National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Reconsidering epistemic structural realism: downward paths, impurities and metaphilosophical reflections
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn this dissertation, I articulate a novel form of epistemic structural realism (ESR), which I call Multiplicative ESR, and argue that it is the only version capable of sustaining the claim that ESR constitutes a distinctive and substantive modestly realist epistemological position that is genuinely responsive to revolutionary theory change. In broad terms, Multiplicative ESR counsels epistemic restraint concerning the prospects of veridically “visualizing” unobservable physical entities—that is, representing them by means of observational concepts rooted in our sensory experience of the macroscopic world. More generally, the position may be understood as expressing a cautionary attitude toward ontological claims of literal identity between apparently distinct entities in contexts of theoretical unification, maintaining that unity at the level of theory does not entail unity in nature. The development of Multiplicative ESR proceeds from the identification and systematic examination of an internal tension within standard (Ramseyan) ESR that has remained underexplored. This tension arises between the semantic motivations for ESR—specifically, the adoption of a descriptivist semantics for theoretical terms—and its historical motivations, grounded in the well-known Pessimistic Meta-Induction. I argue that Multiplicative ESR supplies the only coherent structuralist strategy for reconciling these semantic and historical considerations. Beyond issues internal to ESR, a substantial portion of the dissertation investigates the relationship between ESR and purportedly more robust forms of scientific realism, most notably deployment realism. I argue that the very logic of deployment realism—according to which realist commitment should be restricted to the minimal theoretical content required to derive successful novel empirical predictions—ultimately forces it to collapse into (Multiplicative) ESR, along what is often described as a “downward path.” Once the historical record of theory change and minimality considerations are taken seriously, no weaker restriction on realist commitment remains stable. For this reason, the thesis is relevant not only to discussions specific to ESR, but to scientific realism more broadly. In this respect, the dissertation exposes a fault line within the realism debate itself: either accept a significantly deflated conception of our epistemic access to the unobservable world—whether “anti-visualizing” or “anti-unifying”—or abandon the aspiration to reconcile any form of realism with the historical record of theory change through deployment realist criteria. While standard objections to ESR—such as challenges to the “observational–theoretical” distinction and Newman’s objection—are addressed, they do not constitute the central focus. Instead, extended attention is devoted to a meta-philosophical challenge that has gained significant traction in the contemporary philosophical landscape and bears not only on ESR but on “global” epistemological positions more generally: methodological localism. I argue against dissolving the traditional scientific realism debate in favor of a plurality of local approaches centered on particular theories or narrow disciplines. In its place, I propose a reconceptualization of the debate in terms of a pro tanto conception of epistemic reasons, which takes on board some localist insights while preserving the legitimacy and philosophical significance of broadly framed positions such as ESR.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Brousalis, Kosmas
- Μπρούσαλης, Κοσμάς
Subjects
dc:subject × 28- Επιστημονικός ρεαλισμός
- Δομικός ρεαλισμός
- Επιλεκτικός ρεαλισμός
- Δομισμός
- Θεωρητικοί όροι
- Θεωρητική αλλαγή
- Μεταφιλοσοφία
- Γνωσιολογία
- Σημασιολογία
- Ιστορία της επιστήμης
- Scientific realism
- Structural realism
- Selective realism
- Deployment realism
- Scientific structuralism
- Theoretical terms
- Theory change
- Metaphilosophy
- Epistemology
- Semantics
- Φιλοσοφία, Ηθική και Θρησκεία
- Ανθρωπιστικές Επιστήμες και Τέχνες
- Ιστορία και Φιλοσοφία της επιστήμης
- Φιλοσοφία
- Philosophy, Ethics and Religion
- Humanities and the Arts
- History and Philosophy of Science
- Philosophy
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/61515