Back to search

University of Patras

Essays on efficiency and strategy of innovation focusing on heterogeneity and eco-innovation

Abstract

dc:description

1. Thesis Focus and StructureThe central focus of this dissertation is the investigation of the relationship between, on one side, the heterogeneity of firms’ innovation strategies and, on the other, the returns on their investments in innovative activities, with particular emphasis on environmental innovations. Returns are defined both in terms of technological innovation frontiers, using efficiency metrics, and in terms of the contribution of innovative activities to the broader set of firm operations, using innovation performance metrics. The Dissertation is structured in six (6) chapters. The first chapter establishes the overall framework, identifying the broader research gaps in the international literature both in theory and methodology, and emphasises the importance of addressing these gaps. The second chapter presents the data utilised for the empirical analysis. Specifically, it outlines the framework of the Community Innovation Survey (CIS) conducted by Eurostat and focuses on aspects of innovation strategy, intellectual property rights (IPR), ambidexterity, and the survey modules related to environmental innovation. In this context, the significance of studying innovation strategy and environmental innovation in follower countries (also referred to as non-usual suspects), where innovation systems are fragmented, is established. Below, I briefly present the main points of the Dissertation, which are developed around the following pillars: • Innovation Strategy Efficiency and Strategic Complexity • Environmental Innovation and Firm Size: A Configurational Approach • Environmental Process Innovation and Complementary Strategic Assets 2. Innovation Strategy Efficiency and Strategic ComplexityThe first essay examines the structural trade-off between innovation efficiency and the complexity of innovation strategy. Drawing on Teece’s (1986; 2018) Profiting from Innovation (PFI) framework, the chapter develops an original theoretical and methodological approach that goes beyond standard treatments by endogenising strategic choices into the efficiency estimation process, taking into account the role of complementary assets. It links firms’ competitive positioning to the innovation strategies they adopt, identifying two latent groups of innovative firms:(i) firms pursuing short-term returns based on innovation efficiency (competitive rent seekers), and(ii) firms seeking medium- to long-term monopoly rents (monopoly rent seekers).Two dimensions of innovation strategy are analysed: the breadth of the IPR portfolio, and ambidexterity in product and process innovation. Efficiency is estimated relative to heterogeneous innovation frontiers. The analysis shows that strategic complexity has significant implications for efficiency. While broad IPR portfolios may provide protection, rents, and bargaining power, they also involve managerial costs and uncertainty that tend to reduce efficiency. By contrast, narrower IPR strategies that allow faster appropriation of innovation outputs are associated with higher efficiency. Moreover, pursuing both ambidexterity and broad IPR portfolios further burdens efficiency. This results in a hierarchical structure of innovation strategies, shaped by competitive positioning, and reflected in heterogeneous but ordered innovation frontiers. The contribution of this essay lies in bridging the literature on innovation efficiency with that on innovation strategy, offering a unified understanding of how strategic complexity shapes efficiency boundaries. Methodologically, it introduces a new type of Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), the Innovation Strategy DEA (ISDEA), which allows the endogenous incorporation of strategic innovation choices. Managerially, the results suggest that firms must first recognise their competitive position and consider efficiency losses when adding layers of strategic complexity. At the policy level, the findings point to the need for more effective IPR regimes, particularly in contexts characterised by limited innovation capabilities, where complementary assets are scarce. 3. Environmental Innovation and Firm Size: A Configurational ApproachThis essay examines the relationship between environmental innovation and innovation performance using a configurational approach informed by complexity theory. Innovation performance is measured as the share of sales from new or significantly improved products. In contrast to traditional approaches that estimate net effects, the analysis shows that innovation performance results from multiple, simultaneous, and potentially alternative strategic configurations. The study considers environmental product and process innovations alongside access to external knowledge and internal absorptive capacity, reflecting firms’ knowledge base.Using fuzzy-set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA), the results show that small, medium, and large firms follow distinct strategic configurations leading to high innovation performance. Small firms benefit from external innovation collaborations that compensate for limited internal capabilities. Medium-sized firms, with stronger internal knowledge bases, combine process-oriented environmental innovations with complementary strategic elements. Large firms leverage environmental product innovation, supported by R&D investments and systematic access to external knowledge networks. The contribution is twofold: theoretically, it advances the literature on environmental innovation by integrating complexity and equifinality, demonstrating that there is no single strategic path to high innovation performance. Empirically, it provides strategy roadmaps tailored to technological and organisational characteristics across firm-size classes, informing policy discussions on green competitiveness. 4. Environmental Process Innovation and Complementary Strategic AssetsThis essay examines the impact of environmental process innovation on innovation performance, with a focus on marketing innovation as a complementary asset. A distinction is drawn between End-of-Pipe Technologies (EPT), adopted under regulatory pressure to reduce externalities, and Resource-Efficient Technologies (RET), adopted to improve efficiency. A four-equation structural model is estimated, one equation correcting for selection bias in the adoption of environmental innovations, using Conditional Mixed Process estimators. Principal Components Analysis is used to classify environmental innovations into RET and EPT categories. The results show that RET are positively associated with innovation performance, supporting the “win–win” logic. In contrast, EPT tend to reduce innovation performance due to costs and complexity. However, marketing innovation can counterbalance or reverse the negative effects of EPT, enabling firms to commercialise compliance-driven innovations. This highlights marketing innovation as a strategic asset that transforms constraint into opportunity. The essay situates itself at the intersection of research on environmental innovation adoption and its effects on performance. It shows that firms compelled by external pressures rely on marketing capabilities to extract value from innovation, while internally-driven environmental strategies yield performance benefits even without marketing complementation. 5. Conclusions, Limitations, and Future ResearchThe Dissertation contributes to the economics of innovation strategy by emphasising how strategic choices condition both the efficiency and performance of innovation investments, especially in environmental innovation contexts. It incorporates strategic factors—IPR breadth, ambidexterity, and distinctions between types of environmental technologies—into the measurement of innovation outcomes, and analyses configurational strategy patterns across firm sizes. Managerially, the findings suggest that decision-makers should weigh the costs and benefits of broad IPR portfolios and simultaneous product–process innovation. In environmental innovation, strategies should differ by firm size and knowledge base. The choice between RET and EPT carries distinct implications, and marketing innovation is particularly important when dealing with EPT. At the policy level, the results support the design of differentiated innovation policies based on firm heterogeneity, simplification of the IPR framework in the EU, strengthening of collaboration mechanisms for SMEs, and the development of differentiated policy instruments for RET and EPT. The dissertation is subject to certain limitations. The use of cross-sectional data limits the ability to identify causal relationships, instead focusing on associations. To strengthen causal inference and examine the temporal evolution of environmental innovation strategies, future research would benefit from drawing on panel data, which are currently not available. In addition, the study focuses on countries with moderate innovation performance, leaving open the question of whether the findings can be applied to more advanced innovation ecosystems. Finally, exploring other potential complementary assets such as R&D collaborations, organisational innovations, and business model innovations would be particularly insightful. Overall, the possible synergies form a broad yet promising field for further investigation.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Patras
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Koutsouradis, Georgios
  • Κουτσουράδης, Γεώργιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/60414

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Koutsouradis, Georgios; Κουτσουράδης, Γεώργιος. Essays on efficiency and strategy of innovation focusing on heterogeneity and eco-innovation. University of Patras, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/60414