Back to search

University of Thessaly (UTH)

Η μέθοδος της Μεικτής Μάθησης στη διδασκαλία της λογοτεχνίας στη Δευτεροβάθμια Εκπαίδευση

Abstract

dc:description

The present dissertation addresses a three-cycle action research study (2017-2020), which utilizes the teaching of Literature (National Curriculum, 2011) in Secondary Education (SE)—a demanding subject area with an emphasis on emotion, values, and the identity formation of adolescent students—as a challenging testing ground for the adaptation and enrichment of the blended Community of Inquiry (CoI) model (Garrison et al., 2001). The CoI model, grounded in the principles of social constructivism, describes the learning experience as a dynamic interaction of three Presences: Teaching, Social, and Cognitive. The aim of the research was to refine the CoI model itself, so that it can effectively support the design and implementation of a blended learning environment wherein high-quality learning outcomes, engagement, elaborated dialogue, interaction, and student autonomy/agency are achieved. The research was conducted in 1st Grade classes of a General Lyceum (10th Grade) in a semi-urban school in central Greece, with the researcher acting in the dual role of teacher-researcher (TR), employing a mixed-methods approach (quantitative/qualitative) and multiple data collection tools (written tests, observations, transcribed face-to-face/recorded distance dialogues, interviews, researcher’s diary, among others). The research trajectory constituted an evolutionary learning process for both the students and the TR. In the first cycle, the initial implementation of the model revealed a two-fold problem: on the students' side, poor engagement, superficial learning outcomes, limited interaction, and restricted autonomy/agency were observed; on the TR’s side, a directive, managerial teaching stance was identified. In the second cycle, despite targeted improvements, pedagogical insights, and the strong care demonstrated by the TR towards the students, certain challenges remained unresolved, such as limited interaction, student autonomy/agency, and difficulties in the practical application of the intervention. The analysis led to the conclusion that the difficulties did not merely concern the implementation but the theory itself: a comprehensive framework for coupling Blended Learning (BL) with the specific pedagogical needs of Secondary Education was missing. This knowledge had to be developed. The central theoretical contribution of the dissertation is the proposal for the conceptual extension of the CoI model through the addition of a new, fourth Presence: the Presence of Development. This Presence captures the reciprocal, dialectical relationship that develops over time between two central processes: the transformation of the teacher’s pedagogical practice and the emergence of student agency. This is not a simple cause-and-effect relationship, but a co-evolution: as the teacher learns to recognize and utilize student initiatives, students are empowered, assuming more complex roles that push the teacher towards further reflection and change. To become operational, the Presence of Development is founded on four psychologically and pedagogically grounded dimensions, which render it conceptually distinct from the existing Presences: (1) recognition of others, which transcends simple open communication (Social Presence) and focuses on the deeper psychological act of validating the other as an autonomous subject, creating the necessary condition of safety for the emergence of the authentic self; (2) the learning communication ecosystem, which differs from design and organization (Teaching Presence) as it concerns not only the teacher's plan but the very architecture of the lived, co-configured environment with its distinct places and the flexible roles it permits; (3) reciprocal transformation within a dynamic of cohesion-dissolution, a dimension that, unlike “group cohesion” (Social Presence), recognizes that development is not a linear path towards harmony, but a dynamic process fueled by tensions, conflicts, and syntheses; and (4) narrative identity, which differs from Cognitive Presence as it does not focus on solving a specific problem, but on the broader mechanism of constructing personal meaning, where both students and the teacher integrate learning experiences into a coherent narrative about themselves. The Presence of Development does not function in parallel with the other three; rather, it permeates and enriches them, while being simultaneously influenced by them in a relationship of mutual influence. It transforms Teaching Presence, pushing the teacher from “manager” to “orchestrator” who manages the dynamic relationship between guidance and autonomy, listening to the developmental needs of the community. At the same time, it deepens Social Presence, transforming the classroom from a space of functional cohesion into a field of a developmental community. This developmental community is built through the quality of the pedagogical relationship, the development of dialogic identity, and the conscious shaping of a climate of safety—a process interpreted by the principle of reciprocity in self-disclosure. Finally, it enhances Cognitive Presence, recognizing that in Secondary Education, the bridge to substantial cognitive engagement is the creation of personal meaning, which presupposes a conscious pedagogical process where students connect learning with their lives and the teacher recognizes and utilizes this meaning they bring to the classroom. The practical implementation of the Presence of Development was achieved through the development of a learning communication ecosystem, a network of distinct yet interconnected learning “places”. Each place had a specialized role in the process of learning and development. The distance settings (such as private and group chats) functioned as the “backstage” spaces of the ecosystem: as safe “incubators” for vulnerable ideas, as “laboratories” for collaboration and feedback, and as fields for informal familiarization with complex concepts, where students could test ideas and take initiatives without the fear of exposure and criticism. Conversely, the face-to-face settings constituted the “center stage”, the space of embodied presence where dialogue became elaborated, the pedagogical relationship was grounded, and school knowledge was directly linked to personal lived experience. The essence of the learning ecosystem, however, lay not in each setting individually, but in the orchestrated flow of ideas between them. An initiative born hesitantly in a private chat matured in a group discussion and was finally presented with confidence in the plenary. This path from private to public and from informal to formal constituted the central mechanism that empowered agency and allowed for the substantial development of the participants. The professional development of the TR was a central finding of the research. The study demonstrated that her substantial evolution did not consist merely of improving isolated teaching techniques, but of a fundamental metamorphosis from “manager” to orchestrator” of the learning ecosystem. This transition was not just technical but deeply pedagogical: it was triggered by her need to reconnect with the essence of Literature, beyond exam-centric imperatives. The research highlighted that her effort to design an environment that fosters student autonomy proved to be the primary mechanism of her own developmental trajectory. Through a continuous cycle of action-reflection, fueled by dialogue with critical friends and theory, the TR learned to navigate the demanding process of relinquishing control. This relationship constitutes a mutual transformation (co-development), where student development fuels teacher evolution and vice versa. The application of the enriched model in the third cycle led to the research's most critical realization: the transformation of the TR's pedagogical practice did not “create” student agency from scratch. Instead, it allowed her to recognize and utilize the initiatives that students had always demonstrated. The change in her stance meant that she ceased to view student initiatives as “deviations” from the lesson and began to see them as valuable pedagogical opportunities. Consequently, she created the appropriate framework of safety and legitimation so that these pre-existing agentic actions could be manifested, reinforced, and utilized constructively within the learning process. Overall, within the framework of this dissertation, a modified CoI model is proposed that contributes to the field of Blended Learning by adapting the original framework to the holistic needs of Secondary Education. The addition of the Presence of Development serves to theorize the dialectical relationship between a flexible communication “ecosystem” of learning conditions and the developing capacity of the community—teacher and students—to co-configure the learning process. As a practical tool for transitioning towards this new paradigm, the dissertation additionally introduces the “Reflective Design Protocol”, a methodological guide to support the professional maturation of the teacher. This model shifts the emphasis from the teacher as the sole catalyst to her ability to recognize, validate, and leverage the agency that students already possess. In this way, learning becomes a process of mutual transformation, aligned with the vision for a pedagogy of liberation.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
University of Thessaly (UTH)
Year dc:date
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Authors dc:creator
  • Voivonta, Theodora
  • Βοϊβόντα, Θεοδώρα

Subjects

dc:subject × 24

Rights

Language dc:language
gre

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Identifier
10.12681/eadd/61197

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Greek National Archive of PhD Theses
Base URL
phdtheses.ekt.gr/eadd_oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Voivonta, Theodora; Βοϊβόντα, Θεοδώρα. Η μέθοδος της Μεικτής Μάθησης στη διδασκαλία της λογοτεχνίας στη Δευτεροβάθμια Εκπαίδευση. University of Thessaly (UTH), 2026. http://hdl.handle.net/10442/hedi/61197