University of Thessaly (UTH)
Διαχείριση νερού και θρεπτικών στοιχείων σε ενυδρειοπονικό σύστημα: πειραματική μελέτη και προσομοίωση
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe research on food production systems focuses on increasing the unit of food production per square meter of land without increasing the environmental impact. This is achieved by: 1) transitioning from intensive monocultures to polyculture systems offering greater biodiversity 2) saving water, 3) saving energy, and 4) saving nutrients. One system that combines all of the above characteristics is aquaponics. Aquaponics is a technology that combines the breeding of aquatic organisms in tanks with hydroponics - including microbiological processes - utilizing the solution from the aquatic organisms for plant fertilization. Aquaponics has been documented since ancient times and has undergone remarkable development over time. In the last decade, research and application trends have focused decoupled systems with a plant-centric approach. However, there are gaps in research that this paper aims to fill. The innovations presented are: 1) The comparison of nutritional profiles, plant yields, and indicators of water-fertilizer-nutrients use efficiency between coupled, decoupled aquaponics, and hydroponics as pilot-scale drip irrigation systems under the same environmental conditions. 2) The development of a simulation model (mg L-1) for six compounds-elements (nitrates, ammonia, phosphorus, potassium, calcium, and sodium) after training and evaluation separately in the RAS solution (water-soluble nutrient coefficients from Tilapia metabolism) and in the drainage solution (nutrient absorption coefficients) in a pilot-scale coupled aquaponic system. 3) The development of scenarios for improved pilot scale decoupled aquaponic systems breeding Tilapia and cultivating Tomato focusing on keeping nitrate concentration in compatible range for both organisms and determining the maximum savings of nitrate fertilizers. A four-period experiment was carried out in the aquaponic system established within the climate-controlled greenhouse of the Laboratory of Agricultural Constructions and Environmental Control of the University of Thessaly facilities in Velestino. The greenhouse has a total ground area of 420 m2, which is divided into a 360 m2 hydroponic system and an 80 m2 recirculating aquaculture system (RAS) settled in a closed panel chamber. This is the first modern pilot decoupled aquaponic greenhouse built in Greece for research purposes in 2019. Climate control, irrigation, nutrient solution preparation, and water circulation management were all automated through control software and sensor systems. The total volume of RAS solution ranges from 6.6 to 7.1 m3, which is continuously recycled. The hydroponic subsystem is represented by drip irrigation with perlite substrate. During the 1st experimental period, basil seedlings (Ocimum basilicum cv. Genovese) were transplanted, in the 2nd cucumber plants (Cucumis sativus cv. Aisopos), in the 3rd parsley plants (Petroselinum crispum (Mill.)) and in the 4th tomato plants (Solanum lycopersicum cv. Kabrera). Plant cultivation was combined with Red tilapia (Oreochromis spp.) breeding in all experimental periods. Three treatments were applied concerning the nutrient solution irrigated to the hydroponic subsystem: (1) hydroponics (HP), (2) decoupled aquaponics (DCAP), and (3) coupled aquaponics (CAP). In HP, nutrient solution was represented by a standard hydroponic solution with standard nutrient concentrations. In DCAP, the nutrient solution consisted of RAS solution enriched with fertilizers up to standard hydroponic concentrations. In CAP, plants were irrigated with a pure RAS solution without the addition of fertilizers. In the 1st chapter of results, the nutrient profile and nutrient use efficiency of coupled and decoupled aquaponics was studied in comparison to hydroponics. According to the results, in the CAP treatment, only the leafy plants managed to absorb a sufficient amount of nutrients close to optimum levels, although the plants were irrigated with poor NS. On the other hand, the fruit-bearing vegetables performed poorly in terms of nutrient assimilation, with the possibility of negatively affecting the yield. All the crops in the CAP system, however, had the least impact on the environment among the systems with the highest NUE values. In the DCAP system, both leafy and fruit-bearing vegetables absorbed sufficient amounts of nutrients close to optimum levels. The special composition of the RAS solution highlighted DCAP treatment with ideal nutrient assimilation and greater nutrient use efficiency than HP. Meanwhile, the environmental impact of the DCAP system was lower than in conventional hydroponics. In the 2nd chapter of results, water and fertilizer use efficiency, yields and plant growth parameters between treatments were studied. The DCAP system was demonstrated as the most productive among CAP and HP systems. The CAP treatment resulted in the lowest yield and growth performance because of the nutrient deficiencies and non-optimal nutrient ratios in combination with non-optimal water quality parameters. On the other hand, CAP treatment had higher plant WUE and zero fertilizer consumption compared to the other treatments, followed by DCAP, indicating that aquaponics is more environmentally friendly system than hydroponics. Nevertheless, DCAP treatment was more productive and environmentally friendly compared to HP. The 3rd chapter of results, focuses on developing a model for nutrient management in decoupled aquaponic systems, integrating RAS and HP components. The model aims to predict the fluctuation of main ions in aquaponics, i.e., NO3-, NH3-, PO4-2, K+, Ca2+, and Na+, in both sub-systems RAS and hydroponic drainage solutions. The research involved calibration and validation through various crop cultivation cycles within the same aquaponics set-up with tilapia in RAS and hydroponics with basil, cucumber, parsley, and tomato. The model successfully predicts nutrient levels in an independent crop production cycle on tomato. However, the study also highlights challenges, such as the influence of factors like alkalinity, FA, pH values, biofilter efficiency and other microbial processes. The sensitivity analysis emphasizes the total volume loss as the most significant parameter driving the downward trend in nutrient concentration. Overall, the results emphasize the potential of this model to be applied as a tool for better design, managing, and efficiency of aquaponic systems. The findings reveal further factors and complexities of the RAS system that can be incorporated into the model for an upgraded version. In the 4th chapter of results, two case studies about decoupled aquaponic systems cultivating tomato and breeding tilapia are presented. The 1st case study (Σ1) concerns the addition of basil plants for the first 40 experimental days, to balance the low water requirements of tomatoes. The 2nd case study, involves the addition of tilapia fish, from the 40th day after transplanting (DAT40) until the end of the cultivation period, for balancing the high water requirements of tomatoes. The two case studies were managed to maintain the nitrate concentration stable at 500 mg L-1 to avoid nitrate toxicity in tilapia and achieve maximum nitrate fertilizer savings for the hydroponic subsystem. Maximum fertilizer savings compared to HP were calculated for potassium nitrate (100%), followed by magnesium nitrate (20-21%) and monopotassium phosphate (18-19%). However, the phosphorus and potassium concentrations demonstrated very low availability (18% and 5%, respectively), leading to disproportions of nutrient ratio in the RAS solution. Τhe Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) results, highlighted Σ1 as the best case study because of the reduction rates in all the environmental impact categories (EIC) compared to YΔ1 per kg of tomato yield. There was no reduction rates in the EIC compared to YΔ1 per kg of tilapia yield except for the EIC2. Consequently, the HP subsystem seems to be more environmentally friendly than the RAS and the expectation for the evolution of aquaponics as a plant-centric system is confirmed. The Σ2 case study system was stocked with greater tilapia biomass than Σ1, so there was a reduction only in EIC2 per kg of tilapia yield and none reduction in EIC per kg of tomato yield. Nevertheless, the contribution of the systems Σ1 and Σ2 to the EIP is greater than YΔ1 and YΔ2 for energy and fish feed and these are the factors that have to be improved in the future for better efficiency. According to the developed simulation model, the improvement of the aquaponic system focuses on balancing nutrient inputs and outputs by adding plants or fish according to the system's needs. Additional techniques for improving phosphorus and potassium nutrients in the RAS are considered imperative for future research, as the increase of energy efficiency in order to improve the environmental impact of aquaponics compared to hydroponics. In conclusion, based on the literature and the contribution of this study, the application of pilot-scale aquaponics is recommended to be decoupled with a plant-centric approach for better yields and less environmental impact compared to hydroponics . The application of the simulation model is also crucial for the appropriate rescaling of nutrient inputs and outputs and the maximum possible fertilizer savings compared to hydroponics.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Aslanidou, Maria
- Ασλανίδου, Μαρία
Subjects
dc:subject × 12Rights
- Language dc:language
- gre
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/61127