Abstract
dc:descriptionThe central issue addressed in this thesis concerns the institutional incompatibility between the co operative enterprise and the dominant institutional framework, which has historically been shaped to serve the needs, values, and mechanisms of the capitalist enterprise. Its aim is to examine the extent to which the co operative mode of economic organisation converges with or diverges from the institutional framework of the capitalist enterprise, to delineate the conditions of viability and resilience of co operative enterprises, and to illuminate the mechanisms through which a co operative ecosystem reproduces itself, scales, and networks within and against the capitalist system. The central juxtaposition of the co operative principle ‘one member - one vote’ against the logic of ‘one unit of capital - one vote’ delineates the analytical field and permits a systematic comparison of institutional rules, governance structures, and incentives between the two forms of enterprise. Within this framework, a coherent set of research questions is posed regarding: the degree of convergence or incompatibility of institutions; the similarities and differences in governance between the co operative and the capitalist enterprise; the mechanisms of networking and reproduction of the co operative model; and resilience in periods of crisis. Approaches from institutional economics are employed to analyse the governance mechanisms of the co operative enterprise and to describe/interpret the multi level dynamics at the levels of the individual, the organisation and the ecosystem. Although the historical and theoretical discussion on co operative enterprises is extensive, the processes of networking and the mechanisms by which the model is reproduced by the co operative movement itself have been studied less systematically. The selection of the Mondragón Co operative Group (MCC) as the empirical field rests on the international recognition of its significance as an integrated example of collective governance, innovation, and social embeddedness within a changing social and economic environment. The study of the Mondragón Corporation draws on bibliographic and secondary sources as well as semi structured interviews, with the aim of mapping the rules, routines and interactions that govern collective action. The analytical framework is grounded in Elinor Ostrom’s Institutional Analysis and Development (IAD) model, adopting a holistic approach that distinguishes three distinct spheres of institutional change -economic, cognitive and political - and three levels of analysis - individual/member, organisation, ecosystem. Within this approach, the case study is well suited to an in depth understanding of complex institutional arrangements, as it examines the long term evolution of a network of co operatives in contexts of internationalisation as well as crises. The thesis comprises three parts. Part A develops the theoretical background and methodological framework for understanding the co operative enterprise through its historical evolution and the lens of institutional economics. It includes a historical review of the co operative movement (from its early forms to the twenty first century), the codification of core definitions (ICA/ILO/UN guidance), and the conceptual treatment of the structural elements of governance, networking, innovation, and the ‘ecosystem’ as a defining dimension of co operative organisation. Within this framework, the co operative is compared with the capitalist enterprise in order to bring to the fore the fundamental differences in economic organisation, as well as the conditions for sustainable entrepreneurship in the co operative sector. Part B presents the empirical account of the case study. The historical genesis and evolution of Mondragón are analysed in three periods: (a) 1870-1965, from the social ferment in the Basque Country to the institutional formation of the first co operatives and the instruments of finance and social security; (b) 1966-1985, in which the balance between growth and crisis within the ecosystem is examined, with the institutionalisation of participation (social councils), the creation of technological and educational institutions (e.g., Ikerlan), and adaptations to macroeconomic disruptions; and (c) 1985-2023, marked by internationalisation, the introduction of central governance bodies (Co operative Congress, General Council), the creation of inter co operative funds (FISO, FEPI), transformations in organisational design, and the management of critical events (e.g., the 2008 crisis, the collapse of Fagor in 2013) that led to substantial institutional reforms. The chronological and thematic analysis highlights adaptability, solidarity through shared institutions, polycentric governance, and the embedding of knowledge and innovation as an organisational capability. In Part C, the historical findings are interpreted through the lens of institutional analysis, with an emphasis on the complexity of Mondragón’s institutions and the identification of how events and choices at different levels (individual, organisation, ecosystem) intersect with rules and reshape collective action. The conceptual schema of the ‘virtuous circle’ of the co operative model’s evolution links the literature on co operative governance (member participation, incentive alignment, polycentric structures) with institutional analysis (formal/informal rules, spheres of change, specialisation). The central conclusion is that the degree of incompatibility between the co operative and the capitalist modes of organisation is not static. It depends upon the configuration of governance rules, the architecture of incentives, and the ecosystem’s capacity to generate knowledge. When the co operative enterprise embeds institutions of solidarity (common funds), mechanisms of adaptation (workplace arrangements with a democratic identity), and organisational learning, it exhibits high resilience in periods of recession and crisis. Secondly, internationalisation and the adoption of corporate forms introduce new challenges to co operative principles and values (equality, participation), requiring revisions in governance and a redefinition of subsidiary autonomy so as to preserve network cohesion without eroding co operative values. In conclusion, the co operative enterprise constitutes a distinct institutional form of the economy, in which democratic participation is transformed into organisational capability. The dialectical relationship between the institutional framework and the co operative enterprise is captured by the ‘virtuous circle’. This is a synthetic interpretive schema for the scaling and renewal of the institutional framework of co operatives. This interpretation rests on the interactions among the individual, the organisation, the co operative ecosystem and the wider environment, without compromising value based and organisational identity. It shows how informal practices are transformed into robust formal rules, providing the foundation for the development and resilience of the co operative model. The model of polycentric governance accounts for the resilience of the co operative institution in the face of crises and challenges, and explains how it addresses the trade off between organisational speed/efficiency and the quality/depth of member participation.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Georgiou, Apostolos
- Γεωργίου, Απόστολος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20- Συνεταιριστική επιχείρηση
- Θεσμικό πλαίσιο
- Θεσμικά οικονομικά
- Mondragón
- Κοινωνική οικονομία
- Καπιταλιστική επιχείρηση
- Cooperative enterprise
- Institutional framework
- Institutional economics
- Mondragón Cooperative Group
- Social economy
- Capitalist enterprise
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Επιχειρήσεις
- Οικονομικά
- Economics and Business
- Social Sciences
- Business
- Ecomonics
Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/60511