Back to search

Agricultural University of Athens

Socioeconomic evaluation of weed management practices

Abstract

dc:description

Chemical herbicide application constitutes the predominant weed management strategy in conventional cropping systems. However, the emergence of herbicide-resistant weeds, combined with increasing environmental awareness worldwide and the demand for sustainable food systems, has stimulated research and policy initiatives toward “Sustainable Weed Management Practices” (SWMPs) in agriculture. These encompass non-chemical alternatives grounded in sustainable, integrated and ecological principles, aiming to ensure effective weed control without compromising the social, economic and environmental sustainability of agro-ecosystems. Their prospective advantages include diminished harm to natural resources, improved integrity of plant and animal populations in non-agricultural areas and maintenance of weed susceptibility to control methods. Despite significant attention from the research and policymaking communities, evidence indicates that over a decade after the European Union’s (EU) initial policy objective toward pesticide reduction, the practical implementation of SWMPs remains limited in most European countries, including Greece, due to farmers’ reluctance to switch to non-chemical alternatives. These low adoption rates underscore not only technical or practical constraints hindering SWMPs from being the primary weed control option but also socioeconomic factors affecting farmers’ decision-making process. Beyond their potential agronomic and environmental benefits, the sustainability of SWMPs, as of all innovative or non-conventional approaches, heavily depends on their socioeconomic performance, which involves both long-term economic viability and social acceptability. Lacking empirical, clear knowledge on the economic effects of SWMPs as well as on farmers’ ability and willingness to implement them, renders their resilience over time highly uncertain. This PhD Thesis examines the socioeconomic performance of SWMPs, which has not been properly evaluated in the scientific literature, with the objective to provide insights into their economic viability, social sustainability and practical implementation as well as to inform strategies for their broader adoption in Greek and European agriculture. For this purpose, a holistic socioeconomic approach is introduced, comprising the assessment of the economic impact of SWMPs at both the farm and farming system levels and the investigation of their acceptability among farmers. In particular, this approach builds upon three different dimensions: i) Farming system-level economic analysis, employing a Mathematical Programming model to determine the economic performance of farm types with different SWMPs at the local/regional level under the contrasting effects of a market-based and a policy-oriented scenario; ii) Farm-level economic analysis, involving the development of a farm typology according to the implemented SWMPs by combining Principal Component Analysis (PCA) with Two-Step Cluster Analysis (TSCA) as well as a comparative technical and economic analysis based on the derived typology in order to identify the impact of SWMPs on farm organization, management and economic performance; iii) Analysis of adoption patterns, involving an extended Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) as the theoretical framework and Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to explore the extent to which farmers are willing and able to adopt SWMPs. The PhD Thesis draws on two particular case studies: i) Farms cultivating legumes for livestock feed (referred to in this PhD Thesis as “legumes for livestock—LL” and include species such as vetch, pea, bean, lupin and clover) alongside key annual arable crops (e.g., cereals, cotton) in the Region of Thessaly in Central Greece; ii) Farms cultivating industrial tomato and other important annual arable crops (e.g., cereals, cotton) in the Region of Thessaly in Central Greece under the threat of broomrape parasitism. The PhD Thesis focuses specifically on a carefully designed set of thirteen SWMPs, derived from literature review and empirical insights from actual practices implemented in the study area. These encompass: cover crops; crop rotation; false seeding; deep plowing; fallowing; adjustments on sowing dates; reduced tillage or no tillage; adjustments on sowing densities; competitive hybrids and cultivars; selection of competitive crops; precision weed management; mechanical weeding; and manual interventions. The results of the farming system-level economic analysis reveal that small-sized farms, which are actually more specialized in LL cultivation and more oriented to SWMPs, are the most benefited in economic terms under additional policy support (policy-oriented scenario) or under increase in market revenues (market-based scenario). However, they play a minor role in the expansion of the LL area at the local/regional level. Large-sized farms, on the contrary, which rely more on chemical pesticides, are pivotal in this growth, although they would require substantial policy incentives to achieve this goal. Policy measures increase uncertainties for farms, which relates to their dependence on developments within the CAP framework, whereas the establishment of favorable market conditions for LL products requires more complex interventions but can generate more consistent results. Among these interventions, effective advisory support for farmers, collaboration between all agricultural stakeholders as well as research and technological advancements can be proven crucial. The PhD Thesis also indicates that a typification of farms according to the implementation of various SWMPs under real-life conditions at the farm level, reflecting variations in organizational requirements and daily operation, can provide valuable insights toward the adoption of specific “bundles” of SWMPs and facilitate effective managerial decisions. In particular, farms employing a holistic approach, characterized by a strategic combination of preventive and curative SWMPs, achieve superior financial outcomes. This finding demonstrates that their overall operational environment encourages better resource utilization, particularly, labor, leading to higher profitability. The promotion of business models in which SWMPs are successfully implemented requires specialized advisory services to introduce farmers to the learning steps of SWMPs, generational renewal measures to bolster the presence of young people and ensure labor availability in rural regions, as well as targeted income support payments to mitigate transition-related risks combined with incentives for market integration. The analysis of opinions, attitudes and preferences of farmers suggests that their decision-making process regarding the adoption of SWMPs is affected by their personal characteristics, the characteristics of their farms and the characteristics of SWMPs. Particularly, farmers’ perceptions and understanding of the benefits of SWMPs but also the practicality and applicability of these practices at the farm level are crucial elements that can promote their adoption. It is also pinpointed that farmers’ openness to adopting innovations can also contribute to the uptake of SWMPs, which is also possible when specific external conditions are favorable and accessible. Therefore, strategies to promote adoption should be primarily based on demonstrating the actual tangible benefits of SWMPs, strengthening farmers’ skills to enhance their confidence in implementing such practices as well as improving the broader external environment while also accounting for farmers’ personal attributes.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Agricultural University of Athens
Year dc:date
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Michalis, Efstratios
  • Μιχάλης, Ευστράτιος

Subjects

dc:subject × 26

Rights

Language dc:language
eng

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/60765

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Michalis, Efstratios; Μιχάλης, Ευστράτιος. Socioeconomic evaluation of weed management practices. Agricultural University of Athens, 2025. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/60765