University of Crete (UOC)
''Cretan Tragedy'': ideas and networks of an Ottoman imperial provincial elite at the turn of 20th century
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present doctoral research investigates the evolution of the socio-political networks and ideas of opposition Ottoman intellectuals who occupied prominent positions within the Ottoman administration and witnessed unprecedented political and humanitarian crises in Crete and the Ottoman Empire at the turn of the 20th century. The involvement of these intellectuals in the conspiratorial and solidarity networks of the Young Turks’ movement was facilitated by the establishment of a core network in Crete under the name of the “Islamic Society of Humanists” (Muḥibb-i İnsāniyet Cemʽiyet-i İslāmiyyesi). This is evidenced by the travel of the central figure, Hüseyin Nesimi, to Paris and Geneva – among other cities in Western and Eastern Europe - where he engaged with central figures of the Ottoman opposition, such as Ahmed Rıza. The cooperation and communication of the activists triggered an explosion of publications in Ottoman Turkish and French describing the suffering of the humanitarian crisis in Crete (Girīd Hā’ilesī) amidst rural and urban conflicts, often quoting also the imperialist intervention of the European powers in February 1897. Following the work of these intellectuals through time, with a microhistorical focus on the intriguing case of Hüseyin Nesimi, an essential part of the reform and constitutionalist movements within the Empire and beyond unfolds. This is evidenced by the diasporic press of the Young Turks in Paris and Geneva, where the Cretan Question and the references of their colleagues in Crete are constant and detailed, constituting a component of the wider Eastern Question which highlights the complexity of clarifying the homogeneous character of the movement. The overarching concept of Ottomanism is a fundamental premise underpinning the works produced to solve the socio-political crisis affecting the Empire and the coexistence of diverse communities. The thesis posits that constitutionalism serves as a unifying principle for both Orthodox Christian and Muslim intellectuals on the island, maintaining a cautious stance between the irredentist aspirations of the Greek Kingdom and the Hamidian centralism of Istanbul, both of which have their designs for the island’s future. This coveted constitutionalism was articulated through cultural metaphors and translations, as evidenced in the texts. The research challenges Greek and Turkish historiography’s predominantly ethnocentric and teleological frameworks. By drawing on archives from Istanbul, Crete, Athens, Paris, and Nantes, this work illuminates the intricate network of ideas and transimperial connections fostered by the multilingual Ottoman intelligentsia in the provinces. This alternative perspective engages with Ottoman Turkish and Greek-speaking communities in the Eastern Mediterranean. The doctoral dissertation incorporates methodological tools, including the history of concepts and a microhistorical approach centred on individuals to interrogate broader social and political structures at the macro level. By examining the case of these networks of Cretan intellectuals, bureaucrats, and activists, we can gain insights into the ideological and political developments and processes in the Eastern Mediterranean and Europe during the late 19th to early 20th century, facilitating a gradual transition from imperial models to those of nation-states through the conceptual framework of parliamentarianism and constitutionalism.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Crete (UOC)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Nasis, Antonios
- Νάσης, Αντώνιος
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Διαυτοκρατορικά δίκτυα διανοούμενων
- Κίνημα Νεοτούρκων
- Οθωμανισμός
- Κρήτη
- Χουσεΐν Νεσιμί
- Συνταγματισμός
- Transimperial Intellectual Networks
- Young Turks Movement
- Ottomanism
- Crete
- Hüseyin Nesimi
- Constitutionalism
- Ιστορία και Αρχαιολογία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Νεότερη ιστορία
- History and Archaeology
- Humanities and the Arts
- Modern history
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59591