University of Thessaly (UTH)
Measuring the impact of the European Joint Action “EU HEALTHY GATEWAYS: preparedness and action at points of entry” activities on International Health Regulations (IHR, 2005) points of entry core capacity requirements
Abstract
dc:descriptionIntroductionMeasuring the impact of multi-country European Joint Actions is challenging due to their extensive scope, implementation across diverse contexts, and the complexity of attributing observed outcomes to specific interventions. This doctoral thesis examines how the impact of a European Joint Action can be systematically assessed with regard to strengthening International Health Regulations (IHR, 2005) core capacity requirements at points of entry (PoE). The research focuses on the European Joint Action EU HEALTHY GATEWAYS: Preparedness and action at points of entry (2018–2022), co-funded by the European Union’s (EU) Third Health Programme. This Joint Action aimed to enhance public health preparedness and response capacities at PoE in Europe, and to strengthen coordination among public health authorities and transport sector stakeholders to address serious cross-border health threats. This thesis addresses a set of specific objectives: assessing the impact of Joint Action activities on improving IHR (2005) Annex 1B core capacities at PoE; evaluating the reach, relevance, and perceived effectiveness of activities during the COVID-19 pandemic; examining strengths as well as operational and strategic challenges observed during Joint Action implementation; and identifying gaps to generate evidence-informed recommendations. Methodology A multi-method strategy was used to align with the structure of the Joint Action’s development, implementation, and evaluation phases. Methods used to inform activity development included the identification of guidance needs, rapid and scoping literature reviews, expert consultations, and pilot-testing outputs at PoE level. During implementation, systematic monitoring of the dissemination, training, and uptake of Joint Action outputs was conducted. A multi-level evaluation strategy was applied: impact at project level was assessed through an internal summative evaluation and an external evaluation using a Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats (SWOT) analysis; evaluation at PoE level – specifically at Greek ports – included an in(tra)-action review (IAR) and an assessment of IHR (2005) PoE core capacity implementation levels before and after the Joint Action; national-level comparisons were conducted using the IHR States Parties Self-Assessment Annual Report (SPAR) PoE capacity scores of participating countries before and after the Joint Action; and at European level, impact was explored through a multi-country IAR in the cruise ship setting. Results From a public health perspective, surveillance, event detection, and information sharing were strengthened through digital collaboration tools – particularly the EU Common Ship Sanitation Database (EU CSSD), which facilitated reporting of 47 infectious disease events on passenger ships during the Joint Action – and through 17 guidance documents supporting event management during the COVID-19 pandemic. Capacity-building outcomes included use of harmonised European guidance in routine preparedness planning reported by 20 countries, strengthened port contingency planning, enhanced workforce competencies through three European- and 24 national-level training courses, and a multi-country exercise that improved cross-sector collaboration. At PoE level, progress in IHR (2005) core capacities was observed, with tangible improvements in emergency planning, communication, and operational readiness documented at Greek ports. The Joint Action also generated scientific impacts, with 18 peer-reviewed publications contributing new evidence on the effectiveness and limitations of public health measures in transport settings during the pandemic. Key innovations included novel port preparedness frameworks, development of the EU Digital Passenger Locator Form (EUdPLF), and application of the IAR methodology to revise European guidance. From a policy perspective, Joint Action outputs were referenced in ten EU policy documents during the pandemic. Integration of Joint Action guidance and digital tools was observed at national level, with the EUdPLF and EU CSSD applied by four and 19 countries, respectively. Embedding of outputs at European level was also evident, as the EUdPLF was transferred to European Commission ownership and steps were initiated toward EU-wide implementation of the EU CSSD. Sustainability of key Joint Action activities was further supported through the establishment of a dedicated public health observatory. Broader impacts were also identified: a Horizon Europe call mobilising EU funding in 2021 explicitly encouraged cooperation with Joint Action outputs, while harmonised guidance and technical support contributed to the safer and more consistent resumption of cruise operations in Europe during 2021–2022. Alongside these impacts, challenges influenced Joint Action implementation and outcomes. Uptake of Joint Action activities differed across participating countries. Implementation also differed by transport sector, with stronger integration observed in the maritime sector, possibly reflecting more established European operational networks and prior EU-funded initiatives in this area. The COVID-19 pandemic highlighted continuing challenges in public health preparedness and the implementation of measures within the transport sector. Early events in the maritime sector underscored limited surge capacity for large-scale measure implementation, as well as uncertainty regarding roles, responsibilities, and legal mandates for event management. Implementation of Joint Action recommendations was at times constrained by operational and logistical limitations. The Joint Action also noted shortcomings in epidemiological, behavioural, and impact evidence to support proportionate public health decision-making, alongside weaknesses in risk communication. Inconsistent application of travel-related measures across countries disrupted cross-border mobility and underscored the need for more coordinated, evidence-informed approaches to managing public health events at PoE. Recommendations Recommendations emerging from this thesis emphasise the need to strengthen preparedness planning and policy frameworks, evidence generation, and operational capacity at PoE and within the transport sector. Preparedness frameworks should adopt flexible, all-hazards contingency planning applicable to threats of different origins, with clear allocation of roles, responsibilities, and legal mandates at PoE and national levels. Planning should incorporate mechanisms to define, anticipate, and monitor surge capacity requirements, informed by epidemiological evidence, traffic and traveller volumes/patterns. Sustained preparedness would be supported by maintaining expertise, capacities, and activities across the Joint Action network to ensure continuity of guidance development, training, and exercises, with particular attention to less developed transport sectors. Systematic impact assessment of Joint Actions should be embedded from the proposal phase using standardised evaluation frameworks, indicators, and multi-method approaches. Priority should be given to systematic collection and analysis of epidemiological data related to public health events in the transport sector, including data enabling assessment of measure effectiveness at conveyance and PoE level. Standardised outbreak reporting, behavioural research on compliance and acceptability, and studies on social and economic impacts are essential. Operational preparedness should integrate business continuity planning to sustain essential transport and PoE functions during public health emergencies.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Thessaly (UTH)
- Year dc:date
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Anagnostopoulou, Lemonia
- Αναγνωστοπούλου, Λεμονιά
Subjects
dc:subject × 14- Πύλες εισόδου
- Μέσα μεταφοράς
- Ετοιμότητα δημόσιας υγείας
- Διεθνή Υγειονομικό Κανονισμό
- Points of entry
- Means of transport
- Public health preparedness
- International Health Regulations
- Άλλες Ιατρικές Επιστήμες
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Ιατρική, άλλοι τομείς
- Other Medical Sciences
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Medicine, miscellaneous
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/61533