University of Ioannina
Microbial food webs in experimental aquaponics and aquaculture systems
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe present thesis explores the potential role of the neglected microeukaryotic component of suspended microbial communities in experimental recirculating aquaculture and aquaponics systems by utilizing both microscopy-based and metagenomics-based approaches, while also highlighting the metabolic potential of the prokaryotic community through identifying key genes involved in the cycling of major nutrients. As global population increases there is a growing demand for food. Aquaculture production has recently surpassed the production of capture fisheries for the first time in history. Recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS) have shown promise as sustainable food production methods, especially when coupled with hydroponics set ups to form aquaponics systems. Aquaponics systems allow the simultaneous production of fish and edible plants with the benefits of minimal water usage, higher feed utilization efficiency and reduced environmental impact. Although such systems are not a new concept, their designs are undergoing constant optimization to offset their inherent drawbacks. In this context, particular interest has been shown in the bacterial communities of aquaponics biofilters (i.e., specialized compartments where prokaryotes are employed to carry out nitrification to maintain water quality), farmed fish intestines and to a lesser extent to the suspended bacterial communities in aquaponics tanks. However, the eukaryotic and archaeal fractions of microbial communities in such systems remain scarcely studied, despite playing a potentially critical part in shaping bacterial communities through predation or resource competition respectively. Furthermore, the focus on bacteria in RAS and aquaponics systems has been on nitrifying taxa, but there are other key metabolic functions such as nutrient cycling and organic matter degradation that remain unexplored. Natural abundances and growth rates of the main heterotrophic prokaryotic groups, Ciliophora (ciliates) and heterotrophic nanoflagellates (HNF), were measured using microscopic counts and in situ growth experiments after size fractionation of system water from different compartments of RAS and aquaponics systems. Natural abundances were found generally low, similar to those of rivers and oligotrophic to mesotrophic lakes. Growth rates in the aquaponics system were high, comparable to those in natural assemblages or isolated cultures. Fish tank environment allowed faster ciliate and HNF growth compared to drain tanks where water is collected after plant fertigation. Based on microscopic counts and observations, ciliate genera such as Cyclidium, Halteria, Paramecium, Litonotus, Vorticella and Euplotes were the most observed, while Oxytricha, Stylonychia and Stentor were the most abundant genera according to metagenomics sequence counts. The need for employing both methods to complement each other was also evident in other microbial groups such as amoebae which were clearly observed and identified under the microscope but not detected through metagenomics. Meanwhile, ciliate and HNF abundance was lower in the artificial seawater RAS and both populations declined during the incubation. Thus, it is implied that heterotrophic protists may be more influential over prokaryotic communities in aquaponics and less relevant in the constantly flowing, turbulent water of artificial seawater RAS.Several observations using both metagenomics and microscopy derived data indicated that fish tanks and drain tanks constituted two major niches in the aquaponics systems. Specifically, drain tanks contained an increased abundance of autotrophic groups such as diatoms (e.g., Fragilariopsis) and algae (e.g., Chlorella) likely due to higher sunlight and nutrient availability, as well as amoebae (e.g., Euglypha) and rotifers (e.g., Lecane). Drain tanks also harbored higher richness of bacterial and archaeal genera whereas fish tank microeukaryotic communities were more diverse. Furthermore, although archaeal nitrifying genera were present in all aquaponics compartments, archaeal nitrification genes were mainly present in drain tanks, likely due to the higher ammonia concentration and the presence of sludge providing them better growth conditions. Overall, NMDS and clustering analyses indicated that microeukaryotic and archaeal communities were shaped by compartment type, whereas bacterial communities were more distinct between different aquaponics systems regardless of compartment type. In fact, different bacterial genera were dominant in tomato and cucumber growing systems, with Flavobacterium and Limnohabitans being more abundant in the former and Polynucleobacter and Mycobacterium being more abundant in the latter system. Another system-wide difference was the presence of methanotrophic genera only in the samples of the parsley growing system. In terms of relevant microeukaryotic genera in aquaponics, the presence of Oxytricha, Stylonychia and Stentor in high relative abundance indicates healthy microbial community composition. In addition, both pathogen-containing genera such as Aphanomyces and Phytophthora (Oomycota) and potentially beneficial taxa for fish and plant growth such as Aspergillus (Ascomycota) and Chlorella (Chlorophyta) were detected. The identification of key prokaryotic genes involved in sulfur oxidation suggested the presence of sulfur oxidizing bacteria throughout the aquaponics systems. Carbohydrate degradation gene abundance seemed to reflect the increasing content of plant based organic matter in fish feed. Another key observation was the presence of genes responsible for anaerobic ammonia oxidation (anammox) in the mature aquaponics communities, with the implication that anammox may take place in other aquaponics compartments apart from specialized anaerobic bioreactors. The relative abundance of bacterial nitrification genes peaked in the mature communities in all systems, whereas archaeal nitrification genes were abundant in the drain tanks of the tomato growing system. In the artificial seawater RAS, ammonia oxidizing archaea dominated archaeal communities alongside methanogens, although no archaeal nitrifying genes were detected, highlighting the need for more complete genomic databases going forward with archaeal research. In addition, the RAS fish tank biofilm community was more enriched in nutrient cycling and organic matter degradation genes, as well as harboring a higher microeukaryotic diversity, implying it may serve as a hotspot for ecological processes in RAS. Several Ascomycota genera were among the dominant microeukaryotic groups in RAS fish tank water, biofilm and biofilter and may be a potential candidate for future RAS research.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- University of Ioannina
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Moschos, Stefanos
- Μόσχος, Στέφανος
Subjects
dc:subject × 20Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/61560