University of Crete (UOC)
Mechanisms shaping primary school teachers' preferences for ICT-based teaching characteristics through application of Discrete Choice Models
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis doctoral dissertation investigates mechanisms shaping primary school teachers’ preferences regarding the characteristics of ICT-based teaching, with a particular focus on Digital Learning Objects (DLOs). While DLOs are considered valuable tools for promoting personalized, inclusive, and interactive learning, their adoption in classroom practice remains inconsistent. This study addresses the gap between the theoretical design of digital resources and actual instructional needs by empirically modeling teachers’ stated preferences and attitudinal shifts using a combination of Discrete Choice Models (DCMs) and the Unified Theory of Acceptance and Use of Technology (UTAUT). In doing so, it provides a nuanced understanding of how specific DLO characteristics affect instructional decision-making and how targeted interventions can influence technology acceptance. The research was conducted between 2022 and 2024 in Greece, involving 437 in-service primary school teachers. A series of factorial Discrete Choice Experiments (DCEs) was developed, comprising four distinct subsets of choice cards: (a) general characteristics of ICT-based lessons (e.g., Grade level, Subject area, Interactivity), (b) technical characteristics of DLOs (e.g., Interoperability, Accessibility, Durability, Interactivity), (c) instructional DLO features (e.g., Reusability, Generativity, Adaptability), and (d) teacher profile-related attributes (Openness to unfamiliar DLOs, and Familiarity with DLO integration format). A STEAM-based intervention aligned with the Soft Skills Workshops framework was implemented in Grades 1, 4, and 5 of primary school to provide experiential exposure to key DLO features. An adapted UTAUT-based scale was administered before and after the intervention to assess shifts in attitudes toward ICT. Three of the four DCE subsets (general, technical, and instructional characteristics) were analyzed using alternative-specific conditional logit models in a pre–post design. The fourth subset (teacher profile) was modeled separately using cross-sectional analysis, due to design constraints that limited the number of cards per participant and did not allow for sufficient variability to support longitudinal comparison. Nevertheless, this subset yielded valuable insights into persistent attitudinal patterns. The DCM results revealed that, across all grade levels, teachers consistently preferred the inclusion of DLOs in instruction. Subject relevance, Interactivity, and Adaptability were the most influential attributes, while Accessibility and Interoperability were also positively evaluated. Notably, Reusability—traditionally emphasized in DLO design—was not initially a strong predictor of preference but gained importance after the intervention, highlighting the role of direct experience in shaping perceptions. Segmentation analyses further indicated that less experienced teachers prioritized stability-related attributes (e.g., Durability), whereas more experienced teachers favored dynamic and creative features (e.g., Generativity). Gender-based differences were modest but noteworthy: male teachers appeared less likely to integrate DLOs in early primary grades, while both genders consistently valued subject alignment and interactivity. The attitudinal analysis using the UTAUT framework demonstrated significant post-intervention increases in Effort Expectancy, Performance Expectancy, and overall attitudes toward ICT use. However, Social Influence and Facilitating Conditions did not significantly impact adoption decisions, suggesting that instructional choices are more closely tied to internal perceptions of utility and confidence than to external pressures. This study makes several original contributions. Methodologically, it is one of the first to apply DCMs to model primary teachers’ preferences for digital resources, integrating stated preference modeling with attitudinal tracking and a structured intervention. Empirically, it identifies which DLO attributes drive adoption and how these interact with professional experience and teacher characteristics. Pedagogically, it offers evidence that well-designed interventions can positively reshape perceptions of less familiar digital tools. The findings have practical implications for both educational policy and teacher professional development. Training initiatives should move beyond generic digital skills instruction and instead be tailored to address specific characteristics that teachers prioritize—particularly Adaptability, Accessibility, and Interactivity. Developers of digital educational tools may likewise align DLO design with empirically grounded classroom preferences, rather than relying on abstract technical specifications. The use of structured DCEs may also inform evidence-based revisions of ICT integration frameworks, supporting decisions that reflect authentic instructional needs. Furthermore, the study underscores the pedagogical value of attending to teachers’ situated preferences, offering a data-informed foundation for co-designing digital learning environments that support differentiated instruction, creativity, and meaningful technology integration. The research also demonstrates the analytical capacity of DCEs to capture complex decision-making in educational contexts, while the combined use of DCMs and UTAUT within an authentic STEAM-based intervention provides a transferable model for future empirical studies and program design. The observed post-intervention improvements in effort expectancy, performance expectancy, and overall attitudes—as captured through the adapted UTAUT scale—highlight the effectiveness of experiential, STEAM-based professional development in fostering educators’ confidence and openness toward digital innovation. In addition, the segmentation analyses revealed meaningful variations in preference structures according to teaching experience and training background, suggesting the potential of DCEs to guide the development of more targeted and inclusive ICT initiatives. Finally, the persistent aversion to unfamiliar digital tools observed across all subgroups echoes concerns identified in the broader literature, suggesting that such tendencies may reflect structural or psychological barriers with cross-cultural relevance. Although the study is based on data collected in Greece, its insights are relevant to a broader international context. The combined use of DCMs and UTAUT offers a transferable framework for analyzing preference structures and attitudinal dynamics in diverse educational systems. The findings echo global concerns regarding familiarity, adaptability, and professional autonomy in digital tool adoption. As such, this research contributes not only to national educational reform but also to the global discourse on effective, responsive, and inclusive technology integration in primary education.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Crete (UOC)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Kostaki, Stela Marina
- Κωστάκη, Στέλα-Μαρίνα
Subjects
dc:subject × 19- Ανάλυση δηλωμένων προτιμήσεων
- Ψηφιακά Μαθησιακά Αντικείμενα (ΨΜΑ)
- Λήψη διδακτικών αποφάσεων
- Επαγγελματική ανάπτυξη
- Αποδοχή της τεχνολογίας στην εκπαίδευση
- Παρέμβαση βασισμένη στο STEAM
- UTAUT
- Stated preference analysis
- Digital Learning Objects (DLOs)
- Instructional decision-making
- Professional development
- Technology acceptance in education
- STEAM-based intervention
- Εκπαίδευση
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση και Έρευνα της εκπαίδευσης
- Education
- Social Sciences
- Education and Educational Research
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/60009