Democritus University of Thrace (DUTH)
Exploring the relationship between risk and return in the management of insurance companies within the framework of the solvency II directive: risk appetite, risk tolerance, and the risk limits set as targets by insurance companies through the Own Risk and Solvency Assessment (ORSA)
Abstract
dc:descriptionSolvency II, which was implemented on January 1, 2016, within the European Economic Area, represents a pivotal advancement in the insurance sector over the past two decades, eliciting both substantial expectations and concerns. The risk-based approach is the most significant innovation of this regulatory framework, addressing critical issues related to capital requirements, their supervision, and market disclosure. For insured individuals and beneficiaries, Solvency II prioritizes the protection of their interests. For insurance entities, it offers an opportunity to perceive the new capital requirements as a strategic advantage rather than a constraint. This dissertation addresses three aspects of an insurer's solvency, especially under the prism of the Solvency II framework. Specifically, it assesses the impact of Solvency II implementation, alongside other factors, on the profitability and financial robustness of insurers; it studies the effect of the implementation of regulatory measures and examines the determinants (that allow the forecasting) of the Solvency Capital Requirement Ratio (SCR); and ultimately, it identifies the effect of investment related factors on an insurer's solvency (ratio). More specifically, the first problem tackled unveils the influence of both internal and external factors on the profitability and financial strength of EU insurance groups, with a particular emphasis on the European sovereign debt crisis and the Solvency II Directive—areas that have not been extensively explored in existing literature. The findings suggest that effective accounts receivable, management, and favorable economic conditions enhance profitability and financial strength, whereas underwriting risk, and size exert a negative impact. Long-term interest rates are found to positively affect profitability, while reinsurance purchase, domestic market size, market structure, and inflation negatively influence it. The European sovereign debt crisis is shown to adversely affect profitability and has a negligible positive effect on financial strength. Solvency II is found to have no significant impact on either metric. The second question addressed in this dissertation pertains to the manner in which financial institutions implemented regulatory measures in response to early twenty-first-century crises. These measures aimed to enhance transparency, protect consumers and investors, restructure financial capital, stabilize insurance and pension markets, and improve solvency. The Solvency II framework in the European Union applied these principles to insurance companies. It involves forecasting the solvency of insurers within a cohort of European insurance companies, identifying the key variables influencing the Solvency Capital Requirement (SCR) ratio of European insurers, and establishing benchmarks for monitoring and forecasting SCR ratios, which are essential for the sustainability of European insurance companies. Furthermore, the study demonstrates the efficacy of machine learning techniques, particularly regularized linear regression, specifically Lasso, in the analysis of insurer solvency. Lasso identified the reinvestment rate, cash and equivalents, long-term investment, and losses-benefits-and-adjustments expenses as key predictors of insurer solvency, thereby aiding insurers in maintaining robust solvency capital requirement ratios and ensuring operational continuity with minimal disruption.The third solvency-related issue examined in this study is the impact of investment portfolio structure on insurers' solvency. Linear regression and supervised machine learning models, specifically extra trees regression, were utilized to predict solvency ratios, with extra trees regression exhibiting superior performance. The investigation was further supported by panel data analysis. Key factors influencing solvency ratios included unit-linked and index-linked liabilities, firm size, investments in property, collective undertakings, bonds and equities, the ratio of government to corporate bonds, life and non-life market concentration, domestic bond market development, private debt development, household spending, banking concentration, non-performing loans, and CO2 emissions. The analysis uniquely investigates the relationship between solvency ratios and previously unexplored variables such as portfolio asset allocation, insurance market concentration, and unit-linked and index-linked products, employing both traditional and machine-enhanced methods. It also identifies associations with bond market development and investments in collective undertakings, underscoring the significant solvency risks posed by high banking sector concentration under Solvency II.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Democritus University of Thrace (DUTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Siopi, Evangelia
- Σιώπη, Ευαγγελία
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Ασφαλιστικοί όμιλοι
- Ευρωπαϊκή κρίση δημόσιου χρέους
- Χρηματοοικονομική ισχύς
- Κερδοφορία
- Φερεγγυότητα II (Solvency II)· Απαίτηση Κεφαλαίου Φερεγγυότητας (Solvency Capital Requirement – SCR)
- Μηχανική μάθηση· παλινδρόμηση Lasso· παλινδρόμηση Random Forest· παλινδρόμηση Extra Trees
- Insurance groups; profitability; financial strength
- European sovereign debt crisis
- Solvency II; Solvency Capital Requirement; asset allocation
- Machine learning; Lasso regression; Random forest regression; Extra trees regression.
- Οικονομικά και Επιχειρήσεις
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Χρηματοοικονομικά
- Οικονομετρία
- Economics and Business
- Social Sciences
- Finance
- Econometrics
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/60798