University of Ioannina
Investigation of neutron irradiation effects on the radiological and structural properties of tungsten materials for fusion energy applications
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe pursuit of sustainable, long-term energy solutions has intensified in recent years due to escalating global energy demands, driven by population growth, rising energy consumption per capita, and the limitations of conventional energy sources. Among the leading alternatives, nuclear fusion presents a promising pathway for future energy production, due to its potential for high energy output, minimal environmental impact, and inherent safety features. However, the successful realization of mass-scale fusion power depends on the performance and durability of plasma-facing materials (PFMs), which must endure extreme operational conditions, including exposure to high-energy neutrons, high temperatures, and intense particle fluxes. Tungsten (W) is a promising armor material for the divertor and the first wall in future fusion reactors, due to its numerous advantageous properties such as high melting point, high thermal conductivity, high thermal shock resistance, low coefficient of thermal expansion, high sputtering resistance, low hydrogen retention as well as low neutron activation. However, during neutron irradiation, W may undergo complex physical and compositional changes, including displacement damage within the crystal lattice and nuclear transmutations. These phenomena can significantly alter the material’s properties and thus impact reactor safety, longevity, and performance. While theoretical models have advanced our understanding of these effects, there remains a lack of integrated experimental validation of both transmutation behavior and defect evolution in W. The aim of this doctoral thesis is to provide a comprehensive experimental investigation of neutron-induced transmutations and open volume defects in three different types of tungsten materials (single crystal (SC), forged bar, and "cold"-rolled sheet) irradiated at temperatures and doses which are representative of the conditions anticipated in the plasma-facing components of ITER The SC serves as a model system for the investigation of the defect evolution, since in its non-irradiated state presents almost no dislocations and has the highest purity. The first objective of this study is to validate radionuclide inventory calculations of the transmutation products in W using γ-spectroscopy. These measurements are then compared against numerical calculations performed with the FISPACT-II inventory code, incorporating cross-section data from established nuclear data libraries. The second objective is to investigate the irradiation-induced open volume defects using positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy (PALS), to determine key microstructural parameters such as the total dislocation line density and effective void length density as a function of irradiation temperature and dose. The neutron irradiation experiments were conducted at the Belgian Material Test Reactor (BR2), where tungsten samples were subjected to fast neutron fluxes of approximately 7×10¹⁴ n/cm²/s (>0.1 MeV). The irradiation was performed at doses ranging from 0.12 to 0.83 displacements per atom (dpa) and at temperatures of 600, 800, 900 and 1200 °C. Notwithstanding the current study refers to neutron irradiations performed in a fission reactor, it is noted that the fission neutron spectrum is considered as adequately representative of the one encountered, for example, in the DEMO divertor. The main isotope production mechanism is via neutron capture reactions justifying the irradiation performed in a fission spectrum. Validation of the transmutation products calculation was performed by comparing calculated and experimental γ-spectroscopy specific activities for five detected isotopes. To this end, Monte Carlo simulations using MCNP 6.1 were employed to determine the neutron spectrum at each irradiation capsule and the resulting spectrum served as input for the FISPACT-II simulations. The comparison between experimental and calculated specific activities showed satisfactory agreement in some cases, while in others discrepancies were observed. These discrepancies show the limitations of current nuclear data in accurately describing the reactions occurring in neutron-irradiated tungsten. The results suggest that FISPACT-II inventory calculations using the TENDL-2019 provide a reliable estimate of Re and Os concentrations while EAF-2010 is more appropriate for calculating the Ta concentration in the samples. However, they also show the need for refined cross-section evaluations, particularly in the resonance energy range of neutron capture reactions, to enhance predictive accuracy in future applications, such as in fusion technology. A detailed investigation of the radiation-induced open volume defects was performed on the W samples using the PALS technique. The defects observed in the non-irradiated polycrystalline samples were dislocations and mono-vacancies with the "cold"-rolling process generating a greater density of dislocations compared to the forging process. The analysis of the PALS spectra of the irradiated W samples showed that neutron irradiation induced the formation of further dislocations, mono-vacancies, and large vacancy clusters (voids) having a diameter larger than 1 nm across all W grades. The irradiation temperature was found to significantly influence the defect evolution. In SC tungsten, an increase in temperature from 600 °C to 1200 °C led to a decrease in the average positron lifetime, indicative of defect recovery most probably associated with the coalescence of small voids into larger ones and the annihilation of dislocations and mono-vacancies. The bar exhibited maximum average positron lifetime at the irradiation temperatures of 800–900 °C, while the "cold"-rolled sheet demonstrated an increase in the average positron lifetime with temperature up to 900 °C followed by either a saturation or decrease of the increase rate at the irradiation temperature of 1200 °C. The different behavior of the mean positron lifetime for the three W grades indicates that the thermally activated defect recovery mechanisms are less effective in the presence of dislocations and the higher the inherent dislocation density is the more difficult it becomes for the irradiation induced defects to be annihilated as the irradiation temperature increases.As the irradiation temperature increases from 600 to 1200 °C, the short lifetime, which reflects annihilation in dislocations, mono-vacancies, and the defect-free bulk, decreases for all grades. The SC consistently exhibits the lowest values, indicating lower dislocation density and possibly mono-vacancies than bar and sheet. The long lifetime, which corresponds to positron annihilations in voids, increases as the irradiation temperature increases from 600 to 1200 °C for all grades, indicating that higher irradiation temperatures promote the growth of larger voids. However, in the SC, the long lifetime saturates after irradiation at 900 °C, indicating that the voids attain a critical size beyond which positron lifetime becomes insensitive to the void size. These observations suggest that the initial microstructure of the polycrystalline materials suppresses the defect recovery mechanisms. Further insight into defect evolution was provided by the application of the positron trapping model on the PALS spectra, which enabled the quantification of total dislocation line density and effective void length density. As the irradiation temperature increases from 600 to 1200 °C both the total dislocation line density and the effective void length density decrease for all irradiation doses. However, this decrease is more evident in the case of SC. These findings support the interpretation that thermally activated defect recovery mechanisms are less effective in these W grades. At low irradiation doses (0.12 and 0.19 dpa), all tungsten grades exhibited similar levels of radiation-induced damage, while a decrease was observed in the defect densities at 0.54 dpa across all materials which, in combination with the reduced specific activity data from γ-spectroscopy, suggests that the incident neutron fluence on these samples was lower than the nominal value. At the irradiation dose of 0.83 dpa, only the SC showed a notable increase in defect densities, whereas in the bar and especially in the sheet, the irradiation dose had little to no effect or even led to a reduction in radiation damage. Finally, the defect densities determined by the use of the trapping model are compared with those observed in TEM and the discrepancies are discussed. The present thesis provides an experimental investigation of neutron-induced transmutation and open volume defect accumulation in tungsten under irradiation temperatures and doses representative of the conditions anticipated in the plasma-facing components of ITER. By combining γ-spectroscopy and positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy measurements, the study validates the existing nuclear data on the main transmutation reactions of W and investigates the evolution of defect formation and recovery, as a function of irradiation temperature, dose and W grade. Overall, this work contributes to the refinement of damage models employed in fusion material design and provides critical insights for material selection aimed at extending the operational lifetime of plasma-facing components in future fusion reactors.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Chatzikos, Vasileios
- Χατζίκος, Βασίλειος
Subjects
dc:subject × 23- Βολφράμιο
- Ακτινοβολία νετρονίων
- Πυρηνική σύντηξη
- Υλικά αντιμετώπισης πλάσματος
- Προϊόντα μεταστοιχείωσης
- γ-Φασματοσκοπία
- FISPACT-II
- Φασματοσκοπία χρόνου ζωής εξαΰλωσης ποζιτρονίων
- Total dislocation line density
- Effective void length density
- Tungsten
- Neutron irradiation
- Nuclear fusion
- Plasma-facing materials
- Transmutation products
- γ-Spectroscopy
- Positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy
- Φυσική
- Φυσικές Επιστήμες
- Πυρηνική φυσική
- Physical Sciences
- Natural Sciences
- Nuclear Physics
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/60219