National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Promoting education for sustainability in science education: the role of actor-network theory-informed projects in enhancing students' critical sustainability consciousness
Abstract
dc:descriptionScience Education has been shaped in relation to the evolution of technoscientific fields and their dynamic interconnections with social, economic, and environmental factors. This development has historically taken the form of an interaction between two poles: the first focuses exclusively on the teaching of scientific concepts and theories (Vision I), while the second seeks to connect Science Education with everyday life (Vision II). In the present historical moment—one in which the advancement of Science and Technology entails profound challenges for humanity—the dominant practice in the teaching of Science remains the adoption of the first pole’s perspective, thereby excluding meaningful engagement with sustainability issues. On the other hand, alternative pedagogical frameworks that adopt the perspective of the second pole often incorporate depoliticised approaches, which obscure the influence of power relations on the shaping of technoscience, and, more specifically, the influence of socio-economically powerful groups. By doing so, they contribute to the creation of beautified images of technological products, services and related careers, obscuring problematic elements they might entail. Nonetheless, there is a third pole encompassing critical/transformative frameworks in Science Education (Vision III). These frameworks have been historically influenced by Environmental Education and have the potential to promote the vision of Education for Sustainability. The aim of this doctoral thesis is to explore how sustainability can be promoted in secondary Science Education. To achieve this, the research focused on pedagogical approaches aligned with Vision III, and, more specifically, on those that employ Actor-Network Theory. Actor-Network Theory was developed in the 1980s to analyse the complex relationships among actors that constitute technoscientific products and services, by approaching them as networks of actors with tangible effects. The application of Actor–Network Theory in Science Education offers significant benefits, facilitating a deeper understanding of scientific concepts while contributing to the achievement of the goals of Education for Sustainability. It illuminates the relationships between biotic and abiotic elements, giving voice to all actors; it renders visible perspectives within technoscience that are typically managed exclusively by experts; and it frames technoscience as the outcome of multiple power relations rather than as neutral, uncontextualised entities. More specifically, within the context of the doctoral dissertation, the STEPWISE framework (Science and Technology Education Promoting Wellbeing for Individuals, Societies and Environments) was implemented. STEPWISE incorporates principles of Actor-Network Theory as part of conducting projects that focus on socioscientific issues. STEPWISE was adapted in the frame of sustainability through the modification of one of its core strategies: the construction of Actor-Network maps. In particular, the triple sustainability Venn diagram was utilised as the background for contructing these maps, because it highlights how actors function within the dimensions of sustainability. To assess the impact of the teaching approach, the concept of Sustainability Consciousness was employed, referring to an individual’s knowingness, attitudes, and behaviours in relation to sustainable development across its social, economic, and environmental dimensions. Given that Sustainability Consciousness has been measured in the relevant literature primarily through quantitative models, this study introduces the concept of Critical Sustainability Consciousness. This concept constitutes a qualitative perspective, aligned with the theoretical framework of critical theory and Actor–Network Theory, and enriched with the elements of critical thinking, systems thinking, and action competence. The main research question is: how does participation in Research-informed Action projects, drawing on Actor-Network Theory, contribute to the development of critical sustainability consciousness of lower secondary science students in the context of socioscientific issues? The research question was investigated using critical practitioner research with elements of action research. The research was conducted during the 2020-2021 school year in a secondary science class of a British school in Athens, consisting of 13–14-year-old students – eight boys and nine girls. During the research, qualitative data were collected, including interviews and Actor–Network maps. These data were analysed, respectively, through thematic analysis and through the use of newly developed criteria drawing from concept maps analysis. More specifically, an evaluation rubric was developed and is proposed as an analytical tool, tailored to the structure of Actor-Network maps. Overall, there is evidence to suggest that students’ critical sustainability consciousness was developed with reference to sustainable knowingness, attitudes and behaviours, as well as critical thinking, systems thinking, and action competence. Some aspects of this evolution include: holistic understanding of scientific concepts within the context of socioscientific issues; improved analysis of actors through the lens of sustainability dimensions; the recognition of socio-scientific issues as embedded within broader socio-economic inequalities; the expression of attitudes that go beyond a narrow anthropocentric perspective; empowerment; and encouragement of student-led awareness-raising actions. At the same time, the research highlights the persistence of individualistic thinking when students considered solutions to problematic situations. In addition, the study draws conclusions regarding the use of Actor-Network maps as a strategy capable of contributing to the promotion of critical sustainability consciousness. Through the use of the evaluation rubric, comparisons were made between the maps created by students over the course of the school year, revealing both strengths and areas for improvement of the teaching strategy. In particular, there is evidence suggesting improved use of Actor–Network maps, such as more holistic representations of socio-scientific issues, enrichment of map content through a more balanced reference to biotic and abiotic actors, and a more multidimensional representation of relationships among actors on the basis of the three circles of the Venn diagram. In addition, ways were identified in which the process of creating Actor–Network maps contributed to a better understanding of sustainability. At the same time, limitations of the strategy were identified, such as the difficulties students encountered in adequately describing alliances among actors. Finally, the research offers recommendations for supporting the implementation of classroom projects that integrate Actor-Network Theory. These consist of strategies for rendering key concepts—such as depunctualisation—more accessible, as well as providing scaffolding across the different phases of projects on socio-scientific issues.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Tsoumparis, Dimitrios
- Τσουμπάρης, Δημήτριος
Subjects
dc:subject × 18- Εκπαίδευση για την αειφορία
- Εκπαίδευση φυσικών επιστημών
- Θεωρία Δραστών-Δικτύου
- Κριτική αειφορική συνείδηση
- Κριτική έρευνα παρέμβασης
- Χάρτες Δραστών-Δικτύου
- Education for sustainability
- Science education
- Actor-network theory
- Critical sustainability consciousness
- Critical practitioner research
- Actor-Network maps
- Εκπαίδευση
- Κοινωνικές Επιστήμες
- Εκπαίδευση και Έρευνα της εκπαίδευσης
- Education
- Social Sciences
- Education and Educational Research
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/61321