National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Η χρήση της ρομποτικής τεχνολογίας στη βελτίωση της χειρουργικής ακρίβειας, με τη χρήση μοντέλων μετα-ανάλυσης δεδομένων, σε επεμβάσεις μερικής νεφρεκτομής
Abstract
dc:descriptionBackground: Robotic or Robot‑assisted partial nephrectomy (RPN/RAPN) and open partial nephrectomy (OPN) represent the two main approaches in nephron‑sparing surgery. Their quality is commonly evaluated by the achievement of the Trifecta, a composite outcome that incorporates tumor‑free surgical margins, adequate preservation of renal function, and the avoidance of major complications. However, the Trifecta is characterized by significant heterogeneity in its definitions, particularly regarding the threshold of acceptable impact on renal function, which complicates evaluation in comparative studies. At the same time, the absence of a quantitative framework for the objective assessment of surgical precision creates a gap in linking technical approach with clinical outcomes. The aim of this dissertation was to investigate and interconnect all these elements, proposing an integrated model that captures the concept of surgical precision and its impact on Trifecta achievement. Main Part: The dissertation is structured into five studies. In the first study, mathematical modeling combined with a systematic review of the international literature was performed to compare different definitions of Trifecta. These were initially grouped according to two criteria: a reduction of ≤ 10% in estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) and a limitation of ischemia time to < 25 minutes. Using a mathematical model (volume conservation equations), it was demonstrated that these two definitions practically represent different expressions of the same clinical entity. Therefore, Trifecta achievement rates can be used collectively in subsequent meta‑analyses, provided that appropriate subgroup analyses are applied. In the second study, the incidence of minor postoperative complications (Clavien–Dindo ≤ 2) in RPN/RAPN versus OPN was examined. A meta‑analysis of 16 comparative studies (3,238 patients), along with subgroup and meta‑regression analyses, demonstrated a clear advantage of the robotic approach (petoOR = 0.52, CI95% = [0.43; 0.64]), which remained consistent regardless of year of publication, single‑ or multi‑center design, or patient matching. This finding was attributed to intrinsic minimally invasive characteristics of robotic technology, which may also be associated with a higher level of surgical precision. The third study introduced a new variable: the ischemia ratio (I), defined as the proportion of ischemia duration to total operative time. From an analysis of 62 data sets (26,072 patients), the I ratio remained stable between RPN/RAPN and OPN, indicating that relative ischemia requirements are an inherent feature of partial nephrectomy and appear to be associated more with procedural complexity and hemostatic efficiency rather than with the surgical approach itself. In the fourth study, a second novel variable was developed: the rate of blood loss per minute (Q), defined as the amount of blood loss per minute of surgery. Analysis of 43 studies revealed that Q was significantly lower in RPN/RAPN (MDQ = –1.043 ml/min, CI95% = [–1.338; –0.747]), indicating faster and more accurate hemostasis and superior tissue handling. This advantage remained consistent in subgroup and sensitivity analyses, independent of sample size, risk of bias, or multicenter design. In the fifth study, these indicators were combined with an extensive meta‑analysis of 51 comparative studies evaluating Trifecta achievement and its individual components. RPN/RAPN demonstrated superiority in achieving Trifecta (ORs: 1.3–1.8), lower rates of both minor and major complications (ORs: 0.5–0.7 and 0.5–0.6, respectively), and a small though clinically marginal improvement in eGFR preservation (2–3 ml/min/1.73m²). Absolute ischemia times and positive surgical margin rates remained comparable between the two techniques. The final analysis highlighted that the improved surgical precision of RPN/RAPN, as captured by Q, is associated with a reduction in complications and a higher likelihood of achieving Trifecta, while the I ratio serves as a stable reference parameter within the proposed model. Conclusion: This dissertation developed and validated a unified (quantitative and qualitative) model for assessing surgical precision in partial nephrectomy. RPN/RAPN, through improved tissue handling (lower Q, indicating enhanced intraoperative surgical precision) and reduced complications, achieves higher Trifecta rates compared with OPN, ultimately providing superior surgical quality. The proposed model, which combines Trifecta with the novel variables I and Q, offers a functional and quantitative framework for future assessment of nephron‑sparing surgical techniques and highlights the robotic approach as superior in terms of surgical precision and the associated clinical outcomes, particularly regarding minor but also, secondarily, major postoperative complications.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Artsitas, Sotirios
- Αρτσίτας, Σωτήριος
Subjects
dc:subject × 19- Ρομποτική μερική νεφρεκτομή
- Ανοικτή μερική νεφρεκτομή
- Χειρουργική ακρίβεια
- Trifecta
- Λόγος ισχαιμίας
- Ρυθμός απώλειας αίματος
- Μετεγχειρητικές επιπλοκές
- Robot‑assisted partial nephrectomy
- Open partial nephrectomy
- Surgical precision
- Ischemia ratio
- Blood loss rate
- Postoperative complications
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Χειρουργική
- Clinical Medicine
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Surgery
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59673