Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Διερεύνηση της φυσιολογίας θρέψης και διατροφής εκτρεφόμενων λαβρακιών με βιοτεχνολογικά επεξεργασμένα κτηνοτροφικά όσπρια

Abstract

dc:description

The aquaculture sector continues to grow, playing a crucial role in providing high-quality food to meet global nutritional needs. However, the sustainability of the industry still faces significant challenges, with the most critical being its dependence on fishmeal (FM), which remains the primary source of high-value protein in aquafeeds. Additionally, the increased demand for imported plant-based alternative raw materials, primarily soy products, has been linked to environmental issues such as deforestation and the destruction of habitats for many animal species. Despite these concerns, imported soy remains a major protein source in aquafeeds, being the main plant-based ingredients typically used to replace FM. Sustainable aquaculture practices therefore require reducing the inclusion levels of FM in diets while simultaneously incorporating alternative protein sources that are produced with a significantly lower environmental footprint. Forage legumes can significantly enhance agricultural sustainability, serving as an important plant-based source of protein and energy while offering a favourable amino acid profile. However, the presence of antinutritional factors (ANFs) limits their use in aquafeeds, as they can inhibit the activity of digestive enzymes and/or reduce the bioavailability of dietary nutrients. In order to maximize the nutritional value and utilization efficiency of legumes, it is crucial to reduce or inactivate ANFs before their inclusion in aquafeeds. As legumes have become a promising alternative raw material for aquafeed formulation, particularly as fishmeal inclusion levels continue to decrease, various biotechnological processes, such as the application of exogenous enzymes and microorganisms, are being explored to optimize their nutritional profile and minimize ANF content. Among these, solid-state enzymatic hydrolysis (SSEH) and solid-state fermentation (SSF) have both been shown to improve the nutritional value of plant-based raw materials while simultaneously reducing their ANF content. In the present research, a literature review was initially conducted on locally produced legumes in Greece, followed by an evaluation of their nutritional profile and ANF content. Subsequently, research focused on identifying the exogenous enzymes commonly used in aquafeeds and their specific roles, as well as on exploring microorganisms suitable for application on solid substrates and their potential effects.The first in vitro experiment involved the application of SSEH. Three different combinations of exogenous enzymes were tested on three legume species under various processing conditions (moisture, temperature, pH, and time). The selected legumes were lupin (Lupinus albus), chickpea (Cicer arietinum), and faba bean (Favino faba). The enzyme mixtures included: (a) a multi-enzyme complex (ME) containing phytase, protease, xylanase, β-glucanase, cellulase, amylase, and pectinase; (b) a product containing xylanase, protease, and amylase (XPA); and (c) a combination of xylanase and phytase (XP). Each legume–enzyme combination was processed under: (i) standard conditions (8% moisture, 25 °C, 30 min), (ii) high moisture (45%), high temperature (50 °C), and extended duration (4 h), and (iii) two pH levels (natural and acidic). This process resulted in 27 enzymatic products, which were evaluated for protein content, changes in trypsin inhibitor levels, reduction in phytic acid and NSPs, and phosphorus release. Results showed that, in faba bean and chickpea, the processing conditions were the main factor reducing NSP levels, whereas in lupin both the enzyme composition and processing conditions played a significant role. Phytic acid reduction was most pronounced in the presence of phytase at pH 5.5 for all legume types. Phosphorus content increased in lupin hydrolysed with ME under high moisture and temperature. The combination of enzymatic and thermal treatment significantly reduced trypsin inhibitors in all tested legumes. Based on these findings, the enzymatic products showing the most promising changes were further evaluated for degree of protein hydrolysis (DH) to estimate protein digestibility. Lupin treated with the ME enzyme mixture exhibited the highest in vitro protein digestibility and was selected for use in the subsequent feeding trial.A total of 600 European sea bass (D. labrax, 11.2 ± 1.3 g) were used in the feeding trial. The fish were randomly distributed into 12 tanks (350 L each) and fed four experimental diets containing different ratios of soybean meal and enzymatically hydrolyzed lupin meal: Control (15% : 0%), Lupin 1 (5% : 7.5%), Lupin 2 (2.5% : 10%), and Lupin 3 (0% : 12.5%), for a period of 83 days, with three replicates per diet. The results showed significantly higher final body weight and specific growth rate (SGR), as well as a lower feed conversion ratio (FCR), in the group fed the Lupin 1 diet compared to the Control. The apparent digestibility coefficient (ADC) of crude protein was significantly higher in the Lupin 3 group, while the ADC of lipid was significantly higher in the Lupin 1 and Lupin 3 groups compared to the Control. Essential amino acid (EAA) deposition was highest in the Lupin 2 group, and a similar positive effect was observed for trypsin activity in both the pyloric caeca and intestine. Additionally, fish fed the enzymatically hydrolysed lupin meal showed an improved immune response, and no histopathological alterations were observed. Microbial diversity and abundance in the gut microbiota were also maintained, which is considered a key feature of sustainable dietary replacement. Overall, the findings demonstrated that solid-state enzymatically hydrolyzed lupin meal can completely replace soybean meal without negative impacts on growth performance. Furthermore, when included at 7.5%, it resulted in the best production performance.In the second in vitro experiment, SSF was applied. Specifically, three legumes (lupin, chickpea, and field pea) were selected as substrates for microbial inoculation. The microorganisms used for fermentation were Bacillus subtilis, Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Aspergillus niger. Different moisture levels, pH values, and fermentation durations were also tested. Solid-state fermentation produced 20 samples for each legume, which were analysed biochemically for nutritional value and reduction of antinutritional factors. In lupin, a significant increase in protein content was observed with A. niger (14–18%) and a 1–3% increase with S. cerevisiae and B. subtilis. The DH of protein increased significantly for all microorganisms, along with total phosphorus content, while phytic acid levels decreased significantly. Trypsin inhibitors were almost completely eliminated in all treatments. The DH of protein was highest with S. cerevisiae. Overall, A. niger showed the greatest effect on legume substrates, but its spore inactivation was not possible, so it was excluded from further evaluation. B. subtilis and S. cerevisiae showed similar effects, but B. subtilis required one extra day of fermentation, increasing production costs. Therefore, products derived from S. cerevisiae fermentation were further evaluated for NSP content. Results showed a significant reduction of NSP in lupin at 70% moisture and one day of fermentation. No significant changes were observed in chickpea, while NSP content increased in field pea. Based on the in vitro results, lupin fermented with S. cerevisiae was selected for the feeding trial due to its higher protein content, higher degree of protein hydrolysis, and greater reduction of NSP.A total of 600 European sea bass (D. labrax, 18.9 ± 2.2 g) were used in the feeding trial. Fish were randomly distributed into 12 tanks (350 L each) and fed four experimental diets containing different ratios of soybean meal and S. cerevisiae-fermented lupin meal: Control (15% : 0%), FRLUP 1 (5% : 10%), FRLUP 2 (2.5% : 12.5%), and FRLUP 3 (0% : 15%) for 71 days, with three replicates per diet. The results showed that growth performance indicators were not negatively affected when soybean meal was partially or fully replaced by fermented lupin meal. Replacing soybean with fermented lupin resulted in decrease in FCR and an increase in PER. Significantly higher protein and lipid ADC were observed in groups fed diets with high levels or total replacement of soybean meal by fermented lupin meal. Furthermore, trypsin activity in the pyloric caeca and intestine was significantly higher in all fermented lupin groups compared to the Control. A slight immunostimulatory effect was recorded in the FRLUP 2 group. The gut microbiota was dominated by Proteobacteria, Actinobacteria, and Firmicutes, a composition considered typical for sea bass. Overall, the results demonstrated that S. cerevisiae-fermented lupin effectively enhances the nutritional value of lupin and increases its potential as a sustainable substitute for soybean meal.After the completion of both feeding trials, trypsin activity in the pyloric caeca and intestine was evaluated for each experimental diet for a period of 24 hours. In both trials, 25 fish per tank were fed the respective diets at 2% of their body weight, and six fish per treatment were sampled at six different time points over a 24-hour period (0, 2, 4, 6, 8, and 24 h after feeding). In Experiment 1, trypsin activity in the pyloric caeca and intestine was consistently higher in the Lupin 1 group compared to the Control throughout the 24 h period. Lupin 2 and Lupin 3 groups showed significantly higher pyloric trypsin activity than the Control 6 h post-feeding. In Experiment 2, pyloric trypsin activity was significantly higher in all fermented lupin-fed groups up to 4 h after feeding, with FRLUP 1 maintaining higher activity even at 6 h. In the intestinal tract, trypsin activity remained higher at 6 h and 8 h post-feeding in all fermented lupin groups compared to the control. In both experiments, trypsin activity results indicated that lupin processed either by SSEH or by SSF led to elevated trypsin levels in the pyloric caeca and intestinal tract for most of the 24 h post-feeding period. In conclusion, the results of this study demonstrated that the applied biotechnological processes significantly improved the nutritional profile of legume meals by reducing antinutritional factors. The feeding trials confirmed that complete replacement of soybean meal with biotechnologically processed lupin meal is feasible without negatively affecting sea bass growth performance. Moreover, both low and high inclusion levels of processed lupin improved KPIs. The two biotechnological treatments also enhanced nutrient ADC, leading to improved feed utilization. A slight immunostimulatory effect was observed with the inclusion of processed ingredients, and trypsin activity significantly increased in the pyloric caeca and intestine, a finding closely linked to enhanced nutrient ADC. The application of such biotechnological processes could contribute to the sustainability of aquaculture by providing alternative raw materials to imported soybean meal while simultaneously supporting the agricultural sector.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Vasilaki, Antigoni
  • Βασιλάκη, Αντιγόνη

Subjects

dc:subject × 32

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/60156

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Vasilaki, Antigoni; Βασιλάκη, Αντιγόνη. Διερεύνηση της φυσιολογίας θρέψης και διατροφής εκτρεφόμενων λαβρακιών με βιοτεχνολογικά επεξεργασμένα κτηνοτροφικά όσπρια. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/60156