Back to search

National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)

Πειραματική διερεύνηση της βιολογικής απομάκρυνσης αζώτου μέσω νιτρωδοποίησης-απονιτρωδοποίησης κατά την επεξεργασία στραγγιδίων αφυδάτωσης αναερόβια χωνεμένης ιλύος

Abstract

dc:description

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) apply processes such as thickening, anaerobic digestion and dewatering in order to remove the moisture, stabilize and sanitize the excess sludge. In large WWTPs, the anaerobic digestion process is usually applied to achieve efficient sludge treatment, while at the same time leading to energy production in the form of biogas. The anaerobically digested sludge is then sent to the mechanical dewatering process to reduce its moisture content. In the dewatering process, a side stream liquid waste is produced which is usually known as sludge reject water or sludge liquor and is characterized by its very high total and ammonium nitrogen concentration.In recent years, certain large WWTPs apply the pre-treatment of sewage sludge through thermal hydrolysis upstream of the anaerobic digestion process. In this process, sewage sludge is subjected to high pressure and temperature in order to facilitate the subsequent anaerobic digestion process. Thermal hydrolysis can increase the production of biogas during the anaerobic digestion process, while at the same time it can improve the efficiency of the mechanical dewatering process. The sludge reject water produced after the dewatering of thermally pre-treated digested sludge is characterized by higher concentrations of total and ammonium nitrogen when compared to conventional anaerobically digested and dewatered sludge reject water.The usual practice regarding the sludge reject water in WWTPs is to recirculate it at the inlet of the plant, thus increasing the nitrogen load of the plant by up to 25%. In recent years, the application of the separate side stream treatment of sludge reject water before its recirculation at the inlet of the WWTPs is applied in some plants to relieve them from the nitrogen loads that are applied. Due to the special characteristics of sludge reject water (high nitrogen load, low carbon to nitrogen (C/N) ratio, low biodegradable organic content), the biological nitrogen removal through the process of conventional nitrification/denitrification is problematic. Instead, the application of processes such as nitritation/denitritation and partial nitritation/anaerobic ammonium oxidation (anammox) seem to be the most feasible processes.The main objective of the present doctoral dissertation is to investigate the biological nitrogen removal from sludge reject water generated from thermally pretreated anaerobically digested sludge. To achieve this objective, the development and operation of a pilot-scale Sequencing Batch Reactor (SBR) with a working volume of 9 m³ was selected and implemented at the Psyttalia Wastewater Treatment Plant, where the biological nitrogen removal from sludge reject water was examined through the application of the nitritation/denitritation process.Furthermore, the specific objectives included the investigation of the factors that may affect the implementation of the nitritation/denitritation process, such as temperature, free ammonia (FA) concentration, free nitrous acid (FNA) concentration, and the addition of an external organic carbon source during denitritation process. More specifically, the effect of temperature on the nitritation rate (Ammonium Uptake Rate - AUR) and on the denitritation rate (Nitrogen Uptake Rate - NUR) was examined through a series of batch experiments using the biomass of the pilot SBR. These experiments also led to the calculation of the specific temperature coefficient (θ) of the Arrhenius equation that is applied to normalize the AUR/NUR rates to the reference temperature of 20 °C. A series of batch experiments was also conducted to investigate the effect of different free ammonia (FA) and different free nitrous acid (FNA) concentrations in the mixed liquor, on the nitritation process of the SBR biomass.During the present research, a different denitritation process was also examined through lab-scale reactors for the application of autotrophic denitritation using S₂O₃²⁻ as electron donor. In order to investigate the feasibility of applying the autotrophic denitritation process using S₂O₃²⁻ as electron donor, three identical SBRs were operated for about 170 days. The investigation of the efficiency of the combined suspended-attached growth process to remove nitrogen via nitrite from thermally pre-treated sludge reject water, was carried out using a lab-scale IFAS-SBR (30 L volume filled with floating carrier media (30% or 50%)) that operated for more than 530 days. The pilot-scale SBR unit was operated for approximately 985 consecutive days, achieving high removal efficiencies for both ammonium nitrogen and total nitrogen from sludge reject water. The start-up period of the SBR, defined as the time required to achieve stable nitritation instead of conventional nitrification, lasted approximately 35 days. The primary reason for the washout of nitrite-oxidizing bacteria (NOB) and the accumulation of nitrite was the high free ammonia (FA) concentrations in the mixed liquor (>10 mg NH₃–N L⁻¹), resulting from the gradual increase of the nitrogen loading rate (NLR).Following the start-up period, the operation of the pilot SBR unit was divided into four distinct operational periods. The classification of these periods was based on the application of different NLRs and the use of different external organic carbon sources. The maximum NLR applied to the pilot SBR was 0.51 ± 0.09 kg N m⁻³ d⁻¹, under which the system achieved very high ammonium nitrogen (NH₄–N) removal efficiencies (90.1 ± 4.9%) but exhibited reduced performance in terms of total nitrogen (TN) removal compared to the other operational periods (TN removal = 77.5 ± 12.4%). The reduced TN removal efficiency was attributed to the insufficient duration of the anoxic phases, which did not allow complete denitritation to be achieved.It was determined that the operational limit of the examined sludge reject water treatment system corresponded to nitrogen loading rates of up to 0.5 kg N m⁻³ d⁻¹. At higher NLRs, due to partial denitritation, there was a risk of gradual nitrite accumulation to undesirable levels. During the remaining operational periods of the pilot SBR unit, the average NLR was relatively stable, ranging between 0.31 and 0.33 kg N m⁻³ d⁻¹. Under these conditions, very high ammonium nitrogen removal efficiencies (>90%) and high total nitrogen removal efficiencies ranging from 81.4 ± 19.2% to 91.1 ± 8.6% were achieved.The biodegradable organic content of sludge reject water was very low, with only 5.8% of the total COD being biodegradable, necessitating the addition of an external organic carbon source to achieve denitritation. During the reactor start-up period as well as during the 1st operational period, sodium acetate and sludge liquor originating from the thickening of primary sludge at the Psyttalia WWTP were used as external carbon sources. During the 2nd and 3rd operational periods, sodium acetate was used exclusively, whereas during the 4th operational period, only sludge liquor from the thickening of primary sludge was applied.During the 3rd and 4th operational periods, the pilot unit was operated under similar conditions but with different external carbon sources, in order to conduct a direct comparison between the two substrates. The results demonstrated that the use of sodium acetate as an external carbon source resulted in higher denitritation rates compared to the use of sludge liquor from primary sludge thickening. Specifically, sodium acetate led to a 15% increase in the average denitritation rates and a 10% increase in the overall total nitrogen removal efficiency of the unit. Nevertheless, the use of sludge liquor from the primary sludge thickening unit constitutes a satisfactory zero-cost solution which, when combined with a commercially available external carbon source, could achieve efficient nitrogen removal while reducing the overall operational cost of such systems.A major disadvantage of the exclusive use of sludge liquors from the thickening of primary sludge as an external carbon source is the requirement for the addition of large volumes of this substrate during the denitritation phase in order to achieve the required organic carbon concentration, which may necessitate the design of larger-volume SBR reactors.Given the requirement for the addition of an external organic carbon source during the denitritation process, the application of the alternative autotrophic denitritation process was also investigated within the framework of the present doctoral research. Specifically, the autotrophic denitritation process was examined in lab-scale systems using thiosulfate (S₂O₃²⁻) as the electron donor.As demonstrated, autotrophic denitritation can be successfully applied but presents significant disadvantages compared to conventional heterotrophic denitritation process. In particular, based on both the daily operation of the lab-scale systems and batch experiments, autotrophic denitritation exhibited a pronounced lag phase (more than 20 hours), observed from the time the system was fed with synthetic wastewater until the onset of the denitritation process. Furthermore, the denitritation rates recorded ranged between 0.93 and 1.53 mg NO₂–N gVSS⁻¹ h⁻¹ and were significantly lower than the corresponding NURs achieved through heterotrophic denitritation.Furthermore, autotrophic denitritation resulted in the consumption of alkalinity and a continuous decrease in pH in the mixed liquor, thereby increasing the requirements for chemical addition for pH control. The main advantage of applying autotrophic denitritation using Na₂S₂O₃ as the electron donor, compared to heterotrophic denitritation using sodium acetate (C₂H₃NaO₂), was the reduced cost, by up to 60% per kilogram of nitrite removed.In order to further investigate the nitritation/denitritation process, batch experiments were also conducted using biomass obtained from the pilot-scale SBR reactor, focusing on the evaluation of different factors that may affect the process. Specifically, the effect of temperature on nitritation rates (Ammonium Uptake Rate, AUR) and denitritation rates (Nitrite Uptake Rate, NUR) was examined, as well as the influence of free ammonia (FA) and free nitrous acid (FNA) on nitritation rates.Regarding temperature, it was identified as a determining factor for achieving high AUR and NUR, as it significantly affects the activity of the biomass in such systems. Experimental results obtained at different temperatures indicated that both AUR and NUR increased in an almost linear manner with increasing temperature. Indicatively, at 30 °C, the average AUR were 5.2 times higher than those observed at 15 °C, while similar trends were recorded for NURs. Moreover, these experiments were used for the calculation of the temperature coefficient (θ), which can be incorporated into an Arrhenius-type equation to normalize AUR and NUR values to 20 °C, thus eliminating the effect of experimental temperature variations. Specifically, the θ value determined for the nitritation process was 1.124, while for denitritation it was equal to 1.109.Batch experiments investigating the effect of different FA concentrations (ranging from 1.75 to 88 mg NH₃–N L⁻¹) on the nitritating biomass of the pilot SBR unit, demonstrated that the ammonia-oxidizing bacteria (AOB) were fully acclimated to high FA concentrations. In particular, no inhibitory effects on AUR were observed even at FA concentrations as high as 88 mg NH₃–N L⁻¹. In contrast, similar experiments conducted with conventional nitrifying biomass (originating from a conventional WWTP) exhibited significant inhibition of AUR (>50%) at FA concentrations close to 20 mg NH₃–N L⁻¹.Experiments examining the effect of different FNA concentrations (ranging from 4 to 28 μg HNO₂–N L⁻¹) revealed significant inhibition of AUR (approximately 50%) when FNA concentrations exceeded 10 μg HNO₂–N L⁻¹. Nevertheless, a significant degree of acclimation of the pilot SBR biomass to elevated FNA concentrations was also observed. Corresponding experiments using conventional nitrifying biomass showed considerably higher inhibition of nitrification at high FNA concentrations in the mixed liquor compared to that observed for the nitritating biomass.Despite the satisfactory performance of the pilot SBR unit in treating sludge reject water from thermally pre-treated digested sludge, the application of a system combining both suspended and attached growth biomass was further investigated, aiming to potentially increase the applied nitrogen loading rates. A lab-scale Integrated Fixed-Film Activated Sludge Sequencing Batch Reactor (IFAS-SBR) with a working volume of 30 L was selected and operated for five distinct operational periods (540 days of operation).By applying the nitritation/denitritation process for the treatment of sludge reject water from thermally pretreated anaerobically digested sludge, the IFAS-SBR system achieved very high removal efficiencies for both NH₄–N (91.3–96.9%) and TN (91.5–94.6%) in all operational periods, even at periods when very high nitrogen loading rates reaching up to 1.0 ± 0.02 kg N m⁻³ d⁻¹ were applied. This NLR was approximately twice the maximum applied in the pilot-scale SBR system, highlighting the significant contribution of attached growth biomass in sludge reject water treatment.Considering the influence of temperature on the nitritation/denitritation process, it should be noted that the maximum NLR applied in the pilot SBR unit was achieved during a period when the mixed liquor temperature ranged at 26.2 ± 4.5 °C. In contrast, the IFAS-SBR reactor was able to operate at a double NLR under substantially lower operating temperatures, with the mixed liquor temperature during the period of maximum NLR being close to 19.5 ± 1.8 °C. The development of attached growth biomass in the IFAS-SBR system required a considerable acclimation period, before a significant biofilm concentration (23 g TSS m⁻²) was observed after approximately 100 days of reactor operation.The composition of the attached biomass varied depending on the operational conditions in the IFAS-SBR reactor, as reflected in its fluctuating contribution to nitritation and denitritation processes across different periods. The maximum contribution of attached growth biomass to nitritation was observed during the 3rd operational period, accounting for the oxidation of 23.1% of the ammonium nitrogen converted to nitrite per day. At the same time, the highest contribution to denitritation process was recorded during the 2nd operational period, during which the attached growth biomass was responsible for the reduction of 55.1% of nitrite to nitrogen gas per day.The IFAS-SBR reactor, particularly during periods operated with a 50% carrier filling ratio compared to period with 30% of carrier filling ratio, demonstrated a greater effectiveness in treating higher daily volumes of sludge reject water and achieving higher ammonium and total nitrogen removal efficiencies compared to the conventional suspended-growth SBR system.In summary, the treatment of sludge reject water from thermally pretreated anaerobically digested sludge can be effectively achieved through the nitritation/denitritation process using either SBR or IFAS-SBR configurations. The use of an IFAS-SBR reactor can achieve a better nitrogen removal performance while simultaneously allowing a reduction of up to 50% in the required reactor volume compared to a conventional SBR system. This advantage of reduced reactor volume can be further exploited by designing an IFAS-SBR reactor with a volume exceeding the minimum required, thereby enabling the utilization of sludge liquors from the thickening of primary sludge as an external organic carbon source. Such an approach can lead to a substantial reduction in the overall operational cost of such systems.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National Technical University of Athens (NTUA)
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Statiris, Evangelos
  • Στατήρης, Ευάγγελος

Subjects

dc:subject × 16

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/60493

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Statiris, Evangelos; Στατήρης, Ευάγγελος. Πειραματική διερεύνηση της βιολογικής απομάκρυνσης αζώτου μέσω νιτρωδοποίησης-απονιτρωδοποίησης κατά την επεξεργασία στραγγιδίων αφυδάτωσης αναερόβια χωνεμένης ιλύος. National Technical University of Athens (NTUA), 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/60493