Back to search

University of the Aegean

Πολυδιάστατη ανάλυση των επιπτώσεων της οικονομικής κρίσης στον ψηφιακό μετασχηματισμό της Κεντρικής Δημόσιας Διοίκησης

Abstract

dc:description

Economic crises, defined as severe contractions of economic activity, have appeared with increasing frequency and duration in modern economies since 2000. As a result, “economically normal periods” are becoming progressively shorter, while periods of economic crisis are becoming longer. Economic crises have always constituted a major problem, although in the past they occurred less frequently and lasted for shorter periods, and they are regarded as a significant inherent problem of the market economy model. The economic literature records numerous economic crises that took place during the previous century, triggered by various types of events such as banking crises, hostilities between countries or groups, epidemics (and health crises in general), droughts, sharp increases in the prices of essential goods (e.g., oil, natural gas, food, etc.), and so on, which led to “recessions,” that is, severe contractions of economic activity. However, since the beginning of the current century, the frequency and duration of economic crises have increased for several reasons: the escalating internationalization of the economy and the interconnection of national economies, the expansion of debt at the level of states, firms, and households, the over-expansion of the financial sector (financial capitalism), the worsening of social inequalities, etc. During the current century, several major economic crises have occurred, with particularly negative consequences for the economies and societies of a large number of countries. In 2007, the severe Global Financial Crisis took place, while more recently we experienced another painful economic crisis triggered by the COVID-19 pandemic. According to the recent OECD report Society at a Glance 2024 – OECD Social Indicators, the rapid succession of global crises, such as those caused by COVID-19 and the Russian war against Ukraine, has led to increases in unemployment, poverty, and other social problems and, more generally, to a growing sense of uncertainty in societies. These challenges must be addressed through appropriate public social welfare policies and services. Economic crises cause significant negative impacts on organizations in both the private and the public sectors, and through them on society as a whole. However, in some cases they may also have certain positive effects, as they put pressure on organizations to rationalize their processes, make better use of their resources (human, technological, financial, etc.), and improve their efficiency. Most research conducted on the activities, functions, and various other aspects of private and public organizations mainly concerns “economically normal periods,” while much less research – and especially empirical research – has focused on periods of economic crisis, despite their increasing frequency, duration, and particularly negative consequences. Moreover, the limited empirical research that does exist mainly examines the effects of the 2008 global economic crisis on various financial aspects of private-sector firms, such as their investments and financing, across different countries. In contrast, very limited empirical research has been carried out on the effects of economic crises on critical activities related to the use of digital technologies and the digital transformation of organizations, although these activities are widely recognized as highly important for modern organizations. Furthermore, this limited empirical research concerns the private sector, while corresponding research on the public sector is lacking, despite its widely acknowledged and crucial role in economic activity, social welfare, and social cohesion, particularly during periods of economic crisis. This Doctoral Dissertation aims to contribute to filling this important research gap for both the economy and society. Specifically, the research objectives (ROs) of the Dissertation are the following: RO1: The development of an appropriate research model for the comprehensive and multi-dimensional investigation of the effects of a recessionary economic crisis on the digital transformation of public organizations, as well as on its key determinants. This model enables the identification, evaluation, and understanding of the full range of both negative and positive effects, based on strong theoretical foundations. RO2: The use of this research model to investigate the multi-dimensional effects of the economic crisis that occurred in our country during the period 2010–2018 on the digital transformation of public organizations of the Greek Central Government. To achieve the above research objectives, an appropriate research model was first developed, based on a combination of theoretical foundations from the fields of economics, management sciences, and information systems, specifically drawing upon:-the economic theory of the effects of economic crises,-the business turnaround theory,-the resource-based view (RBV),-the ICT strategy adaptation framework under crisis conditions, and-the conceptualization of digital transformation in public organizations developed by Mergel et al. (2019).This research model allows the calculation of a multi-dimensional pattern of the effects of an economic crisis on the digital transformation of a public organization. This pattern includes six dimensions of effects, structured into four levels. The first five dimensions concern the effects of the crisis on important determinants of digital transformation (i.e., ICT investments and operational expenditures, ICT processes/practices/capabilities, and ICT strategy). The sixth dimension concerns the effects of the economic crisis on the outcomes of digital transformation activities, namely the development of “transformational information systems,” which bring about significant transformations in critical elements of public organizations, such as internal processes, transaction channels with citizens and businesses, consultation channels, etc. More specifically, the six dimensions of crisis effects on digital transformation included in our research model are: Level 1: Retrenchment effectsI. Reduction in ICT investmentsII. Reduction in ICT operational expenditures Level 2: Rationalization effectsIII. Rationalization of ICT resourcesIV. Rationalization of ICT processes/practices/capabilities Level 3: Strategic effectsV. Adjustments to ICT strategic plans Level 4: Digital transformation effectsVI. Effects on six basic forms of digital transformation defined by the conceptualization of Mergel et al. (2019)This research model enables the investigation and understanding of the full spectrum of the effects of a recessionary economic crisis on the digital transformation of public organizations, going beyond the typically studied restrictive/reductive effects and allowing the identification and understanding of possible positive effects, in addition to negative ones. It is worth noting that our research model has broader applicability and can be used for the multi-dimensional analysis of the effects of a recessionary economic crisis on the digital transformation of various categories of organizations, both public (at different administrative levels, e.g., central, regional, and local government) and private. Subsequently, based on this research model, the multi-dimensional effects of the 2010–2018 economic crisis in our country on the digital transformation of public organizations of the Greek Central Government were investigated. Data collection was carried out using a combination of quantitative and qualitative techniques (questionnaires and focus groups). Our analysis yielded a number of particularly interesting findings (some of which were counter-intuitive) regarding the effects of the 2010–2018 economic crisis on the digital transformation of the Ministries of the Greek Central Government and on its determinants. Specifically, the crisis led to a generally small reduction in ICT technological investments (with some Ministries experiencing larger reductions, while others maintained stability or even increases through the use of EU funds). There was also a smaller reduction in “human” ICT investments (for training of ICT staff and users).Regarding ICT operational expenditures, the crisis resulted in a greater reduction in “internal” ICT operational costs (for recruitment and salaries of ICT staff), while “external” ICT operational expenditures (for consulting services and outsourcing) remained stable, with increased spending on cloud services.In response to the above reductions in available financial ICT resources, the examined public organizations undertook small to moderate rationalizations in ICT resources, ICT work processes/practices, as well as ICT strategic plans, and also improvements in the utilization of existing ICT equipment and ICT-specialized human resources. Concerning the effects of the 2010–2018 economic crisis on the digital transformation of the examined Ministries (i.e., the development of transformational information systems), a very interesting and counter-intuitive finding emerged. In none of the examined Ministries was there a negative impact of the crisis on digital transformation. Instead, two sub-groups (clusters) of Ministries can be distinguished: in the first sub-group (five Ministries), there was a small positive effect, while in the second sub-group (the other five Ministries), there was a large positive effect of the crisis on their digital transformation. The second sub-group includes Ministries with key responsibilities related to economic development and the welfare state, where it was necessary to strengthen digital support and digital transformation; therefore, they implemented some highly significant and strongly transformational information systems. So, during the economic crisis, some of the most pivotal information systems ever developed in the country’s public administration emerged, such as the electronic prescription system, the national electronic public procurement system (Prometheus), the central electronic system supporting the administrative operations of primary and secondary schools (MySchool), the system for the provision of digital educational content, among others. Compared to the first sub-group, the Ministries in the second sub-group carried out a greater degree of ICT resource and process/practice rationalization, as well as more adjustments to ICT strategic plans, and experienced slightly smaller reductions in ICT investments and expenditures. The above reveal that highly adverse economic events, such as recessionary crises, do not necessarily act as inhibiting factors for the digital transformation of public organizations; on the contrary, they may function as positive catalysts in this direction, despite the reduction of the available financial resources. This is due to the strong pressures such crises generate for drastic improvements in efficiency and effectiveness in critical state functions, which require (among other things) the development of highly complex and strongly transformational information systems. In order to achieve these ambitious technological objectives, given the reductions in available resources, the competent public organizations proceed with the rationalization of ICT-related processes and work practices, ICT resources, and ICT strategic plans, as well as with the more effective utilization of existing ICT equipment and ICT-specialized human resources.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of the Aegean
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Kavallari, Cryso
  • Καβαλλάρη, Χρύσω

Subjects

dc:subject × 20

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/61010

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Kavallari, Cryso; Καβαλλάρη, Χρύσω. Πολυδιάστατη ανάλυση των επιπτώσεων της οικονομικής κρίσης στον ψηφιακό μετασχηματισμό της Κεντρικής Δημόσιας Διοίκησης. University of the Aegean, 2026. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/61010