are the components of the Digital Governance Science Base? What is the current landscape of Digital Governance? How can we construct the DGSB “What” & “How” components? These research questions constitute the main part of the DGSB establishment. The first question explores the rationale revealing the need for structuring the DGSB, taking, also, into account the current challenges and limitations of the field. The second question identifies the specific elements that should constitute a comprehensive science base for DG, examining various aspects from technological infrastructure to policy frameworks. The third research question unfolds the domain of DG, while the fourth research question reveals the content of the What & How components. The methodological steps of this research combine qualitative and quantitative approaches to ensure an in-depth understanding of the field. Specifically, it begins with a literature review, examining sources such as academic journals, conference proceedings, government reports, and industry white papers. This review fully supports understanding the current state of DG research and practice, identifying any key topics, challenges, and opportunities in the field. For the quantitative analysis questionnaires were used, to gather data on various aspects of DG, including perspectives of practitioners on key components of a DGSB, challenges in implementation, and future trends. These questionnaires were distributed to a diverse sample of DG-related respondents, including government officials, IT professionals, policymakers, and academics involved in DG initiatives. For the quantitative data, the study, also, include qualitative analysis through workshops with (mainly) experts in the field. These workshops main aspect was to bring together diverse stakeholders to gain usefull insights of the field through various participaroty techniques such as focus group discussions, brainstorming sessions, and scenario planning exercises. At the same time, the development of taxonomies and conceptual models forms an important part of the methodology. Thus, for their development a process of synthesizing literature findings and experts insights was followed, leading to a classification of DG concepts, technologies, and practices. These taxonomies are important in order to organize and understand the complexity of the DG landscape. The research also includes the design of curricula and a research roadmap, recognizing the importance of education and capacity building in advancing DG. For this to be achieved it is necessary to identify important knowledge areas and skills required for effective DG, map these to learning objectives and outcomes, and design course structures and content outlines. This dissertation explores the aspects of the DGSB across distinct chapters. To begin, the introduction establishes the importance of DG and discusses the challenges public administration faces when trying to implement it. Following this, the methodology chapter details the specific methods used. It explains the reason why these methods were chosen and how they help answer the research questions. I also use this chapter to acknowledge the study's limitations and describe the steps taken to address them. The following chapters explore the current state of DG, providing an overview of current research and practice in the field, including an examination of concepts, theories and frameworks in DG, as well as an analysis of case studies and best practices from around the world. The structure of the DGSB is then presented, including its components and how they are interconnected. Throughout the research, the importance of a flexible structure was taken into account so that it can absorb changes and developments in the field in the future. Continuing, the thesis delves into the current state of DG research and practice. For that purpose, established theories, concepts, and frameworks were analysed, considering also insights from case studies and best practices worldwide. Building on this literature review, the study puts forward the structure of the DGSB. I then break down its core components and explain how they connect to one another. My aim was to build, in one hand, a comprehensive framework to cover all major aspects of the field today, and on the other, adaptable enough for the developments of tomorrow. A notable part of the dissertation is dedicated to examining the evolution of DG, including the evolution of the Web and Industry. This historical perspective provides context for understanding current trends and future directions in DG. It traces the development of e-government initiatives from early digitization efforts to more sophisticated, citizen-centric approaches. The research identifies three generations of e-Government, e-Government 1.0, which provides basic online information and services; e-Government 2.0, which emphasizes increased citizen participation and collaboration; and e- Government 3.0, which combined already existing with advanced technologies like AI and big data for more personalized and predictive governance. This framework contextualizes current DG initiatives and helps anticipate future developments. One of this dissertation's main contributions is the new Domain Structure for the DG Science Base. The domain structure serves as a detailed taxonomy of DG issues, categorizing the wide range of challenges that public sector organizations face during their digital transformation. This taxonomy offers a method for organizing the complex elements of the DG domain, from technology and policy to organizational processes. Furthermore, it incorporates cross-cutting issues such as cybersecurity, privacy and digital ethics, recognizing their importance while, at the same time, offering a more holistic view, by mapping how the Sector Structure connects to other relevant scientific fields. For the future of DGSB, this thesis presents a research roadmap that aims to provide guidance for future research in the field, highlighting priorities (what should be investigated first) and suggesting potential new paths for exploration. Looking ahead, the roadmap goes beyond simple technology and examines the broader context that shapes the future of the Directorate General for Data Protection. It not only highlights transformative technologies like AI and blockchain, which are poised to redefine the landscape, but also examines the societal and political trends that could impact its development, such as shifting citizen expectations and pressing concerns over data privacy. Given that the advancement of the DG depends largely on education and the development of new competencies, this thesis proposes a set of training curricula to address the perceived skills gap in the sector. These curricula offer professionals a pathway to develop the competencies they need, not only technical knowledge in areas such as data analysis and cybersecurity, but also critical soft skills such as change management and stakeholder engagement. The thesis also focuses on how the DGSB can be applied in practice. It presents specific tools that help identify problems, evaluate them and, ultimately, design solutions. The idea at this point is that the problem-solving process should be done iteratively, i.e. in cycles. The reason is that digital transformation is not a one-time and finished procedure, but a continuous process of adaptation. For this reason, this research proposes and presents the approach of multidimensional matrices. This framework was designed to address the challenges of the DG, which are usually interrelated (connected to each other), while at the same time, it allows to analyze and find solutions, examining, at the same time, many different dimensions of the problem. Overall, this research offers significant assistance to the field of DG, both at a theoretical level (new ideas) and at a practical level (applicable solutions). At its core, it establishes a comprehensive SB that offers a structured way to understand and analyze DG. This strengthens the field's theoretical foundations for future academic work while also yields practical resources, such as taxonomies, methodologies, and tools, for policymakers and professionals on the ground. Based on the interdisciplinary nature of the field, this research combines knowledge from other, already existing scientific fields, such as computer science, public administration and political science, for a more robust and applicable framework to be developed. This holistic view is crucial, as effective DG should balance technological factors with organizational and societal needs. The impact of the research is equally important in public policymaking as the DGSB can act as a valuable tool for governments, helping them, in the future, to shape more evidence based policies and develop innovative digital services that substantially enhance citizen participation. At the same time, it promotes a model of adaptive governance, capable of responding to rapid technological developments, without overlooking critical concerns about privacy, security and equal digital access. Finally, the dissertation confronts the critical ethical questions raised by technology in governance. It proposes frameworks for tackling challenges related to data privacy and accountability, stressing the need for DG to be transparent and citizen centric. Furthermore, the research places these issues in a global context, examining the diverse approaches to digital transformation being taken by different countries and regions worldwide. This thesis concludes by addressing the research questions, summarizing the achievements of the study, discussing limitations, and proposing next steps for future research and development in the field of DG. It emphasizes the dynamic nature of DG and the need for continuous improvement and adaptation of the scientific base to keep pace with technological developments and evolving societal needs. In conclusion, this thesis presents the scientific basis for the DG, introducing a framework to guide research and practice. Its aim is to promote innovation while improving the effectiveness of digital initiatives, leading to a more efficient, transparent and citizen centric governance. An important element that emerges throughout this research is that such a scientific base cannot be treated as a static repository of knowledge but, on the contrary, should be treated as a dynamic, living framework, designed to evolve in parallel with technological developments and changing social needs. Thus, for its continuation and further development, ongoing collaboration between academic, political and professional communities is necessary, participating as a whole for its improvement. Finally, the dissertation insists on a critical evaluation of the broader societal impacts of Digital Governance. While technologies present opportunities, they also raise questions in topics such as digital divide, data protection and the evolving nature of the citizen-state relationship. The research, therefore, advocates a balanced approach that harnesses the transformative potential of technology while safeguarding core social values. Looking to the future, the dissertation identifies a number of areas for research and development in DG further. These include the further exploration of new technologies such as AI in governance contexts; the development of more innovative approaches to citizen engagement and co-creation in digital environments; and the investigation of new models of digital democracy and participation. It also emphasizes the need for focusing on digital skills within government organizations and among citizens. It argues that becoming fully aware of the potential of DG requires technological infrastructure and also a digitally skilled workforce and citizenry. In its final remark, the dissertation underscores the transformative potential of DG to reshape the relationship between citizens and government, enhance public service delivery, and foster more responsive and accountable governance. However, it also cautions that achieving these benefits requires careful planning, ongoing research, and a commitment to ethical and inclusive approaches to digital transformation.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of the Aegean
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Lachana, Zoi
  • Λαχανά, Ζωή

Subjects

dc:subject × 15

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/59409

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Lachana, Zoi; Λαχανά, Ζωή. Development of a science base for digital governance: taxonomies, methodologies and tools. University of the Aegean, 2024. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/59409