University of the Aegean
Comprehensive assessment, economic valuation and mapping of ecosystem services in marine and coastal environments
Abstract
dc:descriptionEcosystem services have increasingly been recognized as an established framework in environmental management, policy-making, and scientific research. Translating ecological assets into socio-economic benefits provides a powerful tool to align environmental, social, and economic sustainability objectives. Key marine and coastal habitats, such as mangroves, seagrass meadows, and coral reefs, have become central to the assessment of the ecosystem services they provide, the quantification of their economic value, and the mapping of their spatial distribution. Although historically these habitats were often overlooked in policy decisions, the adoption of valuation methodologies has facilitated their integration into current management and policy frameworks, promoting informed and effective conservation strategies. The European Union (EU) has recognized the significance of ecosystem services in environmental management through policies such as the Biodiversity Strategy for 2030. A significant milestone toward the economic valuation of ecosystem services was the adoption of the System of Environmental-Economic Accounting (SEEA), a standardized framework designed to quantify the contributions of ecosystems to the economy while simultaneously assessing human-induced impacts. Although EU member states have initiated ecosystem service mapping, the first reporting in 2020 excluded marine and coastal ecosystem services. A more comprehensive assessment, encompassing a broader range of services and enhanced participation by member states, is expected in the 2026 reporting cycle. Ecosystem services are dynamic, continually shaped by environmental and anthropogenic factors, such as climate change, habitat degradation, and biological invasions. Invasive alien species (IAS) represent a major driver of ecological transformation, often disrupting native biodiversity, altering habitat structures, and affecting industries dependent on ecosystem health, such as marine tourism and fishery. While their impacts can often be detrimental, leading to the decline of ecosystem services, certain IAS may occasionally provide beneficial effects, contributing positively to specific services, such as food provision or habitat creation. Understanding these complex and variable impacts is crucial for effective environmental management and informed policymaking, ensuring the sustainable use and resilience of marine and coastal ecosystems. In response to the ongoing degradation of marine ecosystems and the consequent decline in ecosystem services, numerous countries, including EU member states, are prioritizing the expansion of marine protected areas (MPAs). Under the EU Biodiversity Strategy for 2030, member states aim to designate 30% of their marine waters as protected areas, with at least 10% under strict protection. Selecting appropriate areas involves complex trade-offs between ecological conservation, economic development, and stakeholder interests. Economic valuation and spatial mapping of ecosystem services offer essential insights to support comparative analyses, enabling evidence-based decisions that promote sustainable marine management. Beyond environmental conservation, ecosystem services can also enhance inclusivity in marine governance by facilitating broader stakeholder engagement. Traditionally, marine management processes have overlooked diverse stakeholder perspectives, contributing to social disparities. Modern tools such as crowdsourced data, online surveys, and open-source databases now offer improved opportunities for inclusive participation, enabling direct involvement through participatory methods or indirectly via analysis of behavioral data. Leveraging these tools can capture diverse stakeholder perspectives and behavioral patterns, ultimately fostering more inclusive, equitable, and adaptive marine management. This dissertation examines the economic valuation and spatial mapping of ecosystem services, emphasizing their integration into environmental decision-making and policy development. It also examines the complex impacts of invasive alien species on ecosystem services, assessing both their positive and negative effects. The key objectives of this research were to: (a) Conduct a comprehensive economic valuation and spatial analysis of recreational diving in the Aegean Sea as a cultural ecosystem service. This included assessing divers' expenditures, diving center revenues, site preferences, and willingness to pay for biodiversity conservation through Marine Protected Area (MPA) expansion, thereby providing insights to support marine spatial planning. (b) Assess the economic value of Mediterranean seagrass meadows through a meta-analysis of eight key ecosystem services. This included estimating total and per-hectare values, mapping their spatial distribution, identifying knowledge gaps, and examining the effectiveness of benefit transfer in informing policy decisions. (c) Evaluate the economic value of coastal recreation along the Greek coasts using multiple methodologies, including contingent valuation and mapping using crowdsourced data. This involved estimating monetary values, identifying spatial variations, and analyzing visitor preferences to inform coastal management and policy development. (d) Assess the economic value of beach recreation for individuals with ambulatory difficulties in Greece by integrating economic valuation and accessibility analysis. This included estimating total value, quantifying economic losses due to accessibility barriers, and evaluating infrastructure adequacy to support inclusive tourism and equitable coastal management. (e) Develop a cost-benefit analysis framework to integrate the economic value of ecosystem services into Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) processes. The framework was applied to assess the potential expansion of no-take zones in Greece, in line with the EU Biodiversity Strategy’s objective of strictly protecting 10% of the country’s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) by 2030. The analysis included the valuation of ecosystem services provided by key habitats in shallow waters (0–50 m depth), the estimation of both management and opportunity costs, and the evaluation of three alternative spatial expansion scenarios within the Greek EEZ, each reflecting a distinct prioritization strategy. (f) Develop a standardized framework to assess the cumulative impacts of marine invasive alien species (IAS) on ecosystem services. This included developing the CIMPAL-ES index to quantify and spatially map IAS impacts by incorporating species distributions, impact magnitudes, and evidence strength. The framework was applied to the Mediterranean and Aegean Seas to identify hotspots of both positive and negative IAS effects, providing insights to refine impact assessments, enhance ecosystem resilience, and inform management strategies through improved stakeholder collaboration. To accomplish the objectives stated, this thesis undertook the following tasks: (a) A comprehensive economic assessment of recreational diving in the Aegean Sea was conducted using multiple methodologies, databases, and a structured approach to integrating economic and spatial information (Chapter 2). Primary data collection included online surveys targeting Greek recreational divers (n=315) and diving centers (n=42), offering valuable insights into the cultural ecosystem service of recreational diving, a sector previously understudied in Greece. The analysis revealed that recreational divers spend an average of €1,692 annually on diving activities, completing an average of 72 dives per year. Habitat preferences indicated that 58% of dives took place in reef areas, 25% in Posidonia oceanica meadows, and 17% on soft bottoms. The Contingent Valuation Method (CVM) was applied to estimate divers’ Willingness to Pay (WTP) for Marine Protected Area (MPA) expansion aimed at marine biodiversity conservation, yielding an average WTP of €54 per diver per year. Diving centers also contribute significantly to the tourism industry, with an average annual revenue of €68,312 per center across the 226 diving centers operating in the Aegean Sea. The most popular diving attractions included high fish biodiversity (20%), shipwrecks (17%), high sponge biodiversity (14%), caves (13%), seals (10%), gorgonians and corals (10%), and seahorses (9%), while 7% of respondents reported no specific preferences. To estimate the total economic value of recreational diving, economic and behavioral profiles were combined into an equation integrating use and non-use values. The total annual economic value of this ecosystem service in the Aegean Sea was estimated at €154.3 million. This value was spatially mapped based on divers’ preferences for habitats, target species, underwater attractions, and proximity to diving centers. The highest recorded economic value reached €1.1 million per km² per year, while the lowest was €127 per km² per year. The findings highlight the significant role of recreational diving in driving economic growth in Aegean coastal communities. This study underscores the need to integrate recreational diving into marine spatial planning and conservation efforts to ensure its sustainable contribution to both local economies and marine biodiversity protection. (b) A systematic literature review on the economic value of Mediterranean seagrass ecosystem services was conducted using three research engines (Scopus, Google Scholar, Web of Science) and two valuation databases (ESVD – Ecosystem Services Valuation Database and TEEB – The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity). This process identified 511 unique studies, with 17 selected for meta-analysis (Chapter 3). A comprehensive database was compiled, incorporating 91 observations across eight key ecosystem services: coastal protection, water purification, food provision, climate regulation, biotic materials and biofuels, life cycle maintenance, recreation and tourism, and cognitive effects. All values were standardized to International dollars ($Int.) per hectare per year, using 2020 as the reference year. The analysis revealed substantial variation in ecosystem service values, ranging from a mean of $3.6/ha/yr for cognitive effects to $10,894/ha/yr for coastal protection. Climate regulation had the most records (n=34), while services like cognitive effects had only two. Most studies focused on the northwestern Mediterranean, highlighting geographical disparities in research coverage. A meta-regression model was applied to ecosystem services with sufficient records (n>10), including climate regulation, coastal protection, water purification, and food provision, to identify factors influencing per-hectare valuation. GDP per capita of the case study country emerged as the only statistically significant variable, positively correlating with ecosystem service values. For services with fewer records, mean values from the review database were used. These valuations (eight ecosystem services) were spatially mapped across the Mediterranean, estimating the total annual economic value of seagrass ecosystem services at approximately $Int.11.6 billion/yr, with notable country-specific variations. Italy had the highest valuation, while Slovenia had the lowest. The average per hectare value for Mediterranean seagrass ecosystem services was $Int. 8,712/ha/yr. This study underscores the utility of meta-analysis and benefit transfer in informing policy, particularly in data deficient regions, while highlighting the need for further valuation research in underrepresented Mediterranean areas and less studied ecosystems. (c) A comprehensive assessment of the economic value of coastal recreation along the Greek coasts was conducted using multiple methodologies, including travel cost estimations, the Contingent Valuation Method (CVM), previous survey data, and crowdsourced information from Flickr (Chapter 4). Economic data were collected through online questionnaires distributed to the Greek population (n=527), supplemented by a prior survey from the Bank of Greece. Findings revealed that Greeks spend an average of €1,055 per person annually on summer coastal visits (n=38), with expenditures varying by age group. Respondents also indicated a willingness to pay €121 per year for coastline conservation in response to climate change and human pressures. The inbound tourism sector, a key driver of the Greek economy, generates approximately €9.9 billion annually from May to September. By integrating all economic data into a unified equation, the total value of this recreational ecosystem service was estimated at €21.4 billion per year. The study also analyzed factors influencing coastal visitation, showing that deterrents such as port and hotel presence outweighed natural attractions, while beach accessibility was the most desirable feature. Additionally, crowdsourced Flickr data were used to develop a visitation index, enabling the spatial mapping of economic values across Greek coastlines. The highest recorded value per beach was €232 million per year at Santorini’s Caldera Beach, a one-hectare area and one of Greece’s most famous destinations. Spatial mapping revealed significant variations in monetary value, with an average of € 6.7 million per hectare per year. These findings underscore the economic significance of coastal recreation as a cultural ecosystem service, providing valuable insights for coastal management and policy development. By integrating primary survey data with crowdsourced information, the study addressed data gaps and leveraged the extensive temporal coverage of social media to track human activities. This transparent and adaptable framework can be applied to other regions and cultural ecosystem services, supporting sustainable tourism, blue growth, and a balanced approach to economic development and environmental conservation. (d) A comprehensive assessment of the economic value of coastal recreation for wheelchair users in Greece was conducted by integrating economic valuation with accessibility analysis (Chapter 5). Economic data were collected through online questionnaires (n=91), while accessibility infrastructure data was sourced from companies responsible for installing beach access facilities. Additionally, crowdsourced data from Flickr were used to develop a visitation index. Findings estimate that coastal recreation for wheelchair users in Greece generates €237 million annually. However, accessibility barriers limit participation, resulting in an estimated economic loss of €57 million per year. The average Willingness to Pay (WTP) for improved infrastructure was €73 per person per year, though only 46% of respondents were willing to contribute financially, reflecting widespread dissatisfaction with current accessibility conditions. Accessibility was recognized as a crucial aspect of life for wheelchair users, with 83% of respondents rating it as "very important," while 82% believed that improved access would significantly enhance their quality of life. Despite this, 63.5% rated beach accessibility as "bad" or "very bad". An analysis of existing infrastructure revealed that only 11% of access ramps (n=322) met all key accessibility criteria, including designated disabled parking, accessible toilets, adapted changing rooms, shaded areas, and accessible showers. The spatial distribution of economic value showed that beaches with adequate infrastructure had an average annual value of €92,611 per beach, compared to €42,374 for those lacking such facilities. A cost-benefit analysis comparing infrastructure installation costs with the economic benefits of improved coastal access for individuals with mobility impairments demonstrated a significantly higher benefit-to-cost ratio, justifying the investment in an estimated 234 additional ramps. These findings underscore the urgent need for targeted infrastructure investments, offering policymakers actionable insights to enhance inclusive tourism, maximize social and economic benefits, and promote more equitable coastal management. Furthermore, this study is among the few to examine inclusivity in ecosystem services from both economic and spatial perspectives, providing methodological recommendations for future research and emphasizing the broader implications of accessible coastal recreation for social well-being and economic sustainability. (e) A spatially explicit cost-benefit framework for Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) was developed to integrate the economic value of ecosystem services into decision-making processes (Chapter 6). The framework consists of three distinct steps and employs the S.M.A.R.T. (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) approach to objective setting within the MSP context. It introduces analytical tools and methodologies for evaluating both the benefits and costs associated with marine spatial management and provides structured approaches for assessing alternative management scenarios. Greece was selected as a case study to apply the proposed methodological framework, aiming to explore how the country could expand strict protection to encompass 10% of its marine waters and identify suitable areas for passive habitat restoration. The analysis focused on shallow coastal zones—areas of high ecological significance and intense anthropogenic pressure. Three meta-analyses were conducted to estimate the economic value of ecosystem services provided by the region’s three key habitats: seagrass meadows, hard substrates, and soft substrates. Additionally, both operational and opportunity costs to fisheries were calculated, drawing on a formula derived from previous meta-analyses and a spatial model of fishing effort. Three alternative management scenarios were evaluated, each representing a distinct prioritization strategy: (i) prioritization of environmental conservation and protection, (ii) prioritization of conflict minimization, and (iii) a middle-ground scenario integrating elements of both approaches. Results indicate that seagrass meadows provide the highest ecosystem service value ($8,008 × 10²/km²/year), followed by hard substrates ($2,410 × 10²/km²/year) and soft substrates ($93 × 10²/km²/year). Estimated costs range from $747 to $25,565/km²/year, with an average of $1,678 Int./km²/year. Among the scenarios, the middle-ground option produced the most favorable benefit-cost ratio, effectively balancing ecological outcomes with socio-economic feasibility. This research is among the few studies to incorporate the economic valuation of ecosystem services directly into MSP processes. The proposed framework offers a robust and practical methodological foundation for participatory, evidence-based marine planning. It facilitates transparent trade-off assessments, strengthens stakeholder engagement, and supports the co-creation of balanced protection strategies that align with overarching policy objectives. (f) Develop a standardized framework to assess the cumulative impact of marine invasive alien species (IAS) on ecosystem services (Chapter 7). Building upon the original CIMPAL (Cumulative Impacts of Invasive Alien Species) framework, which evaluated IAS effects on biodiversity, this study developed the CIMPAL-ES framework to quantify both negative and positive impacts on ecosystem services. The new impact scoring system incorporates the magnitude of impact and the strength of supporting evidence. A systematic literature review informed the development of this framework, ensuring a robust and data-driven approach. The CIMPAL-ES index was applied to two case studies in the Mediterranean and Aegean Seas using distinct datasets to test its applicability and sensitivity. In the Mediterranean Sea, an assessment of 80 IAS evaluated their effects on 14 ecosystem services, mapping their spatial distribution on a 10 km² grid. Results revealed that the Western Mediterranean and Aegean-Levantine regions exhibited the highest total negative impacts, while the Aegean-Levantine region also showed the highest total positive impacts, followed by the Ionian and Central Mediterranean. In the Aegean Sea, a finer spatial resolution of 1 km² was applied to 29 IAS, further capturing localized variations in IAS impacts. Findings demonstrated significant spatial heterogeneity, with some species exhibiting exclusively negative effects (e.g., Lagocephalus sceleratus, Rugulopteryx okamurae), others contributing only positive effects (e.g., Halophila stipulacea, Pterois miles), and some, like Caulerpa cylindracea, displaying mixed impacts across different ecosystem services. Food provision emerged as the most affected service, experiencing both positive and negative impacts. The developed framework provides a foundation for a holistic assessment of IAS impacts on ecosystem services, with its accuracy expected to improve as more precise data become available. By identifying high-impact areas, prioritizing key species and ecosystem services, and promoting stakeholder collaboration, this approach enhances ecosystem resilience, supports evidence-based decision-making, and strengthens the integration of ecological and socio-economic considerations in marine conservation policies. This dissertation advances the integration of ecosystem service valuation into marine and coastal management by conducting comprehensive economic and spatial analyses across diverse areas, including recreational diving, seagrass meadows, coastal recreation, and the impacts of IAS. It addresses critical gaps in current methodologies by developing standardized frameworks for assessing cumulative impacts and optimizing MPAs placement. Additionally, it emphasizes stakeholder inclusivity by leveraging crowdsourced data and accessibility analyses. By highlighting the economic value of marine ecosystem services and advocating for evidence-based conservation strategies, this research supports sustainable and equitable marine governance, balancing environmental protection with socio-economic development.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of the Aegean
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Stamatiadou, Valentini
- Σταματιάδου, Βαλεντίνη
Subjects
dc:subject × 47- Οικοσυστημικές υπηρεσίες
- Οικονομική αποτίμηση
- Χρηματικές αξίες
- Παράκτια ζώνη
- Αιγαίο πέλαγος
- Καταδυτικός Τουρισμός
- Προθυμία πληρωμής
- Posidonia oceanica
- Χωρική ανάλυση (GIS)
- Μεσόγειος Θάλασσα
- Θαλάσσιος τουρισμός
- Εφαρμογές Crowdsourcing
- Προσβασιμότητα
- Αναπηρία
- Θαλάσσιες προστατευόμενες περιοχές
- Αναλύσεις κόστους-οφέλους
- Ξενικά είδη
- Ελλάδα
- Aξιολόγηση επιρροών
- Ecosystem services
- Economic valuation
- Μonetary values
- Coastal
- Aegean sea
- Diving Tourism
- Willingness to pay
- Spatial analysis (GIS)
- Mediterranean sea
- Sea tourism
- Crowdsourcing
- Accessibility
- Disability
- Marine protected areas
- Cost-benefit analysis
- Alien species
- Greece
- Impact assessment
- Γεωεπιστήμες και Επιστήμες Περιβάλλοντος
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Επιστήμες περιβάλλοντος
- Βιολογία
- Διατήρηση της βιοποικιλότητας
- Earth and Related Environmental Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Environmental Sciences
- Biological Sciences
- Biodiversity Conservation
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/59719