Back to search

National and Kapodistrian University of Athens

Der Raum der Stadt als umkämpftes Konfrontationsfeld: Fallbeispiel Rotes Wien

Abstract

dc:description

In the interwar period, a unique project of social transformation was launched in Vienna through a reform program designed to benefit the broad mass of the population. The driving force and organizer of these efforts was the Social Democratic Party of Austria (SDAP), which, thanks to the absolute majority it succeeded to achieve in the Vienna City Council elections, it managed now to have the control of the local government. The Party was a huge organization, with hundreds of thousands of members and a far-reaching network of trade unions and other organizations, through which it attempted to address every aspect of social life: from cradle to grave. The Social Democrats' program aimed at modernizing and expanding the education and healthcare systems, as well as establishing a cultural hegemony of the working class, which was considered a necessary step before gaining political power at the central level. The goal was to cultivate a "new man," since, in the leadership's view, only mentally and physically healthy individuals could fulfill this task. However since this ideal type was out of touch with reality, the leadership frequently accused the workers of lacking sufficient "class consciousness" and failing to fulfill their "duties" and "responsibilities." Although the proletariat was seen as the new Messiah of society, morally superior to all other classes, the leaders placed little trust in it. Workers' initiative and self-reliance were not encouraged. There were instead quite suppressed. The lower classes were considered "uncultured" and had to be patronized at all levels. This was especially true for women, who were primarily treated as mothers, with the stabilization of the nuclear family being a central goal. This has resulted that only a few members could be truly active. The fundamental principle was the party unity, with a strictly top-down hierarchical mechanism, with decisions made by a small circle only. Intra-party democracy was limited, discussions and confrontations at the grassroots level were rare, discriminations, were made between "good" and "bad" proletarians. Appeals were made to the sense of dignity of "diligent and conscientious people." What however distinguishes the example of "Red Vienna" to this day: it is the gigantic program for the construction of social housing, with which the acute housing shortage was dealt with. Based on Marx, the labor movement considered the housing problem within the capitalistic system to be unsolvable. There were also fears that if workers were to settle down, they would easily be integrated into the system. The Austro-Marxists, on the other hand, had a positive view of the modern metropolis, seeing it as a place where the proletariat could develop further, cultivate its class consciousness, and find its way to the party. However, they lacked a concrete plan for solving the problem. The acute housing shortage, however, forced the new Viennese City government to act quickly. A large-scale housing construction program was not initially planned and only gradually came about. Since there were few large factories in the city, it was hoped that the working class could undergo a transformation in the area of reproduction within the City's large housing complexes. The new quality of housing was intended to produce new people with different habits. Therefore, tenants were carefully selected so that they would conform, as closely as possible to the ideal image of the productive worker and family father. By improving the conditions for the reproduction of labor power, a more productive workforce was to be created, one that would contribute to increased production and economic development. As a result, those who needed it most desperately were denied housing, and many people in the City remained homeless. The residents of the new housing complexes found themselves in a space prefabricated by "experts," impossible to modify or change and in which their individual needs could not be expressed. They had to conform to strict rules; the surveillance, control and the despotism of the factory, were thus transferred to their own living spaces. On behalf of the authority of the building manager, state power also moved in; the state extended its sphere of influence into new areas and was intruded into the private lives of the residents. Their social interactions were to be mediated through party structures. In this way, proletarian solidarity was institutionalized, nullified, and standardized. The foundation of those considerations is the theoretical approach hat society does not exist outside of space. Space is to be understood as a social product of specific production and class relations. The capitalist city is never “completed”, never "finished". It is constantly under construction. It is a complex ecosystem created by human labor, yet this labor is not socially recognized. The unequal access of different classes, groups, and genders to public space, leads to differing perceptions of everyday life and urban space, making it a contested arena of confrontation. What connects people could not therefore be found solely in the workplace. Likewise, the class struggle is also waged outside of production. It is not simply a struggle for control over the means of production and social surplus. Forms of exploitation and oppression also exist outside the workplace. The aim of this research is to understand how the Social Democratic Party was able to build its alliances with specific social classes and social strata. What were the concrete material interests, which did these groups see represented in the policies of the SDAP? What role did culture, sport and the press play in the collective formation and identification with the party? Above all, I am interested to understand the connections between urban planning, by the Social Democratic Municipal Administration, the formation of these local alliances, as well as the conflicts and tensions that resulted from the fact that decisions were made and implemented "from above", without any grassroots involvement. These decisions often contradicted the practices, lifestyles, and fundamental needs of these segments of the population. The leadership's endeavor to regulate and control every aspect of social life created a system that most found oppressive and from which they sought to escape. The Interwar period in Austria was also characterized by an increased willingness to use political violence. Right-wing forces, in particular, resorted to violence to achieve their goals and intimidate their opponents. However, all major political parties maintained "self-defense units." The SDAP kept an ambivalent relationship with "violence" (although this work acknowledges that there is no universally valid, comprehensive definition of "violence"). On the one hand, the strategy of "defensive force" was advocated, meaning the use of armed force only when democratic institutions were threatened. On the other hand, the Party employed military terminology and tolerated, at the very least, the violent disruption of political rallies held by other parties. Even in 1927, the situation of large segments of Vienna's lower classes remained precarious. Poverty, unemployment, deplorable housing conditions, and even hunger and disease, continued to characterize the daily lives of many for whom the Social Democratic reforms were not bearing fruit quickly enough. Consequently, those people developed little trust in the Republic and its institutions. Class hatred toward the wealthy was deeply ingrained, which then deeply influenced the leadership of the Social Democrats. They belonged to different worlds, had different life experiences, and thus exhibited different behaviors.Followinga series of court rulings that acquitted the murderers of workers, pent-up social anger erupted on July 15, 1927. The uprising claimed 84 lives among demonstrators and bystanders, as well as 5 lives among the security forces, and caused considerable damage, including the burning of the Palace of Justice. The Social Democratic leadership tried in vain to shift responsibility for the events onto a small minority outside the movement. As a result, it lost support on both sides: among its more conservative voters, who were frightened by the events, and among those who have gone to the streets that day and were faced with police bullets. Such breaches of trust are not always immediately apparent, of course, but the fact remains that after the 15th of July 1927, the confidence of broad sections of the working class in the party was never the same. At that time, Vienna was a multinational society, but by no means a multicultural one. The Social Democratic Workers' Party (SDAP) itself was convinced of the superiority of the German language and culture and its (supposedly) civilizing mission, which was meant to guarantee the cultural progress of all humankind. Additionally, the ideas of Greater German nationalism, significantly shaped the Party. Vienna was considered a great, ancient cultural city, and the lower classes had to be given the opportunity to participate in the national culture, which was considered the point of reference for everything. The leadership opposed "entertainment culture," "cheap" and “excessive pleasures”. Historically developed subcultures of the working class and forms of popular culture were combated or despised, and the experiences of the workers were disregarded. The gap between workers and intellectuals, or between physical and intellectual labor, was broadened instead of reducing the gap. Learning was to occur not through action, but through education and reading. In reality, however, an uncritical adoption of everything that seemed to benefit the party has prevailed, which led many within it, to protest against this "commercialization". The increasing strategic impasse of the party's strategy led to the “aestheticization” of politics and an ever-stronger appeal to emotions, rather than reason. Large-scale events and demonstrations were intended to facilitate the recruitment of new members and their rapid integration into the movement. The goal was to persuade them with simple words and images, without having to address the individual needs of each person specifically. Culture, much like sports, became not only a substitute for the failure to seize power, but also for the lack of militancy on the part of the unions, which failed to take action against low wages. It thus became a means of control, but also a channel for the energy and frustration of the followers. In this way, the masses were not only demonized, but also mythologized, heroized, idolized, and mystified. The mass of loyal followers was contrasted with the disorderly, unorganized masses. A disciplined, mobilized army, designed to inspire the movement's members, impress potential supporters and intimidate opponents: the masses became thus a vast backdrop for their leaders, a movement to demonstrate its ability to mobilize and control large masses. May Day, in particular, served as an annual event that sent large, organized, and disciplined crowds into the streets. Sport also offered such an opportunity, although the Social Democratic Party leadership's attitude to it was controversial.The Great Depression of 1929 hit Austria especially hard, and government policies, particularly cuts in social spending, exacerbated the situation. Thus Democracy and the State faced a legitimacy crisis, for which the SDAP had no answer. While the elites seemed prepared to do anything to replace the democratic system with an authoritarian one, the Social Democrats appeared indecisive and fearful. Faced with the dual pressure on the one hand from the unemployed demanding immediate relief measures and on the other, from the increasingly radicalized working-class youth: powerlessness prevailed. Thus, in February 1934, the operation to finally abolish democracy, has encountered little resistance. The SDAP cultivated an excessive trust in the state, seeing it as the representative of societal interests as a whole and as a mediator between the classes and their particular interests. Her control over it could, in the long run, guarantee the construction of socialism without experiments or tensions. Red Vienna was intended to set an example and serve as a stepping stone to conquering political power at the national level. However, the experiment faced a number of intractable contradictions from the very beginning. A large portion of the funding for its projects and social programs depended on the federal government, which also controlled very crucial institutions, such as the courts and the security forces. Without the possibility of genuine intervention in the economy and state structures, these efforts were limited. The Social Democrats' hopes could not be fulfilled. One reason for their failure was the overestimation of their own influence on the state, while they underestimated the impact of their entanglement with state mechanisms and the resulting influence, of the bourgeois strategy over their own party. As part of the state, municipalities are called upon to perform essentially the same functions as the central government. The SDAP was therefore unable to create a genuine alternative. Furthermore, the working class did not participate in government, however much this was emphasized. On the contrary, it was an attempt to redistribute the social surplus within capitalism and to enable greater access to urban space for the lower classes, without direct confrontation with the bourgeoisie. There was no connection between the daily struggle for reforms within capitalism and the proclaimed socialist ultimate goal. Since the representation of the working class was taken for granted, much of their own policy aimed at winning the support of the middle class. Although a remarkable infrastructure was created, the capitalistic logic of spatial production was not broken; on the contrary, there were strong ties to the legacy of the imperial era. There was no willingness to experiment, or adopting alternative forms of housing, nor the democratic control of urban space, or of the administration, which was not always in favor of the working class. The primacy of intellectual over manual labor was accepted and reproduced. Convinced of the linear development of society, the Social Democrats failed to recognize the social contradictions they were faced with. The party was placed above the movement and thus above the class and party activity replaced that of the class. Class struggle was thereby reduced to the necessary historical means for achieving full democracy. This led to a highly problematic equation of class, party, and local government and ultimately to the self-limitation of the movement.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Kantzias-Ronte, Alexanter-Kristian
  • Κάντζιας-Ρόντε, Αλεξάντερ-Κρίστιαν

Subjects

dc:subject × 18

Rights

Language dc:language
ger

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/60727

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Kantzias-Ronte, Alexanter-Kristian; Κάντζιας-Ρόντε, Αλεξάντερ-Κρίστιαν. Der Raum der Stadt als umkämpftes Konfrontationsfeld: Fallbeispiel Rotes Wien. National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/60727