Back to search

University of Crete (UOC)

Mare Νostrum: monumentality as cooperation and interaction: at the origins of centralized island societies in prehistoric Mediterranean (the Maltese Archipelago, Sardinia, Corsica, Crete and the Balearics)

Abstract

dc:description

The study explores mediterranean island monumentality in the Maltese Archipelagos, Sardinia, Corsica, Crete and The Balearics, in the longue durée of the Neolithic and the Bronze Age, in relation to social and economic changes and the origins of stratification and centralised organisation. It begins with an island-by-island examination of monumentality within the specific environmental, cultural and economic context of each case. Then continues with a contextual Mediterranean-wide reading, discussing monumentality within the overall socio-economic phenomena of the studied eras, drawing some broad common patterns over certain periods: (4100/3600 BC–3000 BC). The first large scale construction projects appeared in the Mediterranean among mostly agropastoral communities, in different contexts of interaction, however. In the Maltese Archipelagos the temple and hypogea occur seemingly in isolation from the outside world. In Sardinia, Monte D’Accodi and the domus de janas involve communities participating to exchange networks, gradually focused more on metals instead of obsidian. (3000 –2300 BC). Populations increase and a great elaboration noted in the Final Neolithic and Early Bronze Age cultural contexts. Monumental structures in Central Mediterranean (Malta and Sardinia) reflect a central regional role and strong communal investment. For Eastern Mediterranean and the Aegean this is a flourishing time of vivid exchange and interaction, involving many operating centres. 2300 –2200/100 BC: A turbulent time coinciding with the 4.2k aridification event. Major cultural shifts, site destructions and/or collapse, is noted, reflected also in monumentality. Paucity of exchange networks, but also high mobility, throughout the Mediterranean. 2200/100–1750 BC: New forms of monumental architecture (Cretan Palaces, Cyclopean Architecture in Sardinia, and possibly in Corsica and the Balearics) in a period of re-emerging cultural expressions, economic strategies, and exchange networks. In the Near East, there is a rise in urbanization, centralization and re-shaped exchange networks, driven by the quest for metals, and especially, bronze. 1750–1450 BC: Characteristic monumental structures (Cretan palaces, Sardinia nuraghi and tombe dei giganti, Corsican torri, Balearic navetas), of varied elaboration, size and interregional influence, are focal places of the communities’ socio-cultural structures, and organization and management of production in a period of cultural boom and vivid material and cultural interregional exchange. In Eastern Mediterranean, Crete presents more evident signs of centralization (Knossos hegemony), while in Central and West Mediterranean no such signs are attested. 1450 BC–1200 BC: Monumental structures take more differentiated and centralized features. Yet in the Central-West Mediterranean there are still no tangible signs of established socio-economic stratification. In Eastern Mediterranean, in Crete and Helladic Mainland political hierarchies reach their peak while common symbols, values, and standardized products are attested all over. There, economic and political intensification and centralization have ostentatiously materialized in monumentality. 1200 BC–850 BC: A time of unrest, when many centres burn to the ground and cultures perish in the East, and Mediterranean cultures go through significant transformative shifts. But in the West, accumulation of wealth and rising socio-economic differentiations become more evident and exchange networks continue in the early 1st millennium BC, until they unified again, East and West, under the Phoenician maritime power. This outline suggests that the studied island communities were significantly, even if differently, affected by conditions prevailing in the whole Mediterranean world. Similar modes of production operating within an inter-regional context and affecting, by the same socio-economic phenomena, the related Mediterranean cultures: 1) Through rather concomitant transitional phases, which corresponded to world-scale socio-economic shifts, 2) A techno-economic articulation that favoured a gradually increasing communal cooperation and centralization, 3) An overall context of local, regional and interregional integration. In this context it is argued that it is very hard to sustain that the main reason behind either monumentality, or the process of centralization was simply elite coercion. But rather, large-scale architectures appear to be resulting from complex collective labour and the co-operation of working groups in a common project, suggesting an overall entanglement of the community/ies involved. Moreover, that the rise of economic differentiation should not be perceived as a natural process but rather as a potential enabled by systemic transformations of the socio-economic system. Some relevant questions that study addresses are the following: How was the co-operation of the working groups achieved in each case, by what means and for what purpose? How did these collective achievements affect the overall production of the respective communities? Were they restricted to the monumental constructions, or were these only parts of a wider economic entanglement of the communities? To trace what triggered such systematic communal cooperation and economic interweaving, we suggest reading large-scale structure as integrally related to their communities’ overall productive process and need for interaction, exchange and coordination. So, from this view, monumentality in the Mediterranean islands makes sense as originating from communal initiatives, and social symbolisms, operating within a context of changes in production and subsistence that fuelled greater socio- economic, and maybe also political, centralization during the Bronze Age. This was characterized by craft specialization, extended technical division of labour, and by extensive exchange, and accumulation of transformable and transferable value. Common concepts of valuating were developed and, possibly, expressed by a “monetized” concept of metals structured upon a system of economic interdependence and interaction, formed through subsistence practices and cultural responses to stress caused by environmental, techno-economic, and overall social phenomena. This defined the communities and enabled the potentials of a materialized socio-economic stratification and centralization. The effects of this process were perhaps most evident in Eastern Mediterranean, which presents more hierarchical political forms, violently disrupted, nonetheless, in the 12th century BC, possibly due to the loss of both social consensus from the part of the community, and economic control from the part of the administration.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Crete (UOC)
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Vratsalis-Pantelaios, Antonios
  • Βρατσάλης-Παντελαίος, Αντώνιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 29

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/60697

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Vratsalis-Pantelaios, Antonios; Βρατσάλης-Παντελαίος, Αντώνιος. Mare Νostrum: monumentality as cooperation and interaction: at the origins of centralized island societies in prehistoric Mediterranean (the Maltese Archipelago, Sardinia, Corsica, Crete and the Balearics). University of Crete (UOC), 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/60697