National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Evaluation of perceived facial appearance outcomes of orthodontic treatment alone versus combined orthodontic-orthognathic treatment in patients with convex profile and class II division 1 malocclusion
Abstract
dc:descriptionFacial appearance plays a central role in social interaction, psychological well-being, and quality of life, exerting a measurable influence on personal relationships, professional opportunities, and self-perception. Within this context, facial attractiveness constitutes a major motivating factor for individuals seeking orthodontic and orthognathic treatment. Among the various dentofacial configurations, the convex facial profile, most commonly associated with Class II Division 1 malocclusion, represents one of the most prevalent and aesthetically impactful conditions encountered in orthodontic practice. Patients with a convex profile frequently report dissatisfaction with their facial appearance, particularly related to mandibular retrusion, lip imbalance, and excessive sagittal convexity, often considering these concerns more significant than any associated functional impairments. Consequently, improvement of facial aesthetics has become a primary objective of contemporary orthodontic and orthognathic treatment, alongside the achievement of functional occlusion. In non-growing patients with Class II Division 1 malocclusion and a convex profile, two main therapeutic strategies are typically considered: orthodontic camouflage and combined orthodontic–orthognathic surgical treatment. Orthodontic camouflage seeks to mask the underlying skeletal discrepancy through dentoalveolar compensations, while orthognathic surgery aims to correct the skeletal imbalance directly, usually through mandibular advancement, maxillary repositioning, or bimaxillary procedures. Despite clear theoretical distinctions between these approaches, the choice between them remains a persistent clinical dilemma. This is largely due to limited and conflicting empirical evidence regarding how each treatment modality affects facial attractiveness as perceived not only by clinicians, but also by patients and the general population. Importantly, the true impact of treatment extends beyond measurable skeletal or dental changes and is ultimately determined by how these changes are perceived in everyday social contexts. The overarching aim of this PhD thesis was to investigate whether, and to what extent, objective therapeutic changes in the facial soft tissues of adult patients with Class II Division 1 malocclusion and a convex profile are perceived as positive or negative aesthetic outcomes by different groups of observers. Specifically, the thesis sought to compare orthodontic camouflage and combined orthodontic–orthognathic surgical treatment in terms of perceived changes in facial attractiveness, to explore the influence of facial viewpoint (profile versus combined frontal and profile views), to assess the moderating role of baseline facial attractiveness, and to examine the relationship between profile attractiveness and overall facial attractiveness. To address these aims, a series of observational and perceptual studies were conducted using real patient data. Standardized pre- and post-treatment facial photographs were obtained from consecutively treated adult patients with Class II Division 1 malocclusion and a convex facial profile. Strict inclusion criteria were applied to ensure homogeneity with respect to skeletal pattern, dental characteristics, growth status, treatment completion, and absence of confounding aesthetic interventions. Facial photographs were carefully processed to standardize background, size, brightness, and contrast, while eliminating extraneous features that could bias aesthetic judgments. Perceived changes in facial attractiveness were evaluated using validated visual analogue scale (VAS) questionnaires. Rather than assessing isolated pre- and post-treatment images independently, raters were asked to judge paired photographs simultaneously, focusing on the perceived change in facial appearance. This approach was designed to better reflect real-life perception while controlling for secondary factors such as hair, skin tone, or lighting conditions. Multiple facial regions, including the overall face, lower face, lips, and chin, were assessed, allowing both global and regional analysis of aesthetic change. A key strength of the thesis lies in the inclusion of diverse rater groups, reflecting different perspectives relevant to treatment outcomes. These groups included orthodontists, oral and maxillofacial surgeons, patients with convex facial profiles, and laypeople from the general population. This design enabled evaluation of interrater agreement, identification of systematic differences between professional and non-professional observers, and assessment of how societal perception aligns with clinical judgment. Across the studies, interrater agreement was found to be good to excellent, indicating that perceived changes in facial attractiveness were judged consistently across different observer groups. This finding supports the robustness and validity of the perceptual assessment methodology. The results consistently demonstrated that orthodontic camouflage treatment led to only minor positive changes in facial profile appearance, which were often close to perceptual neutrality. In contrast, combined orthodontic–orthognathic surgical treatment produced substantial and clearly perceptible improvements in facial attractiveness. These improvements were evident across all assessed facial regions, with particularly pronounced effects in the lower face and chin, highlighting the central role of mandibular position in overall facial harmony. Importantly, these differences were not limited to professional observers. Patients and laypeople, arguably the most relevant judges in terms of real-world social impact, also perceived significantly greater aesthetic benefits following orthognathic surgery compared to orthodontic camouflage. Although orthodontists and surgeons tended to rate changes slightly more positively than non-specialists, the overall pattern of results was remarkably consistent across rater groups. This underscores the clinical relevance of the findings and confirms that the aesthetic benefits of surgery have a substantial impact on the perception of facial appearance. Further analyses explored the influence of facial viewpoint on aesthetic judgment. The findings demonstrated that the simultaneous presentation of frontal and profile photographs did not meaningfully affect the perceived treatment effect, reinforcing the robustness of the results obtained from the isolated presentation of profile photographs. Additionally, the thesis demonstrated that baseline facial attractiveness moderates perceived treatment outcome: patients with lower initial attractiveness tended to exhibit greater perceived improvement, particularly following surgical treatment. This highlights the importance of individualized treatment planning and realistic expectation management. The relationship between profile attractiveness and overall facial attractiveness was also examined, revealing that while the profile plays a significant role, it does not fully determine overall facial appeal. This finding challenges overly profile-centric approaches to diagnosis and outcome assessment and supports the use of comprehensive facial evaluation in both clinical practice and research. In conclusion, this PhD thesis provides strong, methodologically robust evidence that combined orthodontic–orthognathic surgical treatment offers substantially greater perceived aesthetic benefits than orthodontic camouflage in adult patients with Class II Division 1 malocclusion and a convex facial profile. These benefits are consistently recognized by clinicians, patients, and laypeople alike. The findings emphasize that treatment success should be evaluated not only through objective morphometric measures but also through perceived outcomes that reflect real-life social impact. By integrating multiple viewpoints, facial perspectives, and moderating factors, this work contributes a comprehensive framework for understanding and optimizing aesthetic outcomes in the treatment of convex facial profiles. The results have direct implications for evidence-based clinical decision-making, patient counseling, and the ethical presentation of treatment options, ultimately supporting more informed, patient-centered care.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
- Year dc:date
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Psomiadis, Symeon
- Ψωμιάδης, Συμεών
Subjects
dc:subject × 16- Αξιολόγηση θεραπευτικού αποτελέσματος
- Ελκυστικότητα προσώπου
- Κυρτό προφίλ
- Ορθογναθική Χειρουργική
- Ορθοδοντική
- Patient outcome assessment
- Facial attractiveness
- Convex profile
- Orthognathic Surgery
- Orthodontics
- Κλινική Ιατρική
- Ιατρική και Επιστήμες Υγείας
- Οδοντιατρική, Γναθοπροσωπική χειρουργική και Στοματολογία
- Clinical Medicine
- Medical and Health Sciences
- Dentistry, Oral Surgery and Medicine
Rights
- Language dc:language
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- 10.12681/eadd/61601